"HuffPost SA blog does not constitute hate speech"

Editor of Huffington Post SA Verashni Pillay tendered in her resignation following a ruling by press ombudsman Johan Retief.

Retief found that a blog, which called for white men to lose their voting rights, was discriminatory and constituted hate speech.

CapeTalk's Koketso Sachane spoke to former Business Day editor, now head of Absa communication, Songezo Zibi, about Pillay's resignation.

Zibi says that Huffington Post SA seems to have failed to ascertain who the contributor of the blog was before they could publish on their website. He says the publication should have the contact details of their contributors and be able to engage them on their submissions before making a decision to publish.

Read Songezo Zibi's opinion following judge Retief's ruling titled - Johan Retief's Ruling Mounts To A Blanket Silencing Of Debate

There's interaction that takes place between the editors and the authors or contributors. I really don't think it occurred and that is the big failure in the whole thing.

Songezo Zibi, head of communications at Absa

The role of editors is not to defend the content in an article but to provide a space in which contrasting views in society can be shared in order to facilitate debate in very important matters, as long as that content does not amount to hate speech...

Songezo Zibi, head of communications at Absa

Zibi says he does not think the article constituted hate speech as ruled by Judge Retief. He says although the call by the author to deny white males the right to vote is unconstitutional, it does not amount to hate speech.

Read also: HuffPo SA will have difficulty appealing Ombud ruling

I do not believe highlighting the dominant role of the white male in global affairs necessarily amounts to hate speech.

Songezo Zibi, head of communications at Absa

Suggesting that they, therefore, should not have the vote, I don't feel it incited anyone to go and attack them or hate them.

Songezo Zibi, head of communications at Absa

Click below to listen to the full interview with Songezo Zibi:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : "HuffPost SA blog does not constitute hate speech"


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Journalist describes night in gang infested Ocean View, Cape Town

Journalist describes night in gang infested Ocean View, Cape Town

Journalist Govan Whittles talks about his experience after spending a night in the middle of gang war in gang riddled Ocean View

New ANC president expected to be announced on Monday morning

New ANC president expected to be announced on Monday morning

Outgoing Deputy General Secretary Jessie Duarte says credentials officially adopted and results will be announced on Monday

HuffPo SA will have difficulty appealing Ombud ruling - media law expert

HuffPo SA will have difficulty appealing Ombud ruling - media law expert

Press Ombud ruled that HuffPost SA should apologise for publishing a post arguing that white people shouldn't be allowed to vote.

The "ghost" that haunts the Huffington Post

The "ghost" that haunts the Huffington Post

Independent writer and editor weighs in on how fake news can hurt credible news rooms.

Huffington Post SA doesn't verify identities of bloggers - Editor

Huffington Post SA doesn't verify identities of bloggers - Editor

The publication has been criticised for publishing a piece by a blogger using a fake identity.

'Bogus intelligence report not the first attempt at discrediting Treasury'

'Bogus intelligence report not the first attempt at discrediting Treasury'

Ferial Haffajee says these reports should not be be dismissed as they have serious consequences on the lives of South Africans.

Popular articles
Signs your child could have diabetes (that most parents can't recognise)

Signs your child could have diabetes (that most parents can't recognise)

Wednesday 14 November marks World Diabetes Day, aiming to raise awareness about both Type 1 and Type 2 diabetes.

Political Desk: Gigaba - Did he jump or was he pushed?

Political Desk: Gigaba - Did he jump or was he pushed?

The day after his resignation journalist Ranjeni Munusamy says Malusi Gigaba was lucky to survive so long in cabinet.

[LISTEN] DA MP Glynnis Breytenbach withdraws her candidacy for NDPP post

[LISTEN] DA MP Glynnis Breytenbach withdraws her candidacy for NDPP post

Breytenbach was one of 12 candidates shortlisted for the position.

SA is falling in love with Telkom Mobile (6.5m users, 50% up on 6 months ago)

SA is falling in love with Telkom Mobile (6.5m users, 50% up on 6 months ago)

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Telkom Group CEO Sipho Maseko.

Self-driving Merc returns to Chapman’s Peak to beat the bends in stirring new ad

Self-driving Merc returns to Chapman’s Peak to beat the bends in stirring new ad

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews branding and advertising expert Andy Rice about Merc's stirring new ad.

Former state security boss Mo Shaik on why minister is revetting spies

Former state security boss Mo Shaik on why minister is revetting spies

State Security Minister, Dipuo Letsatsi-Duba, has announced that all agents and staff of SSA will be re-vetted.

[LISTEN] Steinhoff explained: 100 times more looted in Steinhoff saga than VBS

[LISTEN] Steinhoff explained: 100 times more looted in Steinhoff saga than VBS

Steinhoff’s Web of Deception: An Explainer with Financial Mail journalist Warren Thompson.