Forced removals and evictions could create a cycle of illegal squatting in SA

Recent evictions across the country have once again called into question the practice of forced removals and the issue of access to adequate housing in South Africa.

Stuart Wilson, Executive Director of the Socio-Economic Rights Institute of South Africa (SERI), says that we need to change our perspective when considering illegal squatters across the country.

It’s no good to berate people as land invaders. That’s not the way to frame the issue. The way to frame issue is this massive need for land that simply isn't being met, despite the best efforts of many organs of state.

Although the government has invested in subsidised housing programmes, many South Africans can't afford adequate housing and face the on-going risk of eviction by occupying backyard dwellings, informal settlements and "slum buildings".

In the inner city of Joburg alone, about half of the people living there can’t afford market-related rent.

Four facts that may put illegal land occupation into perspective, according to Wilson:

  • 80 percent of the population was confined to 20 percent of the land during apartheid
  • Between 1994 and 2004 a million people were evicted from commercial farm land in the country
  • Urban migration is at a rate of two percent a year in South Africa
  • In 2014 unemployment was the highest ever since the end of Apartheid

Marlboro forced removals. Image courtesy of Eyewitness News.

A vicious cycle of illegal occupation

The forced removals in one place means unlawful occupation somewhere else, unless the state provides accommodation. Temporary settlements tend to turn into permanent housing for lack of a sustainable plan by the state to keep them temporary.

Stuart Wilson

The Informal Settlement Network's (ISN) Sipho Vanga says that the latest Marlboro Gardens evictees are scattered all over. He says some are sleeping outside while others have occupied warehouses.

Vanga says that ISN is trying to identify land in the municipality and is attempting to get a tented temporary accommodation for the vulnerable evictees.

Temporary housing tends to become permanent

In 2012 Marlboro residents were also forcibly removed and some are still without accommodation, despite a ruling by the Constitutional Court for the Department of Human Settlement to offer alternative housing.

Until today, some of them are still squatting in old buildings and we are afraid as ISN that they will be evicted again.

Joseph in Diepsloot told CapeTalk/702's Africa Melane that he was forcibly removed in 2007 in Dainfern and has been living in temporary accommodation since. Lwandle evictee Nomapheli Pupu says that new occupiers are making living conditions difficult in the relocation area, Siyanyazela.

Watch the EWN video covering the current living conditions of evictees in Blikkiesdorp, which was intended as temporary settlement for those evicted from various township dwellings in Cape Town since 2007.

Lwandle forced removals. Image courtesy of Eyewitness News.

Recent cases of forced removals

Marlboro

Last week, in Marlboro, Gauteng, a group of people who had been previously evicted from a low cost housing project they had occupied illegally in Alexandra were to be forcibly removed from their current place of occupation at the local stadium.

According to the city of Joburg they had been served eviction notices almost three weeks ago and they had no other choice to remove the group because the stadium is not an ideal place for people to live.

Watch the EWN video covering the latest Marlboro evictions.

Lwandle

Hundreds of shack dwellers from Lwandle, in Strand just outside of Cape Town, were evicted last year. The construction of alternative accommodation for those evicted has now ceased, and left dozens of evictees homeless according to reports by GroundUp.

Watch the EWN video covering the Lwandle forced removals.

Housing as a human right

According to Wilson, the Constitutional Court has previously ruled that evictions that lead to homelessness are generally unlawful, yet evictions still take place without alternative accommodation or long term solutions in place. Poor people are often unable to challenge court orders because they do not have access to legal representation.

Listen to the full conversation with CapeTalk/702's Africa Melane below:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Is Cyril Ramaphosa in control of both state and ANC? Pundits discuss

Is Cyril Ramaphosa in control of both state and ANC? Pundits discuss

Eusebius McKaiser facilitates a robust debate on the state of South African politics.

'Rica has not been thrown in the dustbin'

'Rica has not been thrown in the dustbin'

UJ Professor Jane Duncan and pundits weigh in on amaBhungane application in the High Court.

Manuel's comments were disrespectful to independence of judiciary - Eusebius

Manuel's comments were disrespectful to independence of judiciary - Eusebius

McKaiser shares his thoughts on Old Mutual board chair Trevor Manuel's comments on Moyo's high court ruling.

The new iPhone range is the 'Rolls Royce' of Apple phones - Aki Anastasiou

The new iPhone range is the 'Rolls Royce' of Apple phones - Aki Anastasiou

Tech Guru Aki reviews the latest iPhone 11, iPhone 11 Pro and the iPhone 11 Pro Max.

How to identify that you have trust issues and how to heal

How to identify that you have trust issues and how to heal

Clinical psychologist Ruth Ancer weighs in on why some people struggle with relying on others in relationships.

"We had nothing to do with the evictions" - Maboneng Precinct developers

"We had nothing to do with the evictions" - Maboneng Precinct developers

Housing MMC at the City of Johannesburg, says they are doing everything in their power to solve the situation at Jeppestown

Popular articles
[WATCH] Mzansi's Ndlovu Youth Choir's wows at AGT finale, voting is underway

[WATCH] Mzansi's Ndlovu Youth Choir's wows at AGT finale, voting is underway

South Africa waits with bated breath as the countdown to the winner of America's Got Talent begins.

[VIDEO] Driver goes to extreme lengths to avoid a ticket, takes cop for a ride

[VIDEO] Driver goes to extreme lengths to avoid a ticket, takes cop for a ride

Yusuf Abramjee shared this 'video as received' on Twitter and it is going viral.

10 unexpected things that most truly rich people have in common

10 unexpected things that most truly rich people have in common

Personal finance expert Warren Ingram on the money values that those "worth" R40 million or more almost invariably have in common.

Small business owner, nobody will save you!

Small business owner, nobody will save you!

There are no shortcuts. Beware of "White Knights and Silver Bullets", warns Aurik Business Accelerator founder Pavlo Phitidis.

Forensic investigator pokes holes in Watson death probe

Forensic investigator pokes holes in Watson death probe

The recent findings of a private pathologist ruled out suicide as the cause of death of the former Bosasa boss.

'My child went to an Afrikaans school'  Panyaza Lesufi says not 'anti-Afrikaans'

'My child went to an Afrikaans school' Panyaza Lesufi says not 'anti-Afrikaans'

Lesufi has been responding to the building of a new Afrikaans university in Pretoria by trade union Solidarity.

Panyaza Lesufi takes a swipe at private Afrikaans university under construction

Panyaza Lesufi takes a swipe at private Afrikaans university under construction

Gauteng Education MEC says there is no room in a non-racial South Africa for reminders of apartheid.

[WATCH] Man and woman assaulting a motorist goes viral, for the wrong reasons

[WATCH] Man and woman assaulting a motorist goes viral, for the wrong reasons

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.