"Secret ballot is inherently undemocratic"

Professor Steven Friedman says a secret ballot in a motion of no confidence in President Jacob Zuma is inherently undemocratic.

United Democratic Movement (UDM) submitted an application to the ConCourt to allow MPs to vote by secret ballot. Last week President Jacob Zuma and Parliamentary Speaker Baleka Mbete filed a response to this application.

Mbete said she does not have the power to allow a secret ballot, and neither does the Constitution. The President has argued it's highly speculative for the party to suggest that ANC MPs are being intimidated to not vote against him.

Read: A legal debate: Does the Speaker have the power to declare a secret vote

The UDM was given until 4pm on Wednesday to file its reply.

Friedman says the basis of accountability by public representatives to voters is that they should pass their vote in public.

There are some democracies in which people actually set up programmes to monitor how public representatives vote so that citizens can see whether they voting in a way which citizens approve of or not.

Steven Friedman, Academic

If we get to a stage where our public representatives are allowed to vote in secret then they cease to be accountable to us at all.

Steven Friedman, Academic

Click below to listen to the full interview...


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : "Secret ballot is inherently undemocratic"


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Sars office operated with skeleton staff to allow union meeting, says caller

Sars office operated with skeleton staff to allow union meeting, says caller

Senior citizen 'Ruth' called in to the John Maytham show to say a Sars office was depleted after announcement of union meeting.

Why did security fail when CCTV cameras picked up train-fire suspects?

Why did security fail when CCTV cameras picked up train-fire suspects?

EWN's Kaylynn Palm reports on Transport Minister Fikile Mbalula's presser after 18 carriages burnt out at Cape Town Station.

Legal debate: Does Mbete have the power to hold a secret ballot (or not)

Legal debate: Does Mbete have the power to hold a secret ballot (or not)

Eusebius McKaiser and legal guests break down the legal issues surrounding the upcoming vote of no confidence in President Zuma.

Court could intervene in Parly rules to protect motion of no confidence- analyst

Court could intervene in Parly rules to protect motion of no confidence- analyst

Prof Richard Calland says court could provide clarity on whether MPs should be allowed to vote by secret ballot against president.

Baleka Mbete and President Zuma oppose UDM's secret ballot vote in Parliament

Baleka Mbete and President Zuma oppose UDM's secret ballot vote in Parliament

A legal battle of note will ensue as UDM pushes for secret ballot vote in no confidence motion while facing opposition from Zuma

Parly places Zuma's no confidence vote on ice

Parly places Zuma's no confidence vote on ice

Parliament Speaker Baleka Mbete has decided to postpone the motion of no confidence in President Jacob Zuma until further notice.

Popular articles
It is not our place to question where Duduzane's pledge comes from - UKZN SRC

It is not our place to question where Duduzane's pledge comes from - UKZN SRC

Zuma has pledged an undisclosed amount of money in order to cover some of the historic debt of students at the university.

Regulator to take action against manufacturers of recalled tinned pilchards

Regulator to take action against manufacturers of recalled tinned pilchards

Eyewitness News reporter Veronica Makhoali says the NRCS urges consumers to look out for leaking cans.

Eskom cuts power but shuns Brian Molefe and others who looted - Seth Mazibuko

Eskom cuts power but shuns Brian Molefe and others who looted - Seth Mazibuko

The Gauteng Housing Crisis Committee spokesperson says the protest is not about Soweto, but is a national issue.

History for the Future: "The trial that changed South Africa”

History for the Future: "The trial that changed South Africa”

In this episode, Andrew Mlangeni recounts how he travelled back to South Africa in the face of mounting tensions.

[LISTEN] Robert McBride reflects on his upbringing and political life

[LISTEN] Robert McBride reflects on his upbringing and political life

The former Ipid head sat down with Eusebius McKaiser for a profile interview.

'Stop pointing fingers and offer practical solutions in fight against crime'

'Stop pointing fingers and offer practical solutions in fight against crime'

Eusebius McKaiser has a frank conversation about crime in South Africa with anti-crime activist Yusuf Abramjee.

Police keeping an eye on Soweto residents' protest over Eskom power cuts

Police keeping an eye on Soweto residents' protest over Eskom power cuts

The organisers of the shutdown have called on residents to abstain from work and take to the streets, wearing black clothing.

[WATCH] Hippo taking a casual stroll to St Lucia garage goes viral

[WATCH] Hippo taking a casual stroll to St Lucia garage goes viral

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.

[WATCH] Mother playing on swing with child from fourth-floor window goes viral

[WATCH] Mother playing on swing with child from fourth-floor window goes viral

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.

'Forced sterilisations make me ashamed of being a health professional'

'Forced sterilisations make me ashamed of being a health professional'

HPCSA president Dr Kgosi Letlape and Hopeville Foundation Support Group founder Bongekile Msibi weigh in on the report by CGE.