Business Unusual

The Sharing Economy has a discrimination problem, who will fix it?

When a guesthouse owner discriminates on who may use their accommodation, the law takes over, but what happens when someone renting out their private home on a platform like Airbnb refuses for the same reason?

The sharing economy offers the opportunity for many to get involved, but discrimination is a big threat. Could technology overcome prejudices or does this represent a major flaw in the entire system?

While there are many platforms that have been created, the best known are the home rental platform Airbnb and taxi service Uber.

Both exist to make it easy for someone to earn revenue from someone that would like to use something for a short period.

The system’s biggest innovation was a rating system for both parties.

The rating is excellent for those that actually use the service and fosters trust - if not enforce good behaviour - to ensure your rating does not see you being overlooked by the next potential user. Trust has always been a significant human behaviour indicator and it is likely to become more important as we engage in non-personal ways online with brands and others.

But the rating can be affected by prejudice. That is first issue.

The second is that it does not work at all on the occasions that the service is declined.

Declining someone with a low rating makes sense assuming that the rating was justified. However, there are no rules for how to rate someone. It is possible that the rating - especially if there are only a few - was based on prejudice.

Airbnb is currently dealing with a growing number of incidents where those looking to book on the platform are being refused not because of their rating, but their race.

#AirbnbWhileBlack is a current trend following a campaign by NGO Share Better to highlight the issue. Airbnb has undertaken to address the issue with hosts and staff but are only expected to have a formal intervention in place by September.

If they succeed in overcoming the discrimination using technology, it may prove useful for other platforms.

What could they do?

The single largest improvement with web based interactions is the collection and processing of vast amounts of data. It was this data that allowed a Harvard study to determine that discrimination is real. Using the data to highlight discrimination and initiate a process would be better than waiting for a complaint to be filed and should lower the number of incidences.

Uber allows drivers to refuse a ride, but limits the number they may refuse in a shift to ensure as many people are served as needed. The company recently settled a lawsuit with the US National Federation of the Blind as Uber drivers had been refusing to transport the guide dogs of blind passengers.

It might seem easiest to remove the elements that may identify race like pictures and names, which has been suggested.

If a host was allowed only a certain number of declines, it might nudge those with bias to see that the prejudice was unfounded without needing a rule requiring you to accept a booking like a registered hotel would. The platforms would not like to implement something that would see hosts abandon it.

You could start a new platform. Innclusive and Noirbnb are yet to launch but hope to compete by being focused on giving all access.

Could it go further though? Some of the worst prejudice can be found on social networks. Might a tech solution help make humanity less discriminating?

Analysing what people post on Twitter and Facebook post could trigger a suggestion or a requirement to take an implicit association test to demonstrate the user's underlying bias. Blocking those with high ratings would lower the incidence of inflammatory posts.

Unfortunately the attempts to determine if diversity interventions work don’t suggest they do. We can, at least, begin with understanding that prejudice is real and more of a hindrance than a help.

702 welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the 702 community a safe and welcoming space for all.

702 reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

702 is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Humans will be returning to the moon, but how will they be fed?

Humans will be returning to the moon, but how will they be fed?

The space race has typically focused on the massive rockets needed to get there, now we need to ensure there is enough to eat.

Defining the Earth we hope to see in 2050

Defining the Earth we hope to see in 2050

Asking what the world will look like in 30 years allows us to start doing what is needed to achieve it.

Bitcoin, Uber and GoPro - how the mighty are challenged - Part 3

Bitcoin, Uber and GoPro - how the mighty are challenged - Part 3

Becoming a world disrupting new technology is not the end of the journey, it may not even be the hardest part.

Bitcoin, Uber and GoPro - how the mighty are challenged - Part 2

Bitcoin, Uber and GoPro - how the mighty are challenged - Part 2

Becoming a world disrupting new technology is not the end of the journey, it may not even be the hardest part.

Bitcoin, Uber and GoPro - how the mighty are challenged - Part 1

Bitcoin, Uber and GoPro - how the mighty are challenged - Part 1

Becoming a world disrupting new technology is not the end of the journey, it may not even be the hardest part.

Are retail shops only going to get smaller now?

Are retail shops only going to get smaller now?

How advances in online retail and delivery options will begin to change the size and nature of physical shops.

Popular articles
Opinion: Laying equal blame on parents in Spur spat is wrong says Eusebius

Opinion: Laying equal blame on parents in Spur spat is wrong says Eusebius

He believes it's a moral cop-out to say the only thing going on in the video is two adults behaving badly in front of the kids.

[LISTEN] Eldorado Park activist's eyewitness account of fatal mob attack

[LISTEN] Eldorado Park activist's eyewitness account of fatal mob attack

Community Activist Dereleen James says there has been a surge of drug related crimes in the area, leading to a series of deaths.

Is Uber dying? Stuff’s editor explains…

Is Uber dying? Stuff’s editor explains…

High ranking employees are resigning en masse as crisis upon crisis pummel lossmaking Uber.

Spur CEO: Man's pic will be up at restaurants and he is not welcome

Spur CEO: Man's pic will be up at restaurants and he is not welcome

Spur CEO says staff aren't equipped for this kind of customer confrontation and he will consider reviewing their training manual.

WATCH: Spur bans man after heated spat caught on camera

WATCH: Spur bans man after heated spat caught on camera

A man has been banned from Spur after threatening a woman during a heated argument which was captured on video and has gone viral.

Spur tightens its belt as 'two for the price of one' Monday burger special ends

Spur tightens its belt as 'two for the price of one' Monday burger special ends

The CEO of Spur says food inflation has played a big role in making this difficult decision.

3 JSE shares you should invest right now (by Momentum)

3 JSE shares you should invest right now (by Momentum)

Looking for a hot tip, or three? Here’s what Momentum Head of Investments and Savings Steven Schultz is buying...

He was a loving family man - Joe Mafela’s niece

He was a loving family man - Joe Mafela’s niece

Legendary actor, Joe Mafela popularly known as Sdumo passed away on Saturday following a car accident.

Earn peanuts? How to best invest very small amounts...

Earn peanuts? How to best invest very small amounts...

Got a spare R200 or R300 a month? Here’s how to make that money work hard and grow…