The Friday Stand-In 2016

Protesting students did universities a favour, says UCT Law Dean

Professor Penny Andrews, the Dean of Law at UCT, was thrust into her new position this year as student revolt picked up again under Fees Must Fall "reloaded" and the Shackville housing protests at UCT.

While she has questioned their methods, Prof Andrews says that student activists have helped university management concentrate on the urgent issues that need to be addressed on campuses across the country.

The students did universities a big service and favour. They focused our minds on what needs to happen. Now we know.

Professor Penny Andrews, Dean of Law at UCT

At the same time Andrews has problematised the disruptive and destructive nature of the movement, which she says has trumped 'civility' with the rise of social media and anonymity.

I have been struck by outright rudeness, intolerance and bullying. A total disregard for another person's view point. What can you say when people engage in threatening conduct? Not only is it uncivil. It's unlawful.

Professor Penny Andrews, Dean of Law at UCT

The dean says that it is possible to debate and disagree without demonising other people's view points.

She advises that she was disappointed that not many difficult questions were confronted between the student body and staff while negotiating engaged decolonising learning and its economics.

Andrews emphasises the importance of transforming the curriculum (what it contains and how it is taught), as well as the existing hierarchy within teaching spaces .

A first-hand account

Meanwhile, student leader Virginia Takoana has testified to the exclusionary nature of the UCT law faculty and campus in general.

Takoana, a Zimbabwean national and vice president of the UCT law faculty's student council, says that students have been rightfully fighting for institutional and curriculum decolonisation.

She says many black people have not felt like they belong in the faculty and have felt a sense of being 'othered'.

The law faculty has been very much white in its operations. Most people didn't feel they fit in.

Virginia Takoana, vice president of the UCT law faculty's student council

You can't teach history as if you're teaching it in Europe when you have other African students that need to know their background.

Virginia Takoana, vice president of the UCT law faculty's student council

Friday Stand-In Judge Albie Sachs says it shouldn't be difficult to decolonise law as the Constitution is the product of African minds.

Together with Sachs, the pair discussed the effectiveness of peaceful protests, the disruption of final exams, stakeholder engagement and other protest tactics from this year.

Take a listen to the in-depth conversation:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Protesting students did universities a favour, says UCT Law Dean


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Sexual and romantic relationships between staff and students off limits at Wits

Sexual and romantic relationships between staff and students off limits at Wits

The university has formulated the banning policy to curtail possible abuse of power by lecturers against students.

TUT exams go ahead despite protests

TUT exams go ahead despite protests

Tshwane University of Technology is ensuring safety of students who are writing exams.

#FridayStandIn thoughtful conversations on civil society and student protests

#FridayStandIn thoughtful conversations on civil society and student protests

Nomfundo Walaza looked at the role of civil society 'minding the gap', and psychological fallout of Fees Must Fall protests.

Reflecting on the psychological impact of student protests

Reflecting on the psychological impact of student protests

High levels of militarisation by security on campuses has caused post-traumatic stress disorder among the university community.

Psychologist Nomfundo Walaza on the trauma of student protests (and the healing)

Psychologist Nomfundo Walaza on the trauma of student protests (and the healing)

Psychologist, human rights activist and acting director at Inyathelo, Nomfundo Walaza, is the #FridayStandIn for the Redi Tlhabi.

UCT to ensure good academic record not damaged by protests - UCT VC Price

UCT to ensure good academic record not damaged by protests - UCT VC Price

UCT has postponed courses that require practicals until next year to ensure that it produces credible and qualified graduates.

10 tips for students experiencing anxiety or trauma

10 tips for students experiencing anxiety or trauma

Psychologist Dr Schomer offers advice to students amid trauma from disputes with university management and various authorities.

Popular articles
'Thuli Madonsela’s name has been mentioned for Deputy President'

'Thuli Madonsela’s name has been mentioned for Deputy President'

Lumkile Mondi (Wits), Ferial Haffajee and Busisiwe Mavuso (Business Leadership SA) on the President's upcoming "slim" Cabinet.

[Exposed] Car dealerships, banks in cahoots; you’re not always getting best deal

[Exposed] Car dealerships, banks in cahoots; you’re not always getting best deal

Consumer journalist Wendy Knowler uncovered evidence of banks sending dealer principles on holidays abroad for hitting targets.

Running Bidvest doesn’t scare me! - Mpumi Madisa (39)

Running Bidvest doesn’t scare me! - Mpumi Madisa (39)

Madisa will soon become Bidvest’s CEO and the only black woman CEO of a JSE Top-40 company. At 39, she’ll also be the youngest.

3 risks to your retirement savings (and how to mitigate each of them)

3 risks to your retirement savings (and how to mitigate each of them)

Only 5% of South African retirement fund members will retire comfortably. Bruce Whitfield interviews advisor Warren Ingram.

'The criminals in the ANC will gang up on Cyril Ramaphosa'

'The criminals in the ANC will gang up on Cyril Ramaphosa'

Political analyst Prince Mashele and Richard Calland dissect the political landscape as 6th democratic Parliament in SA begins.

'Reason for Mabuza's swearing-in postponement is BS' says Eusebius

'Reason for Mabuza's swearing-in postponement is BS' says Eusebius

He believes these things are about power, horsetrading, and skeletons that these people know they have.

Dis-Chem drives ad expert to 'Steve Hofmeyr-like assaults' on his decoder

Dis-Chem drives ad expert to 'Steve Hofmeyr-like assaults' on his decoder

"It’s been said you can’t bore people into buying your brand. Someone should’ve pointed this out to Dis-Chem," says Andy Rice.