Court ruling grants crime victims identity protection but only until they are 18

The North Gauteng High Court passed down a judgment on Tuesday in a landmark case about protecting the identity of child victims and child witnesses from being exposed in the media.

The judge declared that the provision which protects the identity of child witnesses and offenders should be extended to include victims of crimes. The applicant has also argued that these protections should extend beyond the age of 18 years.

The court dismissed that aspect of the application. The court gave an order protecting Zephany Nurse's identity until all appeals are exhausted.

It is disappointing that the court found that the protection of identity should not continue beyond the age of eighteen.

Dr. Ann Skelton, Director at Center For Child Law, University Of Pretoria

Skelton says, the one positive outcome of the judgment, was the judge's ruling to protect identities of victims below the age of eighteen.

We are going to apply for leave to appeal. We remain firm in our view that the case is highly winnable.

Dr. Ann Skelton, Director at Center For Child Law, University Of Pretoria

If someone has gone through the trauma of a crime, they find it far more difficult to recover if they are doing so in the full glare of the publicity and having their identities known makes it worse says Skelton.

Have a listen to the report in the clip below:


702 welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the 702 community a safe and welcoming space for all.

702 reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

702 is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Child rights lobby groups take on media in court

Child rights lobby groups take on media in court

Lobby groups fight for the media to protect the identity of child crime victims even once they turn 18.

Zephany Nurse and Henri van Breda, court cases that rocked the Cape

Zephany Nurse and Henri van Breda, court cases that rocked the Cape

EWN's Giovanna Gerbi looks at the dynamics of the Zephany Nurse and hints on what to expect from the van Breda triple murder case.

Relative may be in jail but we will always have Zephany taunts abductor's family

Relative may be in jail but we will always have Zephany taunts abductor's family

EWN Giovanna Gerbi was at the court when Zephany Nurse's abductor was sentenced to ten years behind bars.

'Empty justice' as Zephany Nurse's kidnapper sentenced to 10 years behind bars

'Empty justice' as Zephany Nurse's kidnapper sentenced to 10 years behind bars

Judge John Hlophe told the woman that she had to be punished for kidnapping Zephany Nurse and tearing apart the estranged family.

The woman convicted of kidnapping Zephany Nurse maintains she did not do it

The woman convicted of kidnapping Zephany Nurse maintains she did not do it

State argues that psychologist Mark Steyn too inexperienced to deal with the Zephany Nurse case.

Zephany Nurse accused found guilty on all three charges, sent straight to jail

Zephany Nurse accused found guilty on all three charges, sent straight to jail

The 51-year-old Lavender Hill woman has been found guilty of kidnapping Zephany Nurse from her sleeping mother's arms in 1997.

Judge Hlophe to hand down judgment in Zephany Nurse trial

Judge Hlophe to hand down judgment in Zephany Nurse trial

Judge will announce the outcome of the Zephany Nurse trial. But the young woman still remains close to the man who raised her.

Accused's husband in Zephany Nurse trial 'lied to for 18 years'

Accused's husband in Zephany Nurse trial 'lied to for 18 years'

The husband of the woman accused of abducting Zephany Nurse at Groote Schuur Hospital in 1997 said he never doubted her pregnancy.

State argues Zephany Nurse's alleged kidnapper bought baby for R3000

State argues Zephany Nurse's alleged kidnapper bought baby for R3000

The state has begun its cross-examination of the the woman accused of abducting Zephany Nurse at Groote Schuur Hospital in 1997.

Accused maintains she adopted Zephany Nurse legally, later breaks down on stand

Accused maintains she adopted Zephany Nurse legally, later breaks down on stand

The woman accused of kidnapping Zephany Nurse in 1997 took the stand in the Western Cape High Court.

Top 5 court cases to watch in 2016

Top 5 court cases to watch in 2016

2015 was a roller coaster ride for the judicicial system and 2016 will have a lot in store for South Africans wanting justice to be served.

The parents of Zephany Nurse on what happened 17 years ago

The parents of Zephany Nurse on what happened 17 years ago

Celeste and Morne Nurse found their daughter after she was taken from them 17 years ago. They speak to John Maytham.

State Security to seek out South Africa's CIA 'spies'

State Security to seek out South Africa's CIA 'spies'

The Midday Report - where you won't miss a thing

Tensions in Thembelihle continue despite government intervention

Tensions in Thembelihle continue despite government intervention

The Midday Report - where you won't miss a thing

DNA confirms identity of a Cape Town girl 17 years after her abduction

DNA confirms identity of a Cape Town girl 17 years after her abduction

A family in Cape Town is re-united with their daughter 17 years after she was stolen from her mother.

Popular articles
7 tips on how to keep your child safe in public

7 tips on how to keep your child safe in public

Social worker and Childline manager Faiza Khota shares practical advise on how to help protect children in public spaces.

Soon you may not be able to light up in public (indoors or out!)

Soon you may not be able to light up in public (indoors or out!)

The Dept of Health is looking to introduce draft legislation that includes a complete ban on all smoking in public areas.

'KZN nudist beach would be a draw card for international tourism'

'KZN nudist beach would be a draw card for international tourism'

Chairman of KZN Naturists Association Christo Bothma says having the section of the South Coast beach will boost the economy.

New drug known as 'flakka' hits Durban

New drug known as 'flakka' hits Durban

Sam Pillay, founder and director of Anti-Drug Forum SA says once the drug takes effect, the user appears possessed.

The President's Keepers: PDF version is tantamount to theft - Exclusive Books

The President's Keepers: PDF version is tantamount to theft - Exclusive Books

A PDF version of the book has been doing the rounds since Sars and the State Security Agency threatened legal action.

Falling out of love? Signs and stages of romantic disengagement

Falling out of love? Signs and stages of romantic disengagement

Can you love your partner, but no longer be in love with them? Dr Eve unravels stages of disaffection in romantic relationships.

Celibacy liberated me - Amanda Ndiki

Celibacy liberated me - Amanda Ndiki

Author Amanda Ndiki, celibate for 6 years describes her journey and how celibacy helped mend her sense of self.

'The university degree is dead'

'The university degree is dead'

Flux Trends founder Dion Chang gives five reasons why he believes getting a degree is past its sell by date.