The role of anecdotal story-telling in public debate

Public debate is often shaped by one's personal experience. But what role does anecdotal evidence play when discussing important societal issues?

Jacques Rousseau, lecturer in critical thinking and ethics at the University of Cape Town, says anecdotes are important.

Some researchers and analysts believe that number based statistics are more reliable than anecdotes, but Rosseau says both play an important role.

Anecdote matters because people are connected to their emotional experience. As a subjected individual, these are things that define your world and the values that you have.

Jacques Rousseau, lecturer in critical thinking and ethics at the University of Cape Town

But it may be complicated to rely solely on anecdotal evidence to make a point during a debate.

According to Rousseau, it is presumptuous to use all anecdotal evidence in the general sense. This is because subjective experience is unrepresentative or biased. It could be a clue, but should not be the sole basis of one's argument.

However, with some institutionalised views that are prevalent in the country or the world, like racism or misogyny, anecdotal evidence may strengthen an argument in this context, he says, and it will better equip one to have more understanding of situations.

To ensure that your lived experience is sufficient to add to your views in a debate or discussion, Rousseau recommends you identify the ways in which your experience may not be representative or reliable.

Listen to the full discussion below:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Festive season can trigger past pains for people - Dr Eve

Festive season can trigger past pains for people - Dr Eve

The clinical sexologist gives a compilation of the best topics that have been covered throughout 2019.

'Do not go into the festive season without a budget,' says financial adviser

'Do not go into the festive season without a budget,' says financial adviser

Old Mutual head of financial education John Manyike and finance professional Palesa Lengolo give advice on financial literacy.

[LISTEN] Qaanitah Hunter talks ‘Balance of Power’.

[LISTEN] Qaanitah Hunter talks ‘Balance of Power’.

The author and award-winning journalist with the Sunday Times shares some insight into her book.

'Daily Maverick is a miracle baby to have survived a decade

'Daily Maverick is a miracle baby to have survived a decade

Journalist and author Richard Poplak discusses how the publication has survived in difficult times for the past 10 years.

The problem with Eskom is racism, says caller

The problem with Eskom is racism, says caller

Callers on the Eusebius McKaiser Show debate various issues including the current load shedding by the power utility.

[LISTEN] Looking back at 2019 and mapping out 2020 in the world of work

[LISTEN] Looking back at 2019 and mapping out 2020 in the world of work

Human capital development executive Edith Leeuta shares some advice.

Popular articles
Considering emigration? Financial planner discusses the affordability of leaving

Considering emigration? Financial planner discusses the affordability of leaving

Can you afford to leave South Africa? Certified Financial Planner (CFP) Barry O'Mahony on what to consider before deciding.

[WATCH] Traffic cop caught on video asking for 'bribe' goes viral

[WATCH] Traffic cop caught on video asking for 'bribe' goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

'Family specifically didn't want Mnangagwa to preside over Mugabe's funeral'

'Family specifically didn't want Mnangagwa to preside over Mugabe's funeral'

Zimbabwe Independent editor Dumisani Muleya explains why Zimbabwe's late president was only buried over the weekend.

4 things you should never say if you want to get rich

4 things you should never say if you want to get rich

Don’t ever say or, worse, believe any of these wealth-destroying platitudes, implores personal finance expert Warren Ingram.

Khaya Dlanga: I fell asleep next to President Mbeki

Khaya Dlanga: I fell asleep next to President Mbeki

Author Khaya Dlanga speaks about his upcoming book titled 'These things really happen to me'.

I want to get SA skiing on the map - Alpine skier Connor Wilson at Winter Games

I want to get SA skiing on the map - Alpine skier Connor Wilson at Winter Games

The 21-year-old says he wants to inspire other young South Africans to participate in the Winter Olympics one day.

Why Steinhoff (formerly SA’s 5th biggest company) lost 62% of its value in a day

Why Steinhoff (formerly SA’s 5th biggest company) lost 62% of its value in a day

Bruce Whitfield interviews Steinhoff Chair Christo Wiese, the JSE's John Burke and Anchor Capital CIO Sean Ashton.