The role of anecdotal story-telling in public debate

Public debate is often shaped by one's personal experience. But what role does anecdotal evidence play when discussing important societal issues?

Jacques Rousseau, lecturer in critical thinking and ethics at the University of Cape Town, says anecdotes are important.

Some researchers and analysts believe that number based statistics are more reliable than anecdotes, but Rosseau says both play an important role.

Anecdote matters because people are connected to their emotional experience. As a subjected individual, these are things that define your world and the values that you have.

Jacques Rousseau, lecturer in critical thinking and ethics at the University of Cape Town

But it may be complicated to rely solely on anecdotal evidence to make a point during a debate.

According to Rousseau, it is presumptuous to use all anecdotal evidence in the general sense. This is because subjective experience is unrepresentative or biased. It could be a clue, but should not be the sole basis of one's argument.

However, with some institutionalised views that are prevalent in the country or the world, like racism or misogyny, anecdotal evidence may strengthen an argument in this context, he says, and it will better equip one to have more understanding of situations.

To ensure that your lived experience is sufficient to add to your views in a debate or discussion, Rousseau recommends you identify the ways in which your experience may not be representative or reliable.

Listen to the full discussion below:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
How technology is changing the world of archaeology

How technology is changing the world of archaeology

This week Technobyte looks at how technology is changing archaeology, SA’s IoT network and Uber's on-demand staffing system.

[LISTEN] Catch up with this in-depth look at the week's news and analysis

[LISTEN] Catch up with this in-depth look at the week's news and analysis

Political Journalist at News24 Matshidiso Madia gives an analysis of the past week's political headlines.

How to help your kids adjust to new siblings

How to help your kids adjust to new siblings

Clinical psychologist Khosi Jiyane says parents must recognise the anxiety new siblings create and give other kids reassurance.

Khayelitsha fire victims should get same help as Knysna says Sizwe Mpofu-Walsh

Khayelitsha fire victims should get same help as Knysna says Sizwe Mpofu-Walsh

Sizwe Mpofu-Walsh and callers discuss ways that corporate SA should help displaced Khayelitsha fire victims in Cape Town.

[LISTEN] #NakedScientist: Very first lab-grown oesophagus implanted in mice

[LISTEN] #NakedScientist: Very first lab-grown oesophagus implanted in mice

Experiment will hopefully lead to clinical trials of food pipes for kids born with part of their oesophagus damaged or missing.

[LISTEN] Callers share how they beat the odds to achieve academic excellence

[LISTEN] Callers share how they beat the odds to achieve academic excellence

Callers share how they overcame difficult situations to get an education.

Popular articles
#Changemakers2018: I don't like talking about myself, but I need to - Ray Zondo

#Changemakers2018: I don't like talking about myself, but I need to - Ray Zondo

At the #Changemakers2018 conference, Deputy Chief Justice of SA Raymond Zondo spoke about the struggles he faced growing up.

The Polo GTI has got that vrrrpha mentality written all over it - Jacob Moshokoa

The Polo GTI has got that vrrrpha mentality written all over it - Jacob Moshokoa

Automotive Journalist, Jacob Moshokoa shares his views of the Polo GTI 2018, and chats about the vrrrpha mentality among young men

Yet another wet and cold weekend for Gauteng warns weather service

Yet another wet and cold weekend for Gauteng warns weather service

Gauteng residents are warned to brace themselves for another weekend of heavy rain, possible hail and damaging winds.

[Watch] SA choir stuns with isiZulu cover of Ed Sheeran’s ‘Shape of You’

[Watch] SA choir stuns with isiZulu cover of Ed Sheeran’s ‘Shape of You’

Khabazela shares some of the most popular tweets, posts, and videos on 'What's gone Viral'.

Calls for more women to come forward and testify at Timothy Omotoso's trial

Calls for more women to come forward and testify at Timothy Omotoso's trial

Thanduxolo Jindela explains why he is running a campaign to encourage more of Omotoso’s victims to come out and testify.

10-year-old maths whiz Sbahle Zwane gets a scholarship from Curro school

10-year-old maths whiz Sbahle Zwane gets a scholarship from Curro school

Azania Mosaka catches up with Sbahle Zwane's mother to hear about developments with his schooling.