Secret Ballot: "Judges seemed unconvinced by Mpofu's arguments"

Representing the United Democratic Alliance (UDM), advocate Dali Mpofu has argued that the National Assembly rules 103 and 104 are clear that the Speaker has the discretion to determine the voting procedure to be followed for any vote.

The party presented its argument in the Constitutional Court on Monday.

It wants the court to find that Parliament must hold a secret ballot in a motion of no confidence against President Jacob Zuma, but the National Assembly Speaker argues that the rules of Parliament make no such provision.

READ: Speaker has constitutional obligation to grant secret ballot, argues Dali Mpofu

Clement Manyathela has been following developments on the case.

One of the things that some of the justices raised was, they wanted the legal councils representing the various political parties to explain why the Constitution explicitly prescribes this secret ballot in specific situations but is actually silent in a motion of no confidence vote.

Clement Manyathela, EWN reporter

They were not entirely convinced from some of the arguments presented by Advocate Dali Mpofu and that is why they wanted the advocate to explain a lot on that.

Clement Manyathela, EWN reporter

Mogoeng Mogoeng was also very careful, he suggested that it was unwise for the court to be embroiled in claims of intimidation and said they are more interested in looking at the interpretation of the law.

Clement Manyathela, EWN reporter

Click on the link below to listen to the full report.....


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Transport Dept told to step in and formalise Fireblade terminal deal at OR Tambo

Transport Dept told to step in and formalise Fireblade terminal deal at OR Tambo

The court found last year that Oppenheimers' Fireblade Aviation terminal was granted permission to operate by Home Affairs Dept.

 Semenya's battle against IAAF puts spotlight on sports categories, says expert

Semenya's battle against IAAF puts spotlight on sports categories, says expert

The Olympic 800 metres champion is challenging proposed IAAF rules that could force her to lower her testosterone levels.

Billionaire Patrice Motsepe promises to keep hands off Eskom unbundling

Billionaire Patrice Motsepe promises to keep hands off Eskom unbundling

SA billionaire Patrice Motsepe says his company will not participate in the sale or disposal of any entities or assets of Eskom.

Speaker has constitutional obligation to grant secret ballot, argues Dali Mpofu

Speaker has constitutional obligation to grant secret ballot, argues Dali Mpofu

Constituional Court hears arguments from the UDM on why MPs should be allowed to vote by secret ballot against Zuma.

Anti-Zuma march heads to ConCourt on day of secret ballot bid, Maimane explains

Anti-Zuma march heads to ConCourt on day of secret ballot bid, Maimane explains

The groups will march on ConCourt the same day set aside for the court bid for a secret ballot in Parly's no confidence debate.

Constitution to be probed on secret ballot vote in motion of no confidence

Constitution to be probed on secret ballot vote in motion of no confidence

Casac has submitted an application with the courts, to be admitted as an amicus for the UDM.

Popular articles
Caster Semenya calls out IAAF for publicising expert witness list

Caster Semenya calls out IAAF for publicising expert witness list

Olympic champ Caster Semenya is challenging proposed IAAF rules that may force her to lower her testosterone levels.

'Parliament should have proper inquiry into Mkhwebane's fitness to hold office'

'Parliament should have proper inquiry into Mkhwebane's fitness to hold office'

DA's John Steenhuisen says Parliament should investigate the public protector after the findings against her.

I had nothing to do with VBS - Florence Radzilani

I had nothing to do with VBS - Florence Radzilani

Vhembe District former mayor Florence Radzilani says the Provincial Forensic Investigation exonerated her from the VBS scandal.

Pule Mabe was never alone in hotel room with assistant - ANC NEC's Sdumo Dlamini

Pule Mabe was never alone in hotel room with assistant - ANC NEC's Sdumo Dlamini

ANC's Sdumo Dlamini says party spokesperson Pule Mabe free to return to work after he being cleared of sexual harassment charges.

Black gay men can be misogynists, and here's what a few have to say about it

Black gay men can be misogynists, and here's what a few have to say about it

Presenter Eusebius McKaiser hosted a panel discussion with black gay men exploring entrenched patriarchy and the dynamics at play.

Why rooibos tea price remains high despite improved rains

Why rooibos tea price remains high despite improved rains

MD at Rooibos Ltd, Martin Bergh explains the current high price of Rooibos tea.

[WATCH] Owner catches car thief off guard and thwarts vehicle theft in Springs

[WATCH] Owner catches car thief off guard and thwarts vehicle theft in Springs

The vehicle's owner came out of the store just in time to scare away the man attempting to steal his bakkie.

Johannesburg’s drive to create a smart city is rolling out

Johannesburg’s drive to create a smart city is rolling out

Vumatel is deploying 15 000 CCTV security cameras over the next five years to make Joburg's streets safer.