Debate: Analogies in political discussion can be tricky

The use of analogies in political debate has recently sparked questions over recent weeks around what is appropriate when making comparisons to drive an argument on issues of state capture, colonialism, apartheid to name a few.

Jacques Rousseau, lecturer in critical thinking and ethics at the University of Cape Town explains how it is often ineffective and what one should guard against.

Use the analogy more as a thought experiment rather than a rebuttal.

Jacques Rousseau, UCT lecturer of critical thinking and ethics

What you must start by doing is establish a kind of relationship of mutual respect and trust in an argument so when you do land that challenging idea they are not inclined to view you as an enemy or somebody who is trying to undermine them.

Jacques Rousseau, UCT lecturer of critical thinking and ethics

But are some analogies taboo?

He comments on the problematic use of rape as an analogy as seen in a recent Zapiro cartoon about Zuma and State capture.

There is no question that rape is brutal, degrading and traumatic and so forth, but Sean [caller] does raise an interesting question here around our principles and around our consistency because we don't in general disallow reactions to things that depict other brutal and traumatic events.

Jacques Rousseau, UCT lecturer of critical thinking and ethics

This idea that rape is uniquely different to all of those other things does need to be challenged, as difficult as that may be.

Jacques Rousseau, UCT lecturer of critical thinking and ethics

Click below to listen to the full debate...


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Debate: Analogies in political discussion can be tricky


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
LISTEN: Debate on Mabulu's latest work and what constitutes art

LISTEN: Debate on Mabulu's latest work and what constitutes art

Ayanda Mabulu has drawn controversy once again over his latest painting depicting Nelson Mandela in a sexually explicit position.

Opinion: Zapiro needs new tools

Opinion: Zapiro needs new tools

702's NightTalk host Gugulethu Mhlungu says Zapiro reduces sexual violence to a trope and social commentators should do better.

Zapiro defends rape as a metaphor...again

Zapiro defends rape as a metaphor...again

The cartoonist says he has been thinking about revisiting the metaphor amid reports of state capture.

Disciplinary process against Zille set in motion

Disciplinary process against Zille set in motion

The DA's James Selfe has confirmed that the party has instituted a disciplinary process against its former leader, Helen Zille.

Zapiro takes on critic Eusebius McKaiser over organ grinder monkey cartoon

Zapiro takes on critic Eusebius McKaiser over organ grinder monkey cartoon

Zapiro's cartoon depicting NPA boss as an organ grinder's monkey has caused much public criticism, with accusations of racism.

Popular articles
[WATCH] Fikile Mbalula's funny interview has social media in stitches

[WATCH] Fikile Mbalula's funny interview has social media in stitches

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

 Eskom buys fine coal that looks like baby powder when wet, says expert Ted Blom

Eskom buys fine coal that looks like baby powder when wet, says expert Ted Blom

Energy analyst Ted Blom weighs in on the energy crisis in South Africa as load shedding stage 2 is implemented.

SA's Zozibini Tunzi simply the best, crowned Miss Universe 2019

SA's Zozibini Tunzi simply the best, crowned Miss Universe 2019

The 26-year-old is the third South African to be crowned Miss Universe and has made the country proud.

Want to start a small business? Lessons from a successful serial entrepreneur...

Want to start a small business? Lessons from a successful serial entrepreneur...

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Nic Haralambous, founder (at the cost of R5000!) of funky sock company Nic Harry.

Considering emigration? Financial planner discusses the affordability of leaving

Considering emigration? Financial planner discusses the affordability of leaving

Can you afford to leave South Africa? Certified Financial Planner (CFP) Barry O'Mahony on what to consider before deciding.

'SAA’s collapse plays nicely into hands of a politically constrained Ramaphosa'

'SAA’s collapse plays nicely into hands of a politically constrained Ramaphosa'

After dithering for fear of spending political capital, SAA is now out of the President’s hands, says Pieter du Toit (News24).

There is no Ubuntu in how Khanya Cekeshe has been treated - Thuli Madonsela

There is no Ubuntu in how Khanya Cekeshe has been treated - Thuli Madonsela

Former public protector says the eight-year sentence was too harsh and it shouldn't matter that he was not a Wits student.

‘South Africans are getting poorer and poorer because of politics’

‘South Africans are getting poorer and poorer because of politics’

SAA is a classic example, says Isaah Mhlanga, Chief Economist at Alexander Forbes Investments.

How to make your first R1 million (after that it just becomes so much easier)

How to make your first R1 million (after that it just becomes so much easier)

Rich. Wealthy. Financially free... Call it what you will; the first million is how you get there. Warren Ingram on his book...