Is the Supreme Court of Appeal the next route for the State in Pistorius matter?

Judge Thokozile Masipa rejected an application by the State to appeal against Oscar Pistorius’ 6-year murder sentence. EWN reporter Gia Nicolaides joins The Midday Report's Stephen Grootes on the line.

She says the judge considered the arguments, but does not believe another court would come to a different conclusion. She says prosecutor Gerrie Nel argued the court misdirected itself when it was looking at the judgments. Nel also felt Judge Masipa was too sympathetic towards Oscar Pistorius's personal circumstances.

Nel argues 6 years in prison is far too lenient, bearing in mind the minimum sentence for murder is 15 years.

Advocate Barry Roux disagreed, saying Oscar has been punished over and over again and if one tallies up the time spent in jail already and under house arrest it comes to an effective 8 years.

After a couple of hours deliberation, Judge Masipa returned and dismissed the application with costs.

Nicolaides says the prosecution does have the option to petition the Supreme Court of Appeal in Bloemfontein, to try and get a different outcome.

However Nel was not prepared to speak to the media at this stage about their plans.


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
[WATCH] Pepper the robot first non-human to face questions in UK Parliament

[WATCH] Pepper the robot first non-human to face questions in UK Parliament

The robot gave testimony at an education special committee in the House of Commons and caused some amusement.

Kensington Palace announces Harry and Meghan are expecting a baby

Kensington Palace announces Harry and Meghan are expecting a baby

The couple who are on tour in Australia, New Zealand, Fiji and Tonga are due to have a baby in the UK spring.

[WATCH] SA prison warder appears drunk and can't even find his gun

[WATCH] SA prison warder appears drunk and can't even find his gun

A superior officer films this prison warder who staggers to his feet in a seemingly inebriated state.

[LISTEN] South African victim of Catholic sex scandal opens up about his abuse

[LISTEN] South African victim of Catholic sex scandal opens up about his abuse

William Segodisho says he suffered sexual abuse at the hands of a Catholic priest who took him under his wing as a teenager.

[WATCH] Heavily armed private security escort man to rumoured tender meeting

[WATCH] Heavily armed private security escort man to rumoured tender meeting

A man was caught on video walking to a tender meeting in KZN flanked by armed security guards in military-style uniforms.

Tanzania's Jokate Mwegelo on inspiring Africa's youth

Tanzania's Jokate Mwegelo on inspiring Africa's youth

Radio personality Lee Kasumba chats to Tanzanian actress, entrepreneur and regional district commissioner on Africa State of Mind.

Popular articles
'Sars eFiling is stable, at the moment'

'Sars eFiling is stable, at the moment'

Testimonies at the Sars Inquiry has many South African taxpayers panicked. Bruce Whitfield interviews Sars' Mark Kingon.

Callers rally behind Zondi, question support for Omotoso at the trial

Callers rally behind Zondi, question support for Omotoso at the trial

Callers on The Eusebius McKaiser Show with Sizwe Mpofu-Walsh discuss the Omotoso Trial.

Questions raised over line of questioning at Omotoso trial

Questions raised over line of questioning at Omotoso trial

James Grant says he thinks that it may be time to re-look how the law works in terms of dealing with rape victims.

[WATCH] A golden buzzer for South African trio on talent show

[WATCH] A golden buzzer for South African trio on talent show

Khabazela shares some of the most popular tweets, posts, and videos on 'What's gone viral'.

'The EFF seems to be trying to find scapegoats'

'The EFF seems to be trying to find scapegoats'

Deputy Editor at Financial Mail, Sikhonathi Mantshantsha, seems to be finding excuses as to why its leaders are in trouble.

Support for #CherlyZondi as she wraps up her testimony against Tim Omotoso

Support for #CherlyZondi as she wraps up her testimony against Tim Omotoso

Wits Institute For Social Economic Research research associate Lisa Vetten looks at how witnesses cope on the witness stand.

Sanral considers new measures to 'aggressively' tackle Gauteng e-toll defaulters

Sanral considers new measures to 'aggressively' tackle Gauteng e-toll defaulters

Discussions between Sanral, and the Ministers of Finance and Transport have apparently reached an advanced stage.