"Secret ballot certainly 'permitted', and in current context it is 'required"

The ConCourt is hearing arguments on Monday on whether a secret ballot should be conducted when Parliamentarians vote on a motion of no confidence against President Jacob Zuma

The question before the court - Is a secret ballot prohibited, permitted, or required?

The day has progressed with numerous arguments for counsel for the various opposition parties.

Professor Richard Calland chats to John Maytham about the proceedings.

As is a member of Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution (Casac).

Our view is that it is certainly 'permitted', and in the circumstances of the current context, it is 'required'.

Prof Richard Calland, UCT Lw faculty and Casac member

We along with other parties in this very important litigation were urging the Court to make a constitutional interpretation that not only is Parliament entitled to say that there may be a secret ballot, but that they should declare that there is one.

Prof Richard Calland, UCT Law faculty and Casac member

It's a hard case, and there are good arguments in both directions.

Prof Richard Calland, UCT Law faculty and Casac member

The justices have been seen pressing all counsel from both sides of the argument, he says.

Read: Speaker has constitutional obligation to grant secret ballot, argues Dali Mpofu

Also Read: Secret Ballot: "Judges seemed unconvinced by Mpofu's arguments"

I have not made up my mind about which way they are going to go.

Prof Richard Calland, UCT Law faculty and Casac member

He says a judge may well be pressing counsel, not because he is against his or her argument, but rather to test his or her own thoughts and arguments.

There has been considerable skepticism today..and I think the Court can smell the mood in the country.

Prof Richard Calland, UCT Law faculty and Casac member

Take a listen:


Recommended

by THE NEWSROOM
Read More
Why Ramaphosa's hands are tied over replacing Shaun Abrahams (until next week)

Why Ramaphosa's hands are tied over replacing Shaun Abrahams (until next week)

Casac has asked the national prosecutions boss to wait until after next week's ConCourt ruling before deciding on Zuma's fate.

'Cape aquifer drilling will have negative impact on rare fynbos'

'Cape aquifer drilling will have negative impact on rare fynbos'

Adam West of UCT's Biological Sciences Dept says we should proceed with due caution if we are looking to exploit that resource.

'Drone patrol across SANParks would need 24-hour response team or alert system'

'Drone patrol across SANParks would need 24-hour response team or alert system'

Drone expert Theo Pistorius says infrared cams can be installed on drones to help locate attackers on mountains using body heat.

[WATCH] 'Why is Noordhoek beach attack front page news, but not township crime?'

[WATCH] 'Why is Noordhoek beach attack front page news, but not township crime?'

CapeTalk's John Maytham discusses latest attack on the beach and says we need to factor in all realities of life in Cape Town.

IJR: 'Inxeba' ban a blatant attempt to silence LGBTQIA voices, narratives

IJR: 'Inxeba' ban a blatant attempt to silence LGBTQIA voices, narratives

Last week, the highly-debated film was reclassified to X18 and was banned from being screened at mainstream cinemas.

Lobby group welcomes Ramaphosa's plan to remove SOE boards from tender processes

Lobby group welcomes Ramaphosa's plan to remove SOE boards from tender processes

On Friday, President Cyril Ramaphosa announced that non-executive directors of SOEs will be removed from any role in procurement.

Popular articles
Minister Zwane confirms trips to Dubai and Switzerland

Minister Zwane confirms trips to Dubai and Switzerland

EWN parliamentary correspondent Gaye Davis says Mineral Resources Minister Mosebenzi Zwane received detailed and tough questions.

Zweli Mkhize 'taken by surprise' with latest cabinet reshuffle

Zweli Mkhize 'taken by surprise' with latest cabinet reshuffle

The ANC treasurer-general confirmed Mantashe’s comments that the President did not consult the ANC leadership on the reshuffle.

"Duduzane Zuma is the Gupta family's greatest asset"

"Duduzane Zuma is the Gupta family's greatest asset"

Sunday Times journo Thanduxolo Jika who broke the front page story about the Gupta family emails vouches for their authenticity.

So what exactly is radical economic transformation?

So what exactly is radical economic transformation?

Wits associate professor of economics Christopher Malikane speaks to Azania Mosaka about the term that is being bandied about.

‘My worst fear is being 80 years old and poor’ – famed actor Dr. John Kani

‘My worst fear is being 80 years old and poor’ – famed actor Dr. John Kani

"My earliest memory of money is my father saying, ‘Why do you want to do this thing? How are you going to feed the family?'"

Who is Advocate Tembeka Ngcukaitobi?

Who is Advocate Tembeka Ngcukaitobi?

The EFF lawyer stole the show during the state capture report court battle.

3 easy questions could bag you R2000!

3 easy questions could bag you R2000!

WIN R2000! But only if you can prove you're a whiz of the MTN Biz Quiz by answering the following three questions...

Meet Errol Musk - father of Elon, the most innovative entrepreneur of our age

Meet Errol Musk - father of Elon, the most innovative entrepreneur of our age

Elon Musk, as you’d expect, hails from an exceptional family. Bruce Whitfield interviews his Capetonian father.