What are the legal implications of naming and shaming water wasting culprits?

Publishing the names of people who have allegedly contravened water restrictions may run a risk of having a number of defamation cases lodged against a municipality.

Though in the case of the City of Cape Town the list released contained only the street names where the culprits reside.

Cape Town Executive Mayor Particia De Lille said fines of up to R2 000 have been issued to people not adhering to the water restrictions.

She added, 'once those issued with fines ranging between R500 and R2 000 have paid their admission of guilt fines, we will [by law] be able to name them.'

Thus far no one has been named.

But, if any municipality did name names, what case is there for legal action if residents are guilty of overriding the rules?

Legal consultant Ben Winks explains.

The defining line if you can name and shame anybody in anything, is public interest.

Ben Winks, Independent Legal Consultant

For someone who is actually contravening water restrictions in circumstances where there is drought and water is an increasingly scarce resource, there is a degree of public interest in that.

Ben Winks, Independent Legal Consultant

So as long as its true and it's in the public interest then defamation action by the person who is named and shamed will not succeed.

Ben Winks, Independent Legal Consultant

36 fines were issued last week to consumers, as well as list released on Thursday of the streets in which the top water users live.

Listen to the full interview below...


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
[WATCH] Refentse Morake continues breaking cultural barriers through his music

[WATCH] Refentse Morake continues breaking cultural barriers through his music

The singer who says he's 'on the border of being Afrikaans and being African' joined Azania Mosaka for this week's #702Unplugged.

[LISTEN] Azania in conversation with Khanyi Mbau ahead of 'Red Room' premiere

[LISTEN] Azania in conversation with Khanyi Mbau ahead of 'Red Room' premiere

In the movie Mbau plays Zama Marawa, the wife of a wealthy man who loses everything.

BeSpecular - The app helping to improve the lives of visually impaired people

BeSpecular - The app helping to improve the lives of visually impaired people

The organisation featured on this week's #GoodNewsThursday.

#KnowlerKnows Consumer Talk: Digging yourself out of debt

#KnowlerKnows Consumer Talk: Digging yourself out of debt

Correspondent at Consumer Talk Wendy Knowler sits down with Azania to talk about the burden of debt and possible solutions.

De Lille raises alarm bells over Cape water crisis, proposes new measures

De Lille raises alarm bells over Cape water crisis, proposes new measures

Mayor Patricia De Lille wants to declare Cape Town a 'proactive disaster area' in order to secure funding for interventions.

5 things you need to know about how water restrictions affect you

5 things you need to know about how water restrictions affect you

Joburg residents will be fined for failing to abide by level 2 water restrictions implemented this week.

Popular articles
[WATCH] Refentse Morake continues breaking cultural barriers through his music

[WATCH] Refentse Morake continues breaking cultural barriers through his music

The singer who says he's 'on the border of being Afrikaans and being African' joined Azania Mosaka for this week's #702Unplugged.

What happens to our bodies if we cut out sugar

What happens to our bodies if we cut out sugar

Naked Scientist Chris Smith explains.

Why did Jussie Smollet fake his own attack? Eusebius and listeners weigh in

Why did Jussie Smollet fake his own attack? Eusebius and listeners weigh in

Eusebius McKaiser facilitates a debate on whether or not American actor Jussie Smollet faked his own attack.

[WATCH] SANDF members hilariously mess up a supposedly easy practice run

[WATCH] SANDF members hilariously mess up a supposedly easy practice run

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

[LISTEN] Wife of Vele Investments' Madzonga flatly denies VBS involvement

[LISTEN] Wife of Vele Investments' Madzonga flatly denies VBS involvement

Vele Investments CEO Robert Madzonga's estranged wife Khosi shares her side of the story on the VBS saga.

Is EOH corrupt? Is that why Microsoft ran for the hills? Its CEO explains…

Is EOH corrupt? Is that why Microsoft ran for the hills? Its CEO explains…

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Stephen van Coller, CEO at EOH Holdings.

'R23 million for rent a month seems huge. I don't think we could've done better'

'R23 million for rent a month seems huge. I don't think we could've done better'

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Adrian Gore, founder and Group Chief Executive Officer at Discovery Limited.