Somerset Hospital re-zoning is critical for any housing to be built - Zille

There has been widespread outrage over a multi billion-rand development planned for the Somerset Hospital precinct - with affordable housing as an afterthought.

The Cape Argus reports that civil society and the local rate payer's association in Green Point opposed a proposal to rezone the Somerset Hospital between the V&A Waterfront and the Cape Town Stadium precinct into a mixed-used development, which would include a hotel, 1 000 luxury apartments, a restaurant and places of entertainment.

Western Cape Premier, Helen Zille says the re-zoning is critical to build any housing there at all.

The bottom line is that we've asked for the re-zoning of the whole Somerset Hospital site. But the three hundred affordable units that we specifically referred to, does not refer to the whole site. It only refers to the Helen Bowden nurses home component of it.

Helen Zille, Western Cape Premier

It's completely wrong to say that there will only be three hundred in total on that site. The application itself says a minimum of three hundred.

Helen Zille, Western Cape Premier

If you want to have a re-zoning application you have to have a broad brush development plan submitted explains Zille.

She says they've applied for a specific zoning which allows for a whole range of different uses from housing to boarding houses, flats, place of worship, business premises etc.

She says they cannot commit to more units because they need to ensure that the project is viable and that there is cross subsidisation from other developments to make those units affordable.

You cannot give some people, who are a poor, a subsidy worth one and a half to two million rand and other people a subsidy worth a hundred and twenty thousand rand. That would not pass constitutional muster.

Helen Zille, Western Cape Premier

She says the only way to balance a governments subsidy is to ensure that top dollar is paid for the private parts of that development on which they then cross subsidise.

Then the proper state subsidy will extend to various portions of that site for affordable housing, she adds.

It can't be rational or equitable in terms of the Constitution says Zille.

Click on the audio below for the full interview:


702 welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the 702 community a safe and welcoming space for all.

702 reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

702 is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Ten years ago 7% of cinema goers were black, today that number is nearly 70%

Ten years ago 7% of cinema goers were black, today that number is nearly 70%

Hollywood vs Bollywood vs Nollywood vs Egoliwood - SA film industry gurus chat to Eusebius McKaiser about the local film scene.

Cape Town houses ranked the third most expensive in the world

Cape Town houses ranked the third most expensive in the world

Ndifuna Ukwazi researcher Julian Sendin, says South Africa's housing issues date back to the apartheid era.

All systems go for Knysna Oyster Festival, organiser explains

All systems go for Knysna Oyster Festival, organiser explains

The festival will take place from 7 July to 16 July, weeks after the ravaging fires that claimed 7 lives and displaced thousands.

Zille: Garden Route rebuild project to jumpstart local economy

Zille: Garden Route rebuild project to jumpstart local economy

The new initiative will develop a rebuilding strategy for the area and identify where public and private funds can best be spent.

Social Development to clamp down on illegal daycare centres

Social Development to clamp down on illegal daycare centres

This follows a recent court ruling on Ava Barley's case, the five-month-old baby that died at a Cape Town daycare centre in 2010.

"Our interpretation of sleeping around is sleeping around"

"Our interpretation of sleeping around is sleeping around"

A throwback to Floyd Shivambu talking about Helen Zille during his ANCYL days, interrogated by Redi Tlhabi in 2009. #FarewellRedi

Mkhwebane met with stench of broken communal loos in Masiphumelele visit

Mkhwebane met with stench of broken communal loos in Masiphumelele visit

Public protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane was in Masiphumelele on Friday to address complaints regarding the state of the area

Zille: Comparing fire tragedies based on race is unfair

Zille: Comparing fire tragedies based on race is unfair

The town of Knysna and surrounding areas was severely damaged as a resulted of raging flames that destroyed many homes.

DA have had to put a band aid on something that is still unresolved - Brown

DA have had to put a band aid on something that is still unresolved - Brown

Political analyst Karima Brown gives her take on Helen Zille stepping down from the DA and other political headlines.

The DA clips Helen Zille's wings

The DA clips Helen Zille's wings

At the press briefing, Zille made an admission that her public utterances have effectively undermined DA leader Mmusi Maimane.

DA accepts Helen Zille's belated apology for colonialism tweet

DA accepts Helen Zille's belated apology for colonialism tweet

Zille apologised to all South Africans during a press conference and has been relieved of her leadership roles within the party.

Gigaba a Gupta enabler with credibility deficit, says analyst

Gigaba a Gupta enabler with credibility deficit, says analyst

Political analyst Karima Brown says Finance Minister Malusi Gigaba has been caught with his pants around his ankles.

Selfe: No grounds to remove Zille as WC Premier

Selfe: No grounds to remove Zille as WC Premier

The DA's federal executive chair James Selfe says the party doesn't want to remove her as Premier of a successful local govt.

[Watch] Helen Zille to step down from all decision-making structures

[Watch] Helen Zille to step down from all decision-making structures

DA leader Mmusi Maimane and Helen Zille address the media over Zille's colonialism tweets.

City clarifies advert on the lifting of title deeds restrictions

City clarifies advert on the lifting of title deeds restrictions

Following concerns about a title deed restrictions advert, Cllr Brett Herron answers questions and gives clarity on what it means.

This week's stock tips. - Christopher Gilmour gives his top 3 picks

This week's stock tips. - Christopher Gilmour gives his top 3 picks

Stock Pick Monday: Christopher Gilmour, Analyst at the Wealth and Investment Department at Barclays Africa gives his picks.

Famous Brands CEO Kevin Hedderwick to retire after 16 years of service

Famous Brands CEO Kevin Hedderwick to retire after 16 years of service

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Hedderwick, who will retire as CEO of Famous Brands on 29 February 2016.

City of Cape Town is accused of not respecting the rights its residents

City of Cape Town is accused of not respecting the rights its residents

A concerned resident tells John that the City is keeping the community in the dark about its plans, denying them rights to participate.

Frequently Asked Questions - school admissions

Frequently Asked Questions - school admissions

Almost everything you need to know about placing your child in school for 2015.

Popular articles
Meet the inspirational man who has lived with HIV since birth

Meet the inspirational man who has lived with HIV since birth

Ntimbwe Mpamba shares his life's journey of living with HIV. He is the longest living person with HIV in Africa.

Historical victory as Parliament passes paternity leave bill

Historical victory as Parliament passes paternity leave bill

The Labour Laws Amendment Bill seeks to regulate the right of parental leave for South African fathers and adoption leave.

Soon you may not be able to light up in public (indoors or out!)

Soon you may not be able to light up in public (indoors or out!)

The Dept of Health is looking to introduce draft legislation that includes a complete ban on all smoking in public areas.

'If you don't like dagga, you're not going to like the future', says lobbyist

'If you don't like dagga, you're not going to like the future', says lobbyist

The Clear Option's CEO, Quintin van Kerken, says the State has failed to make a convincing argument against legalising cannabis.

Dr Viwe Mtwesi is South Africa's youngest black female cardiologist

Dr Viwe Mtwesi is South Africa's youngest black female cardiologist

Dr Viwe Mtwesi spoke to Relebogile Mabotja about her achievements and commitment to serving people through her work.

Almost 30 million SA ID numbers compromised after site hacked

Almost 30 million SA ID numbers compromised after site hacked

Independent Marketing Consultant in the Technology Space, Andrew Fraser says this looks like a leak and not a hack.

'The university degree is dead'

'The university degree is dead'

Flux Trends founder Dion Chang gives five reasons why he believes getting a degree is past its sell by date.