Law expert answers big 'what-ifs' ahead of Zuma no confidence debate

Did you know that if the vote of no confidence in President Jacob Zuma is successful on Tuesday, National Assembly Speaker Baleka Mbete will have to fill his shoes for as long as a month?

Legal expert and political analyst Professor Richard Calland explains that, if Zuma is voted out, he and his Cabinet will have to vacate office, effective immediately.

The no confidence vote has immediate effect. Therefore the government has to step down and the Speaker (Baleka Mbete) would immediately become the acting president, according to the Constitution.

Professor Richard Calland, Public Law Lecturer at UCT

Read: If Baleka Mbete called Pierre de Vos for advice on the no confidence vote

The Constitution states that National Assembly would have to reconvene within 30 days in order to vote for a new president, under the watch of the Chief Justice (Mogoeng Mogoeng).

Calland explains that if Parliament failed to reach a decision on the right candidate to become President, then an early general election would have to be called.

He says that Mbete has lost her legitimacy amid questions about her conflict of interest as National Assembly Speaker and ANC's national chairperson.

He adds that in the case of a successful vote against Zuma, removed minsters could be re-appointed in the formation of a new Cabinet.

Also read: NEC decision to back Zuma 'ill-advised', says ANC MP Mondli Gungubele

Calland explored the outcomes of various scenarios, including:

  • if Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa is appointed President
  • if the secret ballot matter is taken on review
  • if the matter would be considered urgent by the courts
  • the potential political gains for opposition parties
  • the possible effects of the motion on ANC's December elective conference

The principle of rationality has become embedded in South African Constitutional law. It means the Speaker has to take into accuount evidence beofre er

Professor Richard Calland, Public Law Lecturer at UCT

The evidence that has been emerging over the last few months is evidence of a government that should no longer be in office and a President who is no longer fit.

Professor Richard Calland, Public Law Lecturer at UCT

What we really need is National Assembly to do its job and remove the President and government.

Professor Richard Calland, Public Law Lecturer at UCT

According to Calland, there should ideally be an open vote in Parliament in order to promote transparency and other democratic values.

He explained the difference between the no confidence debate (section 102 of the Constitution) and the uncharted territory of an impeachment bid (Section 89 of the Constitution).

Take a listen to his insights:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Law expert answers big 'what-ifs' ahead of Zuma no confidence debate


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
SABC TV news staffers threaten to strike over 'unlawful' production unit merger

SABC TV news staffers threaten to strike over 'unlawful' production unit merger

The Television News Technical Personnel say the SABC must undo the merger or news employees will go on strike, union Bemawu warns.

Cosatu: planned strike against state capture a unanimous decision

Cosatu: planned strike against state capture a unanimous decision

Cosatu general secretary Bheki Ntshalintshali says the federation is united in its call for nationwide strike action on Wednesday.

DA, Saftu warn Gigaba and co to keep hands off PIC funds

DA, Saftu warn Gigaba and co to keep hands off PIC funds

Saftu general-secretary Zwelinzima Vavi says Finance Minister Malusi Gigaba is part of the "Zuma-Zupta agenda for looting".

Ex Sars officials to seek legal recourse after KPMG bins Sars 'spy unit' report

Ex Sars officials to seek legal recourse after KPMG bins Sars 'spy unit' report

Former Sars spokesperson Adrian Lackay says KPMG's half-hearted apology leaves many questions unanswered.

Holomisa: ANC out order for threatening MPs over no confidence vote

Holomisa: ANC out order for threatening MPs over no confidence vote

UDM leader Bantu Holomisa has urged ANC members of Parliament to listen to the public outrage.

If Baleka Mbete called Pierre de Vos for advice on the no confidence vote

If Baleka Mbete called Pierre de Vos for advice on the no confidence vote

Constitutional Law Expert, Pierre de Vos explains how he would advise the Speaker of Parliament on the no confidence vote.

Popular articles
COVID-19 death toll rises to 18 in SA, cases at 1,845

COVID-19 death toll rises to 18 in SA, cases at 1,845

In a statement released on Wednesday night, the minister said the cases had gone up to 1,845.

Lockdown: Companies with good service on social media - and those without

Lockdown: Companies with good service on social media - and those without

Consumer journalist Wendy Knowler investigates which companies are meeting their customers’ needs on social media.

How to support outdoor entertainment indoors

How to support outdoor entertainment indoors

Theatres across the world have gone dark, but you can still support and watch the arts while at home

How did a single Netcare hospital become the epicentre of Covid-19 in KZN?

How did a single Netcare hospital become the epicentre of Covid-19 in KZN?

Bruce Whitfield interviews Richard Friedland, CEO at Netcare – owner of the hospital at the epicentre of KZN’s Covid-19 outbreak.

Expect no price hikes or shortages (except rice, pasta) from us - Tiger Brands

Expect no price hikes or shortages (except rice, pasta) from us - Tiger Brands

Tiger Brands CEO Noel Doyle assures South Africans that there are sufficient supplies of most of the company's products.

Dis-Chem launches drive-through COVID-19 testing sites

Dis-Chem launches drive-through COVID-19 testing sites

The company says the tests will cost R850 each and it may take 24 to 48 hours to get your results back.

#COVID-19: Old Mutual offers 4bn worth of free life cover to health workers

#COVID-19: Old Mutual offers 4bn worth of free life cover to health workers

The company is making it available to approximately 430,000 registered healthcare workers on the front-line of the pandemic.

Lockdown shelters in Tshwane helping reunite the homeless with their families

Lockdown shelters in Tshwane helping reunite the homeless with their families

Joanne Joseph speaks to City of Tshwane administrator spokesperson Omogolo Taunyane- Mnguni to find out more.

Only fruit and veg, fresh meat, grocery, spaza shop permits to be issued - Cogta

Only fruit and veg, fresh meat, grocery, spaza shop permits to be issued - Cogta

Deputy Minister Obed Bapela says permits fro cooked food will not be issued as well as furniture shots.

Savanna Virtual Comedy Bar launches on Thursday, featuring comedic heavyweights

Savanna Virtual Comedy Bar launches on Thursday, featuring comedic heavyweights

Bruce Whitfield and comedian John Vlismas share a few Covid-19 jokes and discuss the launch of the virtual comedy club.