[LISTEN]Law experts divided on whether courts should interfere in Gordhan axing

The Judiciary has come under attack following the High Court judgment ordering that President Jacob Zuma provide reasons for his latest Cabinet reshuffle.

The Democratic Alliance (DA) approached the High Court in Pretoria to ask for the record and explanation of Zuma's decision as well as the intelligence report he reportedly relied on to sack former finance minister, Pravin Gordhan and his deputy Mcebisi Jonas.

Read: President Zuma's affidavit pleads ignorance of Gordhan intelligence report

Experts have raised different arguments regarding the ruling, disagreeing on whether courts court should interfere on Zuma's decision to fire Gordhan.

Constitutional law expert, Pierre de Vos, has said every exercise of public power can be reviewed by the courts on the basis of rationality.

On the other hand University of Cape Town's Professor Richard Calland says the court should stay out of the matter, and there will be problems when the court starts to decide who is in or out of government.

Calland also explained that because Zuma has not admitted to the intelligence report as the basis of dismissing Gordhan it will be difficult to prove that his decision was irrational as per the DA's court order.

Listen to Prof Calland's analysis below...

Constitutional law expert Khomotso Moshikaro says both Calland and De Vos are correct.

Moshikaro says public power can be reviewed.

He explains that a court can ask for reasons, but "the better question to have asked is whether the court ought to have asked for reasons".

Moshikaro also supports Calland's argument that Zuma and the Presidency have not publicly stated why he fired Gordhan.

He says the President could say that sacking Gordhan was a political decision and that there was an irretrievable breakdown in their relationship.

Moshikaro says the President does have the right to ask for an appeal.

Read: Zuma can't appeal court order to provide Cabinet reshuffle records - DA

Listen to the audio below to hear Moshikaro arguing courts "have been overreaching for a long time"...

Read More
Maimane on court's ruling for Zuma to provide Cabinet reshuffle records

Maimane on court's ruling for Zuma to provide Cabinet reshuffle records

Democratic Alliance leader Mmusi Maimane says this court ruling is a victory for South Africans.

Jail those involved in corruption! - Trevor Manuel

Jail those involved in corruption! - Trevor Manuel

Ray White interviews EWN’s Stephen Grootes, who is in Durban at the World Economic Forum (WEF) on Africa summit.

12 reasons why Zuma axed Gordhan (leaked by 'insider' Chester Missing)

12 reasons why Zuma axed Gordhan (leaked by 'insider' Chester Missing)

Revolutionary political puppet Chester Missing says he's got the files on why JZ really showed Pravin Gordhan the door.

Zuma can't appeal court order to provide Cabinet reshuffle records - DA

Zuma can't appeal court order to provide Cabinet reshuffle records - DA

The DA's James Selfe says it won't cut it if President Zuma justifies the Cabinet reshuffle with his "constitutional prerogative".

Zuma ordered to give explanation for firing Pravin Gordhan

Zuma ordered to give explanation for firing Pravin Gordhan

Richard Calland says it may be difficult for the courts to prove President Zuma's Cabinet reshuffle decision as irrational.

Hawks: NPA came up with 'coup-plotter' charges

Hawks: NPA came up with 'coup-plotter' charges

New acting Hawks head Yolisa Matakata made her first appearance before police portfolio committee in Parliament.

Zuma ordered to hand over record of his decision to axe Gordhan

Zuma ordered to hand over record of his decision to axe Gordhan

DA’s advocate Steven Budlender has argued in the High Court that the President's executive decisions are subject to review.

Should heads of state make public their health status?

Should heads of state make public their health status?

Following speculations on the health of Nigerian President Buhari, Gugs and Sizwe ask why head of states hide when they are sick.

"South Africa must stop demonising state institutions"  #WEFAfrica2017

"South Africa must stop demonising state institutions" #WEFAfrica2017

Eskom chair Ben Ngubane had strong words speaking to Stephen Grootes on day 2 of the World Economic Forum on Africa.

SACP threatens action if Zuma is not recalled

SACP threatens action if Zuma is not recalled

Deputy general secretary, Solly Mapaila was speaking at the NUM education and training summit in Midrand on Wednesday.

President Zuma's affidavit pleads ignorance of Gordhan intelligence report

President Zuma's affidavit pleads ignorance of Gordhan intelligence report

The DA's application with the High Court compelling President Zuma to hand over the intelligence report will be heard on Thursday.

Gordhan still man of the moment at WEF - Stephen Grootes

Gordhan still man of the moment at WEF - Stephen Grootes

Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan continues to be looked up to amongst his peers.

South Africans looking to emigrate increasing - expert

South Africans looking to emigrate increasing - expert

Inquiries about emigration shot up by 250% per day after Zuma announced his latest Cabinet reshuffle say immigration experts.

[LISTEN] How the Guptas built an empire - ' The Republic of Gupta'

[LISTEN] How the Guptas built an empire - ' The Republic of Gupta'

Award-winning journalist and author of 'The Republic of Gupta', Pieter-Louis Myburgh shares his insights.

WEF Africa needs more Finance Minister Gigaba and less Instagram Gigaba: Grootes

WEF Africa needs more Finance Minister Gigaba and less Instagram Gigaba: Grootes

More than 1 000 delegates from 100 countries are expected to attend the 27th World Economic Forum for Africa starting today.

Is South Africa in a recession? Consider, for example, new car sales...

Is South Africa in a recession? Consider, for example, new car sales...

