Today's Big Stories

Madonsela report makes no adverse findings against Molefe - law expert

Public Law expert Cathy Powell says people are misinterpreting the fact that the state capture report made observations rather than concrete findings.

Eskom CEO Brian Molefe has announced his resignation, claiming the report's observations have harmfully damaged his and the power utility's reputation.

However, Powell says his reputation was harmed long before the release of the scathing report by Thuli Madonsela.

Madonsela was very careful in her observations not to make any adverse findings against any person.

Cathy Powell, Senior Lecturer in Public Law at UCT

She made several conclusions on the facts and she produces lots of evidence. I can see why Brian Molefe is upset.

Cathy Powell, Senior Lecturer in Public Law at UCT

Powell explains that Madonsela had legal reasons for why she acted quickly on the procedural compilation of report, which is divide into separate sections.

Powell says the report provides evidence that Eskom's dealings, particularity with the Optimum coal mine by the Gupta-owned Tegeta firm, did not benefit the parastatal in any way.

The report recommends that President Jacob Zuma appoint a judicial commission of inquiry into state capture within 30 days, headed by a judge solely selected by the Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng.

Therefore, Powell says that all the government officials, who claim to have their reputations damaged by the report, can defend themselves and present their evidence in open court.

At the same time, she says Zuma is grandstanding by lodging a complaint with the Public Protector's office over a leaked audio recording of his interview, transcribed in the report, with Madonsela.

Listen to the full analysis with Cathy Powell:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Madonsela report makes no adverse findings against Molefe - law expert


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Eskom boss Brian Molefe calls it quits

Eskom boss Brian Molefe calls it quits

In a statement, Eskom CEO Brian Molefe says he will leave Eskom on 1 January 2017.

Presidency chastises Madonsela for Zuma interview leak

Presidency chastises Madonsela for Zuma interview leak

Dr Bongani Ngqulunga says Madonsela should back off from the state capture report and making public statements about it.

Zuma lodges complaint over leaked state capture report audio

Zuma lodges complaint over leaked state capture report audio

The state capture report was released last week and eNCA has uploaded audio recordings of the interview with President Zuma.

Tweeps poke fun at Brian Molefe's #SaxonwoldShebeen

Tweeps poke fun at Brian Molefe's #SaxonwoldShebeen

As the weekend strikes, tweeps are scrambling to find the watering hole now referred to as Saxonwold's best kept secret.

ANC balance of power shifts to opposing faction to President's - Steven Friedman

ANC balance of power shifts to opposing faction to President's - Steven Friedman

Steven Friedman added his analysis to this week's events from state capture report, Eskom's CEO shedding a tear, and ANC future.

Eskom disputes Madonsela's findings

Eskom disputes Madonsela's findings

Day two of Eskom's press conference is underway in Johannesburg responding to Madonsela's findings in state capture report.

How your cellphone can be used to track your whereabouts

How your cellphone can be used to track your whereabouts

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Stuff Magazine Editor Craig Wilson.

Molefe makes light of evidence of Gupta visits ('There's a shebeen there…')

Molefe makes light of evidence of Gupta visits ('There's a shebeen there…')

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews EWN's Gia Nicolaides about the Eskom CEO’s response to the state capture report.

Molefe slams Madonsela for not allowing him to explain state capture allegations

Molefe slams Madonsela for not allowing him to explain state capture allegations

Public Protector's report reveals that Eskom made certain deals with the Guptas to benefit the family's companies.

Popular articles
Former air force sergeant Flippie Venter gets parole despite ex-wife objections

Former air force sergeant Flippie Venter gets parole despite ex-wife objections

Correctional Services spokesperson Singabakho Nxumalo says the board looks at a number of factors when it considers parole.

Law Reform Commission proposes mediation for family disputes

Law Reform Commission proposes mediation for family disputes

Clement Manyathela spoke to commissioner for the Law Reform Commission Prof Wesal Domingo to find out more.

 South African Union of Students calls for national shutdown of universities

South African Union of Students calls for national shutdown of universities

Secretary-general Lwandile Mtsolo says their engagements with the department was rejected by the Student Representative Councils.

[LISTEN] Understanding premenstrual syndrome and premenstrual dysphoric disorder

[LISTEN] Understanding premenstrual syndrome and premenstrual dysphoric disorder

Eusebius McKaiser speaks to specialist psychiatrist Dr Mashadi Motlana.

SAHRC visits Tembisa Hospital following death of 10 babies

SAHRC visits Tembisa Hospital following death of 10 babies

SAHRC Gauteng provincial manager Buang Jones they are hoping to establish the circumstances around the death of the babies.

'Mokgalapa will have to answer questions over leaked audio clip,' says Zille

'Mokgalapa will have to answer questions over leaked audio clip,' says Zille

DA fedex chair Helen Zille says the DA federal legal commission has found that there is a case to answer for Tshwane mayor.

Lesufi visits slain Laticia Jansen's family, demands answers from school

Lesufi visits slain Laticia Jansen's family, demands answers from school

Gauteng Education MEC wants Graceland Education Centre to say why this matter has handled the way that it was.

ANC and DA debate merits behind Gauteng MEC's suspension of top councillors

ANC and DA debate merits behind Gauteng MEC's suspension of top councillors

Kgosi Maepa and Solly Msimanga discuss legalities after Cogta MEC Lebogang Maile suspended Katlego Mathebe and Vasco da Gama.

It is silly for Bathabile Dlamini to call for chemical castration - Eusebius

It is silly for Bathabile Dlamini to call for chemical castration - Eusebius

The ANC Women's League president has called for harsher punishment and chemical castration for those found guilty of rape.

[WATCH] How do you want your book to end? Kevin Hart's speech goes viral

[WATCH] How do you want your book to end? Kevin Hart's speech goes viral

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.