Unpacking the rooted "leadership crisis" in the police

Corruption Watch and the Institute for Security Studies (ISS) will be launching a public awareness campaign focused on the appointments of the South African Police Service (SAPS) national commissioner and the head of the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigations (the Hawks).

The campaign aims to ensure a transparent selection process that allows for public participation in line with the criteria recommended in the National Development Plan. Both Corruption Watch and Institute of Security Studies (ISS) consider the impact of the appointments critical in strengthening the fight against corruption and crime.

Gareth Newham, head of the Justice and Violence Prevention Programme at the ISS says the vulnerability in law enforcement institutions began soon after the appointment of Jacob Zuma as South Africa's president when the Directorate of Special Investigations (or Scorpions) was disbanded.

We were very worried at that time when we suddenly saw this move to shut them down based on this idea that they were politically misused.

Gareth Newham, Head of the Justice and Violence Prevention Programme at the Institute of Security Studies

The fundamental problem is that the constitution allows the President to appoint any man or woman he likes to be the chief of police says Newham. He adds that people without police experience, with questionable integrity saw themselves appointed by President Zuma to become the National Police Commissioner.

We've had no permanent appointment that have ended in disgrace. We've had acting appointments that have been very good.

Gareth Newham, Head of the Justice and Violence Prevention Programme at the Institute of Security Studies

David Lewis, Executive Director of Corruption Watch says South Africa is a well placed to fight corruption.

We have a strong foundational law, we have independent courts, we have robust and courageous media, we have active civil society. The only thing that's missing is an effective criminal justice system.

David Lewis, Executive Director of Corruption Watch

Lewis further explains that the design of how top cop appointments are made is also problematic. He lists the first problem as President Zuma possessing unvetted discretion in appointing the SAPS Commissioner. The second problem is who the President is, says Lewis.

Listen to the clip for more on the police leadership being in crisis:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Police embark on re-enlisting former members

Police embark on re-enlisting former members

Police spokesperson, Vishnu Naidoo spoke to Xolani about this process and the spate of attacks on people leaving ORTIA.

[LISTEN] Caller wants immediate redeployment of amaberete in Alexandra township

[LISTEN] Caller wants immediate redeployment of amaberete in Alexandra township

Popcru support police minister, Fikile Mbalula's decision to redeploy amaberete in townships.

"SA has the fourth largest private security industry in the world" - expert

"SA has the fourth largest private security industry in the world" - expert

The architecture and economy of fear in South Africa where an estimated R55 billion is spent on private security annually.

Mbalula happy with police work but wants top structures fixed

Mbalula happy with police work but wants top structures fixed

Fikile Mbalula appeared before Parliament’s Police Committee promising sweeping changes to the SAPS civilian secretariat.

Path now clear for 'unfettered investigation' as Phahlane  steps aside - Brown

Path now clear for 'unfettered investigation' as Phahlane steps aside - Brown

Political analyst Karima Brown gives insight into the end of Khomotso Phahlane's acting tenure.

Zuma  announces new SA top cop Lesetja Mothiba

Zuma announces new SA top cop Lesetja Mothiba

President Jacob Zuma says Lieutenant-General Khomotso Phahlane's acting tenure came to an end today.

How government shirks responsibility in fighting gender-based violence

How government shirks responsibility in fighting gender-based violence

There is a visible absence of political will to fight these crimes and it shifts to civil society says Stellies Prof Amanda Gouws.

Popular articles
10 best business books reviewed on The Money Show in 2018

10 best business books reviewed on The Money Show in 2018

Know someone who’d appreciate a business book for Christmas? These were the best ones of the year…

'The corrupt use anti-corruption campaigns to divert attention from themselves'

'The corrupt use anti-corruption campaigns to divert attention from themselves'

Political analyst Steven Friedman says corrupt people use anti-corruption campaigns to neutralise those fighting corruption.

ANCWL calls on the ANC to suspend Pule Mabe

ANCWL calls on the ANC to suspend Pule Mabe

ANC Women's League says Mabe must be suspended pending the outcome of a sexual harassment complaint lodged against him.

'Evidence is solid. Poor people’s money was used illegally. Shivambu benefitted'

'Evidence is solid. Poor people’s money was used illegally. Shivambu benefitted'

Ray White interviews Pauli van Wyk, an investigative journalist with Scorpio at Daily Maverick.

RMB and a paediatric surgeon from Baragwanath came together to save little lives

RMB and a paediatric surgeon from Baragwanath came together to save little lives

Ray White interviews Prof Jerome Loveland (Paediatric Surgery at Wits and Baragwanath) and Gareth Armstrong (Rand Merchant Bank).

ANC Spokesperson Pule Mabe accused of sexual harassment

ANC Spokesperson Pule Mabe accused of sexual harassment

In a letter seen by Eyewitness News a 26-year-old woman says Mabe wanted to have sex with her in exchange for a job as his PA.

[LISTEN] EFF's Floyd Shivambu was a beneficiary of stolen money - Pauli van Wyk

[LISTEN] EFF's Floyd Shivambu was a beneficiary of stolen money - Pauli van Wyk

Journalist Pauli van Wyk outlines how VBS approved Brian Shivambu’s R1. 46m home loan, with a little help from his brother.

[WATCH] Johnny Clegg opens up about emotional 'The Crossing' video

[WATCH] Johnny Clegg opens up about emotional 'The Crossing' video

South African legend, musician Johnny Clegg talks about the moving recording of his track The Crossing by over 50 artists.