LISTEN: Debate on Mabulu's latest work and what constitutes art

Ayanda Mabulu's latest painting depicting Nelson Mandela in a sexually explicit position has drawn questions over what constitutes real art, alongside the works of cartoonist Jonathan Shapiro.

Mabulu's painting which takes aim at President Jacob Zuma has been described as crude and lacking creativity - not far from Shapiro's 'Lady South Africa' and ' Lady Justice'.

READ: 'We don’t have to sugar-coat anything! We need straight forward symbolism!'

ALSO READ: "I can't take responsibility for racists engaged in those kinds of tropes"

While they have not crossed any legal boundaries in their right to freedom of expression and freedom of speech, Eusebius McKaiser describes the works of both artists as "lazy" and "uncreative".

I struggle to understand what the artistic merit is in it, like Zapiro's cartoon which is a riff off rape analogies in a country where rape is endemic. It is lazy, uncreative, I don't think its very sophisticated.

Eusebius McKaiser, 702 anchor

Personally in my very subjective view point it is not good art, it doesn't make me think in an interesting way, it doesn't make me see the world in a particularity different way.... It is amatuerish, I don't see the artistic, the moral or the political value in this latest Ayanda Mabulu work.

Eusebius McKaiser, 702 anchor

Here is what some listeners had to say about Mabulu's painting:.

I would like to disagree with you on the fact that the painting isn't sophisticated....I feel like it's speaking about blood money. I am picking up so many things. I think the question is maybe sometimes we get lost in the hype and don't look at things and try to open our eyes to what it says. I think it asks a lot of questions about Mandela's role as well.

Keneilwe, 702 caller

We haven't asked a lot of questions about Mandela's role in the current situation we are facing in the country right now.....I see he is asking the question of Mandela's bad legacy, and sometimes we do need to interrogate that, he can't just be all heroic in our view.

Keneilwe, 702 caller

Its very distasteful. If that is art then it means artists have actually degenerated. It makes me wonder what values this guy holds, does he have elders he seeks advice from? Does he respect his elders?

Zamane, 702 caller

It seems as though society is hellbent on discussing things based on shock tactic, its the only thing that gets people out of apathy.... does it mean we have got to use that to get rid of apathy?.

Trevor, 702 caller

Click below to listen to the full debate......


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
'Love your vulva the way it is' - Designer vaginas are dangerous, warns Dr Eve

'Love your vulva the way it is' - Designer vaginas are dangerous, warns Dr Eve

So-called 'designer vaginas' are created through various surgical or non-surgical procedures, explains clinical sexologist Dr Eve.

'Cyril is the most popular president since Nelson Mandela'

'Cyril is the most popular president since Nelson Mandela'

Author Max de Preez weighs in on where SA would be if Jacob Zuma was still president and the impact of Ramaphosa now.

Opinion: Zapiro needs new tools

Opinion: Zapiro needs new tools

702's NightTalk host Gugulethu Mhlungu says Zapiro reduces sexual violence to a trope and social commentators should do better.

On using rape as an analogy: Caller asks what's so offensive?

On using rape as an analogy: Caller asks what's so offensive?

Cartoonist Jonathan Shapiro has once gain drawn controversy over his latest cartoon. Eusebius McKaiser explains why it's wrong.

Opinion: It's time Zapiro rethinks his role as commentator

Opinion: It's time Zapiro rethinks his role as commentator

Xolani Gwala says he is disappointed by Zapiro's rape cartoon published in the Daily Maverick.

I watch my metaphors a bit more carefully now, says Zapiro

I watch my metaphors a bit more carefully now, says Zapiro

Satirical cartoonists and commentator Zapiro reflects on his more controversial depictions this year and his 21st book collection.

Popular articles
Adriaan Basson the second journalist to lay a charge against an EFF member

Adriaan Basson the second journalist to lay a charge against an EFF member

Earlier on Friday, Karima Brown laid a charge of intimidation against a party member who sent her what she says is a threatening text.

'Love your vulva the way it is' - Designer vaginas are dangerous, warns Dr Eve

'Love your vulva the way it is' - Designer vaginas are dangerous, warns Dr Eve

So-called 'designer vaginas' are created through various surgical or non-surgical procedures, explains clinical sexologist Dr Eve.

'Shutdown of Ndalo Media is no surprise and is a blow to media diversity'

'Shutdown of Ndalo Media is no surprise and is a blow to media diversity'

The company will reportedly shut its doors in January 2019.

'Cyril is the most popular president since Nelson Mandela'

'Cyril is the most popular president since Nelson Mandela'

Author Max de Preez weighs in on where SA would be if Jacob Zuma was still president and the impact of Ramaphosa now.

Here is what to do if you're affected by driving licence backlog

Here is what to do if you're affected by driving licence backlog

The WC Traffic Department has made provisions to cater for motorists affected by the backlog with the issuing of driving licences.

Gigaba and Dlamini make ANC KZN provincial nominee list

Gigaba and Dlamini make ANC KZN provincial nominee list

EWN reporter Ziyanda Ngcobo says Malusi Gigaba and Bathabile Dlamini have made the provincial nominee list for the ANC KZN.

[WATCH] Internet search for talented singer Nosipho is over...she's been found!

[WATCH] Internet search for talented singer Nosipho is over...she's been found!

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.