Is criticism levelled against African Union within reason?

The African Union has over the years come under increased criticism, with commentators labelling it a "toothless" organisation.

Naysayers have lamented the continental body's track record in poor conflict resolution, weak democratisation efforts and human rights concerns.

702/Cape Talk's Eusebius McKaiser (standing in for Redi Tlhabi) spoke to political analyst Prince Mashele and former diplomat Tom Weiler regarding the matter.

Listen to the conversation below:

Mashele said there's little evidence suggesting any effectiveness of the AU according to its own mandate. He said political instability in Zimbabwe, Democratic Republic of Congo, Burundi and Rwanda are examples of ongoing governance challenges.

Inter-governmental organisations by their very nature are held hostage to national interests of member states. The AU is not an exception, the UN suffers the same problem, the EU is in turmoil because of the same problem.

Prince Mashele, political analyst

Wieler said that the AU has done well in coordinating talks between regional bodies (SADC, ECOWAS and EAC) as it's important for African leaders to talk.

If the member states choose a strong leader to replace her [Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma], perhaps then that person can turn the organisation around.

Tom Wieler, former diplomat

Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Is it wrong to call a white person 'mlungu'?

Is it wrong to call a white person 'mlungu'?

Callers debate if using the k-word should be criminalised and one caller says she felt offended being called mlungu.

'I didn't remove painful aspects of my history and retain only heroic stuff'

'I didn't remove painful aspects of my history and retain only heroic stuff'

Moe Shaik reflects on why he felt the need to write his memoir titled The ANC Spy Bible: Surviving across enemy lines.

[LISTEN] Sex is not limited to penetration

[LISTEN] Sex is not limited to penetration

Dr Eve talks about the expectation of penetration and how men who suffer from erectile problems can look at sexuality differently.

Budget appeased rating agencies but showdown looms with unions - Karima Brown

Budget appeased rating agencies but showdown looms with unions - Karima Brown

Eusebius McKaiser facilitates a conversation on Tito Mboweni's speech with different pundits.

'Maybe us as guys don't understand how bad gender-based violence is'

'Maybe us as guys don't understand how bad gender-based violence is'

Callers on the open line share stories of how women are living in fear in the country and how bad the situation is.

Women in the workplace: 'It's no longer a token gesture, it's about credentials'

Women in the workplace: 'It's no longer a token gesture, it's about credentials'

Executive coach Dawn Klatzo joins Eusebius McKaiser in studio to unpack continued underrepresentation of women in the workplace.

Popular articles
BE WARNED: Heavy traffic set to hit Nasrec on Saturday due to derby, festival

BE WARNED: Heavy traffic set to hit Nasrec on Saturday due to derby, festival

Johannesburg Metro Police's Wayne Minnar suggests alternate routes for music festival goers and soccer fans.

'SA is certainly one of best prepared countries in our region for coronavirus'

'SA is certainly one of best prepared countries in our region for coronavirus'

South African Health Products Authority chairperson Helen Rees they have done their best to train healthcare professionals.

EFF reach Megwatt Park despite heavy downpours

EFF reach Megwatt Park despite heavy downpours

Eyewitness News Edwin Ntshidi says members of the Economic Freedom Fighters were to hand over their memorandum.

[VIDEOs] Heavy rains cause havoc on roads

[VIDEOs] Heavy rains cause havoc on roads

Motorists share videos on Twitter about heavy traffic and floods on the roads.

[WATCH] The Soil back in studio and working on new music

[WATCH] The Soil back in studio and working on new music

Two members of the group joined Azania Mosaka for this week's 702 Unplugged ahead of their concert at Silverstar Casino Ballroom.

Pearl Thusi: The fact that we are in charge of the narrative is very important

Pearl Thusi: The fact that we are in charge of the narrative is very important

The actress says what is really powerful for her about the new show 'Queen Sono' is that the entire ark is driven by women.

SA citizens repatriation: 'We have no idea when Wuhan lockdown will be lifted'

SA citizens repatriation: 'We have no idea when Wuhan lockdown will be lifted'

Department of Health acting director-general Dr Anban Pillay explains why it was necessary to have South Africans returned.

Mandisa Mashego cagey on her talks with EFF leadership over 'internal matters'

Mandisa Mashego cagey on her talks with EFF leadership over 'internal matters'

The Economic Freedom Fighters’ (EFF) Gauteng chairperson Mandisa Mashego was reacting reports and speculation that she had recently resigned as the party's Gauteng chairperson over tensions within the party.

 Adam Catzavelos hit with R50k fine for racist remarks

Adam Catzavelos hit with R50k fine for racist remarks

Should he commit another crimen injuria crime, Catzavelos would need to pay the fine or go to jail.

[LISTEN] Sex is not limited to penetration

[LISTEN] Sex is not limited to penetration

Dr Eve talks about the expectation of penetration and how men who suffer from erectile problems can look at sexuality differently.