What a snowman in Saudi Arabia has to do with the Charlie Hebdo cartoons

Snow is rare in Saudi Arabia so when freezing temperatures resulted in snow falling many used the opportunity to build things, including snowmen and even a snow camel. However, a cleric responding to a question after the event said building replicas of living things is not allowed.

The instruction to not build snowmen is based on the same religious teachings that don’t allow for images of the prophet Mohammed.

In the teachings used alongside the Quran, there is a Hadith which warns that statues and images of living things could lead to idol worship. As there is only one God in Islam, worshipping idols is not allowed and so neither is the creation of objects that could become idols.

This is the basis for banning all representations of living things in Islam. It is also why shapes, patterns and writing features so prominently in Islamic art and decoration. Given the importance of Mohammed to Islam, creating an image of him is even more problematic.

But then it gets complicated. There are images of Mohammed that have been created throughout history both by followers of Islam and those that are not. Sometimes he has been depicted with his face covered by a veil or as a flame-like halo. One reason for the variation is that Sunni Muslims and Shia Muslims differ on how strictly this needs to be applied. Sunni Muslims make up the majority of Muslims and are most spread out geographically which means the most Muslim communities would not want any images of Mohammed to be published.

The further aggravating factor is that the occasions most recently when depictions have been published, they have also been negative. The combination of these three factors has drawn anger and criticism from Muslims and the response certainly from people who don’t accept or understand why it is an issue has been further antagonism.

This is an element of a larger issue about how Islamic communities respond to the measures various countries have taken against Middle East countries under the banner of combatting terrorism even though significant civilian casualties have not succeeded. Some may argue it has sustained or even increased the chance for future terrorist acts.

This is not intended to resolve the debate about freedom of expression, justify the beliefs of Islam or comment on how to combat terrorism. It is hopefully a first step in inviting further reading and discussion about a complex subject.

Sources: Snow Story http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/01/12/us-odd-saudi-snow-idUSKBN0KL15N20150112

Snow Picture credit http://gulfnews.com/news/gulf/saudi-arabia/saudi-fatwa-banning-snowmen-triggers-heated-debate-1.1439821

Wiki entry on images of Mohammed http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DepictionsofMuhammad

A piece on the “ban” of images of Mohammed following the Danish cartoons publication http://www.faithstreet.com/onfaith/2010/05/06/why-islam-does-not-ban-images-of-the-prophet/2383

Hadiths http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadith

An imam responds to questions about the depiction of Mohammed http://o.canada.com/news/charlie-hebdo-depictions-of-prophet-muhammad-574875


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Doomsday weapons, a deterrent or a real threat?

Doomsday weapons, a deterrent or a real threat?

The World is both safer and more dangerous than it has ever been and these weapons could end human life on the planet.

It's called the web. Is it any surprise we got caught in it?

It's called the web. Is it any surprise we got caught in it?

The World Wide Web is 25 years old. What was supposed to connect us has become more like a trap and we all helped it happen.

Humanity 2.0: Tech is driving our evolution

Humanity 2.0: Tech is driving our evolution

Technology is becoming the driver of human evolution. It took another step forward this month.

Space weather: sunny with a chance of destruction

Space weather: sunny with a chance of destruction

Solar activity could result in a rare and improbable event which could send civilisation back to the dark ages.

Peak disruption - is the internet revolution almost over?

Peak disruption - is the internet revolution almost over?

The likelihood of seeing a new Alphabet or Alibaba in the next decade is declining.

The world may soon have only one time zone (and a new calender)

The world may soon have only one time zone (and a new calender)

You may think that the time and date is unchanging, but it does change, and it might do so again.

Popular articles
To get her money's worth, woman wears her wedding dress for entire year

To get her money's worth, woman wears her wedding dress for entire year

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

Land Claims Court ruling: 'Jubilation when judgment was handed down'

Land Claims Court ruling: 'Jubilation when judgment was handed down'

Association of Rural Advancement director Laurel Oettle praises ruling by ConCourt to uphold move to appoint a special master.

[WATCH] Ndlovu Youth Choir shine once again with latest AGT performance

[WATCH] Ndlovu Youth Choir shine once again with latest AGT performance

The inspiring South African choirU2's Beautiful Day at America's Got Talent quarter-finals.

Trevor Noah – 4th highest paid comedian on Earth – made R430 million in 2018

Trevor Noah – 4th highest paid comedian on Earth – made R430 million in 2018

Trevor Noah cracked Forbes magazine’s list of highest-paid stand-up comedians in the world.

SA’s richest woman opens up about being a refugee and becoming a billionaire

SA’s richest woman opens up about being a refugee and becoming a billionaire

Magda Wierzycka – Sygnia’s renegade CEO – on her attitude toward money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.).

Former EFF MP: 'I didn't know where the money came from until it was leaked'

Former EFF MP: 'I didn't know where the money came from until it was leaked'

EFF member Tebogo Mokwele and Small Business Development Minister Khumbudzo Ntshavheni respond to leaked CR17 bank statements.

'Aarto Amendment Act takes away right to be tried before an ordinary court'

'Aarto Amendment Act takes away right to be tried before an ordinary court'

Justice Project South Africa chairperson Howard Dembovsky explains what the new bill will mean to motorists.

'I get anxious when people talk to me about money'

'I get anxious when people talk to me about money'

Bruce Whitfield interviews comedian Anne Hirsch about her attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.).

[WATCH] Father and daughter dance-off changes tune when she starts twerking

[WATCH] Father and daughter dance-off changes tune when she starts twerking

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.