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews ETM Analytics Economist George Glynos.

'Coup plotter' story doesn't seem credible, says defence analyst

'Coup plotter' story doesn't seem credible, says defence analyst

Analyst Helmoed Heitman says the alleged mastermind of a plot to assassinate 19 people linked to state capture doesn't seem legit.

Coup plotter accused named in court

Coup plotter accused named in court

A 33-year-old man faces charges of conspiracy to commit murder with an alleged hit list of 19 people, including Cabinet members.

Terror expert explains why Hawks probe on coup plotter arrest doesn't add up

Terror expert explains why Hawks probe on coup plotter arrest doesn't add up

A man who allegedly plotted assassination of prominent South Africans including Zuma, Guptas and Maine is set to appear in court.

Alleged ‘coup plotter’ to appear before court

Alleged ‘coup plotter’ to appear before court

A 33-year-old man allegedly planned to assassinate 19 people including members of the Cabinet‚ SOEs and prominent South Africans.

3 red flags over alleged Cabinet assassination plots

3 red flags over alleged Cabinet assassination plots

Terrorism expert Jasmine Opperman says something is fishy with the Hawks' investigation into two recent alleged terrorism threats.

Debate: Analogies in political discussion can be tricky

Debate: Analogies in political discussion can be tricky

Eusebius McKaiser speaks to Jacques Rousseau, UCT lecturer in critical thinking and ethics, about whether some analogies are taboo.

'Mantashe isn't backing down on the reshuffle and neither is Zuma'

'Mantashe isn't backing down on the reshuffle and neither is Zuma'

ANC secretary general Gwede Mantashe rightfully denied apologising to Presiden Jacob Zuma, explains Stephen Grootes.

Economist explains why Rand strengthens despite junk status

Economist explains why Rand strengthens despite junk status

Economist at Nebank, Isaac Matshego, explains why the Rand has strengthened over the past few days.

Downgrade was looming before Cabinet reshuffle - Dawie Roodt

Downgrade was looming before Cabinet reshuffle - Dawie Roodt

The country's fiscal and growth numbers have been an indication that SA will be downgraded says economist Dawie Roodt

Gigaba said he failed to assure Moody's about SA economic policy- senior journo

Gigaba said he failed to assure Moody's about SA economic policy- senior journo

The Finance Minister admitted that he faced difficult questions from investors during his visit to the US, says Simon Marks.

SACP says it doesn't want SA turned into a playground by Gupta dynasty

SACP says it doesn't want SA turned into a playground by Gupta dynasty

The South African Communist Party is picketing outside Treasury in Tshwane to oppose state capture and corruption.

[Cartoon] Who's got the FinMin's ear?

[Cartoon] Who's got the FinMin's ear?

EWN's Dr Jack & Curtis take a look at Malusi Gigaba's recent public snub of economic advisor Chris Malikane.

Zweli Mkhize won't be drawn on past comments over Cabinet reshuffle and Zuma

Zweli Mkhize won't be drawn on past comments over Cabinet reshuffle and Zuma

The ANC treasurer-general says the only thing that matters now is to rally behind resolutions made at the last NWC meeting.

ANC's NEC should discuss "reckless" junk status comments  - Zweli Mkhize

ANC's NEC should discuss "reckless" junk status comments - Zweli Mkhize

ANC TG kept his cards close to his chest and refused to say if he would accept the position of ANC president or deputy president.

Gigaba told Malikane to 'keep quiet' after nationalisation comments

Gigaba told Malikane to 'keep quiet' after nationalisation comments

Finance Minister will attend IMF and World Bank meetings in the US and tells media he will assure them SA economy is stable.

Gigaba will have to work hard to convince international investors - economist

Gigaba will have to work hard to convince international investors - economist

Finance Minister Malusi Gigaba is due to embark on a road show to restore confidence in SA after two downgrades.

Popular articles
Sassa cards will be functional beyond expiry date

Sassa cards will be functional beyond expiry date

Sassa says text messages making the rounds asking beneficiaries to come and renew their Sassa cards is a hoax.

Why Sisulu and Dlamini-Zuma aren't suitable Presidential candidates: analyst

Why Sisulu and Dlamini-Zuma aren't suitable Presidential candidates: analyst

ANC branch in the Eastern Cape, Z.R Mahabana, has launched a campaign backing Lindiwe Sisuslu as an ANC presidential candidate.

It's not the end of the road... Top tips to improve your matric

It's not the end of the road... Top tips to improve your matric

"Recognise that it’s not the end, it’s the beginning." Expert advise for school-leavers who want to improve their results.

Bylaws, times you may use fireworks

Bylaws, times you may use fireworks

City of Johannesburg has urged residents to respect by-laws and the times set for fireworks to be used.

‘I started my thriving business with R5000 (and made a profit in the 1st month)’

‘I started my thriving business with R5000 (and made a profit in the 1st month)’

After 3 years there are 3 Nic Harry stores (incl online) that sell 100 000 pairs of socks in over 20 countries around the world.

3 easy questions could bag you R2000!

3 easy questions could bag you R2000!

WIN R2000! But only if you can prove you're a whiz of the MTN Biz Quiz by answering the following three questions...

Blesserfinder: Matching you with a sugar daddy near you

Blesserfinder: Matching you with a sugar daddy near you

Is social trend Blesserfinder, where girls are allegedly matching up with rich 'benefactors' in exchange for sex, a real thing?