Zapiro takes on critic Eusebius McKaiser over organ grinder monkey cartoon

Zapiro's cartoon depicting NPA boss, Shaun Abrahams, as an organ grinder's monkey has caused much public criticism, with accusations of racism being shouted from many quarters.

One such critic who made his voice hears is political commentator Eusebius McKaiser.

Zapiro responded saying he would debate McKaiser anywhere, anytime.

They both join Stephen Grootes on the line to air their views about the controversial cartoon.

Eusebius McKaiser made his view clear about the racist tropes that underlies the use of a monkey image.

There is a long history of black people depicted the world over, in anti-black and racist societies, as sub-human, and often the comparison is with monkeys, as Penny Sparrow so viciously reminded us at the beginning of the year.

Eusebius McKaiser, political commentator

McKaiser adds that the fact that Zapiro has used the organ grinder musician analogy, does not excuse him.

He (Zapiro) knows the context. He prides himself on his anti-apartheid credentials, so in our context, he ought to have been aware.

Eusebius McKaiser, political commentator

Mckaiser says that, aside from the racist connotation, the depiction of the organ grinder monkey lets Shaun Abrahams off the hook and is in his view instrumentally a bad analogy.

Zapiro disagrees with this last criticism.

I disagree that it lets Shaun Abrahams off the hook. I think it makes a clear political point.

Zapiro, satirist and cartoonist

But on the main criticism of a monkey having racist connotations, Zapiro concedes that he will need to take stock of where we are at the moment in our society.

What I thought I could do, I couldn't. I went in eyes open. Where I completely agree with (McKaiser) is the understanding of what that racist trope is.

Zapiro, satirist and cartoonist

I don't feel I am coming from a racist perspective. That is the last thing I would ever do.

Zapiro, satirist and cartoonist

But he agrees that the political intent of the analogy misfired. he says too many people he respects have criticised it for him not to feel the cartoon succeeded. He says he realises in the context of racially polarised South Africa, it was a step too far.

He says he has always striven to be edgy and there are no sacred cows.

Now I need to reassess, not about how hard hitting I can be, but certain things are too difficult to explain in the way I want to explain them.

Zapiro, satirist and cartoonist
Read More
Star Wars stands to make a killing from new release

Star Wars stands to make a killing from new release

A new Star Wars movie, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, is due to be released worldwide on December 16.

Former Safa president to consult legal team on Fifa ban

Former Safa president to consult legal team on Fifa ban

Kirsten Nematandani, banned for match-fixing, believes he was never given an opportunity to present his side of the story.

Zim allows citizens to use rand currency through cellphone service

Zim allows citizens to use rand currency through cellphone service

Zimbabwe adopts Econet rand wallet facility to help country's cash woes.

New Unisa chancellor Thabo Mbeki has African renaissance vision - advisor

New Unisa chancellor Thabo Mbeki has African renaissance vision - advisor

Somadoda Fikeni says he doesn't think Mbeki's controversial tenure and past decisions will impact negatively on institution.

Former MPs Willie Hofmeyer, Tony Leon recall Constitution signing 20 years on

Former MPs Willie Hofmeyer, Tony Leon recall Constitution signing 20 years on

In December 1996 the SA Constitution was signed into being and has been acclaimed as one of most progressive in the world.

BED's decision on math pass level has been misunderstood - Mary Metcalfe

BED's decision on math pass level has been misunderstood - Mary Metcalfe

BED decision applies only to learners who have passed all other subjects and will continue only with maths literacy.