Opinion: In Defence of Mr Paul Edey

Dear 702,

In light of the terrible news coming out of St John's, and the way in which Mr Edey has been portrayed by some of your talk show hosts, I feel duty-bound to express the truth about him, and about the tremendous influence he has had upon my life.

As a young, poor, indigenous child who had gained his way into St David's Marist College with an academic scholarship, high school proved to be a continual reminder of my own economic deficiencies and my cultural divergences from the mainstream elite at the time. I was one of 2 black students in a class of 100, and I had no shield to protect me from teenage deprecation.

High school was in short a terror - and I am ashamed to confess that I decided early on to try my hand at joining the terrors, so that I could gain a measure of infamy, and in so doing, deflect some attention away from my poor self.

The opportunity to cause insult to my overweight accounting teacher arose when we were asked to compile a business plan early in Standard 6 (Grade 8). Armed with Herbalife brochures, and a wicked way with words, I set off with mischievous glee. I was only trying to be funny, I convinced myself. The sorry truth which I hid all too well from myself, was that my presentation was shameful, sexist, and ignobly pejorative about women with weight challenges. It was the lowest point of my scholastic career. Of course, I got cackles and sniggers from the rest of the class. Of course, my poor teacher was humiliated. And of course, I got into (perhaps) the worst trouble of my life.

When I went to Mr Edey's office, an unspoken part of me feared the worst. Was I going to get suspended? Or expelled? What were my parents going to say? And as Mr Edey spelled out for me the gravity of my ill conduct, my self-worth lost all lustre and value. Then just at the point when I was sure that Mr Edey would take severe punitive action, a remarkable thing happened.

"Irvine," he said. "Do you know what 'Confortare Esto Vir' means?" "No," I whispered. "'Confortare Esto Vir' is the school motto. It means 'Take Courage and Be a Man'. Now I could punish you severely for your actions, but one thing I have learned is that punishment on it's own will not teach you anything. And I believe that at St David's, you have a great opportunity to learn, if you are willing to accept the lessons we teach." "Yes, Sir" I said, my morose eyes firmly fixed to the ground. "So Irvine, how would you take courage and be a man now?" Silence stretched out interminably whilst I groped for a suitable response. "Irvine?" "I uh, I suppose I should redo my accounting assignment." I dared a glance at Mr Edey, hoping that this would suffice. His stern glare did not waver one bit. "You need to do more." Inwardly, I plumbed the depths of desperation, whilst sweat burst into a frenzied sheen on my forehead. "I must say sorry to Mrs -?" "In writing," affirmed Mr Edey. "Today, you will write the letter right after detention. And you will redo your assignment tonight. Am I clear?" "Yessir! Sorry, sir!" Relief bloomed in my mind like fireworks in the night sky. Mr Edey nodded his dismissal, and I scurried towards the door on tremulous limbs. As I reached the door, Mr Edey called out "Irvine?" I turned and his sharp eyes caught mine firmly. "'Confortare Esto Vir'. Never forget these words, and what they mean."

I never forgot. Neither did Mr Edey.

In this Teacher/Student incident of prejudice, I believe that Mr Edey has tried to offer the teacher the same opportunity of redemption that I was offered. Because he is right: punitive action on its own will not teach the offender anything. Rather, it risks reinforcing the prejudices that have led the teacher to such offensive behaviour.

The castigation and exile being promulgated by some of your radio hosts is not the solution. In saying this, I am not making light of what has happened at St John's. The teacher's statements and actions are terrible in the extreme. But everyone deserves the opportunity to make amends. And how will this teacher do this if you destroy his life before he has a chance to change it?

Mr Edey is not leading poorly. He is not being soft-handed. He is not making light of racism. He is trying to change a terror, into something far better. For his bravery, and his conviction, Mr Edey deserves recognition and respect, however the St John's incident is resolved.

And for the compassion he showed me, even as he corrected my erroneous judgement, Mr Edey has won my love and my eternal support. Because he is a far better, far wiser man, than some of your poor pithy denouncements have made him out to be.

Yours Sincerely

Irvine Lehloo


702 welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the 702 community a safe and welcoming space for all.

702 reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

702 is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Reeva Steenkamp Foundation launches #BluePurpleBlack campaign for abuse victims

Reeva Steenkamp Foundation launches #BluePurpleBlack campaign for abuse victims

On Friday, Oscar Pistorius' sentence for killing girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp was increased from 6 years to 13 years and 5 months.

SAB launches #NoExcuse campaign to raise awareness against gender based violence

SAB launches #NoExcuse campaign to raise awareness against gender based violence

South African Breweries has launched its #NoExuse campaign ahead of 16 Days of Activism which begins on the 25 November.

Jethro Tait delivers an outstanding performance on #702Unplugged

Jethro Tait delivers an outstanding performance on #702Unplugged

Singer, songer and producer, Jethro Tait has penned songs for the winners of season 1 and 2 of 'The Voice SA '.

Zuma's guests who came for dinner

Zuma's guests who came for dinner

On Thursday evening, President Jacob Zuma hosted a working dinner with ANC presidential hopefuls.

Lesufi: Racist St John's teacher has left

Lesufi: Racist St John's teacher has left

Lesufi had earlier given school management until 1pm today to reverse its decision regarding a teacher found guilty of racism.

St John’s alumni speak out against alleged protection of racist teacher

St John’s alumni speak out against alleged protection of racist teacher

Sizwe Mpofu-Walsh and Markus Trengrove slam the school for lack of decisive action and council chairman Dr Jon Patricios explains.

Popular articles
So what exactly is radical economic transformation?

So what exactly is radical economic transformation?

Wits associate professor of economics Christopher Malikane speaks to Azania Mosaka about the term that is being bandied about.

Shop 'til you drop: The top 'Black Friday' deals this week

Shop 'til you drop: The top 'Black Friday' deals this week

Start your Christmas shopping off with a bang at these major retailers offering some impressive discounted sales for Black Friday.

Pamela Nomvete on her downfalls as actress, and 'climbing back'

Pamela Nomvete on her downfalls as actress, and 'climbing back'

This week Xolani Gwala's speaks to former Generations actor Pamela Nomvete for #WhatInTheWorldHappenedTo feature.

How Naspers paid peanuts for Tencent (China’s most valuable company)

How Naspers paid peanuts for Tencent (China’s most valuable company)

In 2001 Naspers invested $32 million in (then tiny) Tencent. Learn more about the wildly profitable Chinese behemoth...

'The university degree is dead'

'The university degree is dead'

Flux Trends founder Dion Chang gives five reasons why he believes getting a degree is past its sell by date.

3 easy questions could bag you R2000!

3 easy questions could bag you R2000!

WIN R2000! But only if you can prove you're a whiz of the MTN Biz Quiz by answering the following three questions...

Blesserfinder: Matching you with a sugar daddy near you

Blesserfinder: Matching you with a sugar daddy near you

Is social trend Blesserfinder, where girls are allegedly matching up with rich 'benefactors' in exchange for sex, a real thing?