Why are some court sentences harsher than others?

The Khayelitsha regional court on Wednesday sentenced four men to a combined 127-years imprisonment for running an abalone syndicate.

The sentence shocked many people asking why the justice system is lenient on murderers and rapists and very harsh on these four men.

Criminal law expert, Advocate Mannie Witz, says it all depends on the charges and the Act under which an individual is charged as each one has a sentence provision.

Statutory matters prescribe to the presiding officers what type of sentence should be imposed.

Advocate Mannie Witz, Criminal Law Expert

According to Witz, these kind of crimes used to be under a different kind of Act which has now been changed to Marine and Living resources Act. In this particular Act they charge people with possession of abalone, transporting and processing of it, says Witz.

What happened here is a very important act which was formed in 1998, it's a statute called the Prevention of Organised Crime Act (Poca)... This is a sentence for proper organised crimes - syndicate related crimes.

Advocate Mannie Witz, Criminal Law Expert

In terms of Poca, you can get a fine R100 million or life imprisonment if you are found guilty. The regional court can limit it to a fine of R30 million or 20-25 years imprisonment or both.

Advocate Mannie Witz, Criminal Law Expert

Obviously these people have been convicted under that Act.

Advocate Mannie Witz, Criminal Law Expert

To hear more of this interview, listen below:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Why are some court sentences harsher than others?


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Former media exec molested 'hundreds' of boys and young men - Deon Wiggett

Former media exec molested 'hundreds' of boys and young men - Deon Wiggett

The final episode of Deon Wiggett's podcast series 'My Only Story' has been published in collaboration with News24.

District Six land claimants to discuss govt's proposed restitution plan

District Six land claimants to discuss govt's proposed restitution plan

The District Six Reference Group will hold a meeting on Saturday to outline the proposals that the government has put on the table.

'We're ready and able to deal with increased online payments on Black Friday'

'We're ready and able to deal with increased online payments on Black Friday'

PayFast MD Jonathan Smit says the spread of technologies available should help mitigate risk of compromising payment systems.

The rand… Pravin Gordhan speaks... De Beers on Kimberley’s Big Hole…

The rand… Pravin Gordhan speaks... De Beers on Kimberley’s Big Hole…

These were the 7 most read, most talked about business articles of the past week.

De Beers discusses Kimberley’s Big Hole – one of the largest on the planet

De Beers discusses Kimberley’s Big Hole – one of the largest on the planet

Bruce Whitfield interviews a De Beers spokesperson on what some people claim to be the world’s largest hole dug by hand.

How the legal abalone (aka perlemoen) industry functions in South Africa

How the legal abalone (aka perlemoen) industry functions in South Africa

The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield interviews the MD of Abagold, a company that cultivates, processes and exports abalone.

Popular articles
How South Africa is viewed across African continent is crucial - Zeinab Badawi

How South Africa is viewed across African continent is crucial - Zeinab Badawi

BBC presenter discusses the broadcaster's interactive Global Questions series.

[WATCH] Mom revealing that she forgot her children during school run goes viral

[WATCH] Mom revealing that she forgot her children during school run goes viral

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.

[WATCH] Michael Jackson lookalike wrestling has social media in stitches

[WATCH] Michael Jackson lookalike wrestling has social media in stitches

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.

EFF march against load shedding to Eskom head office

EFF march against load shedding to Eskom head office

Secretary-general Marshall Dlamini says the aim of the protest is to bring awareness of the incompetence of that in charge.

Budget 2020 made simple: how does it impact my personal finances?

Budget 2020 made simple: how does it impact my personal finances?

Wealth builder Warren Ingram on how the new budget affects you.

Spur to open 11 more outlets in South Africa

Spur to open 11 more outlets in South Africa

Spur releases results saying it plans to open 11 outlets in SA and 17 internationally in the second half of the year.

Massmart explains store closures and retrenchments in the face of a R1.3bn loss

Massmart explains store closures and retrenchments in the face of a R1.3bn loss

Massmart has withheld their dividend as it swings to a R1.3bn loss

'Blame Madiba  and Mbeki for Eskom' - unions vow to fight Budget 2020 wage cuts

'Blame Madiba and Mbeki for Eskom' - unions vow to fight Budget 2020 wage cuts

''Government is speaking with forked tongue and Budget 2020 came as a shock''. Unions want to fight planned wage cuts.

 #Budget2020: There is a huge sense of relief among retailers - Edcon

#Budget2020: There is a huge sense of relief among retailers - Edcon

On Wednesday Finance Minister Tito Mboweni said there would be no new income tax hikes this year.

Cape Winelands farm workers protest following eviction of six family members

Cape Winelands farm workers protest following eviction of six family members

Women on Farms co-director Carmen Louw says they hope the Extension of Security of Tenure Act will be amended.