Why we couldn’t prosecute Grace Mugabe

Grace Mugabe has officially been granted diplomatic immunity after her alleged assault on 20-year-old model Gabriella Engels.

She has now returned to Zimbabwe with President Robert Mugabe after the Southern Africa Development Community (SADC) Summit.

This raised many questions into how The Department of International Relations (Dirco) could grant the Zimbabwean first lady diplomatic immunity.

International criminal law expert, Ottilia Maunganidza, helps us decipher Dirco's decision.

READ: Grace Mugabe immunity: SA between ‘rock & hard place’

One of the biggest question to arise from Dirco Minister Maite Nkoana-Mashabane minutes declaring the diplomatic immunity was the fact that no specific date was given to indicate when the immunity starts.

Maunganidza says that official Government Gazette on the matter will give more clarity when it is released. However, Maunganidza says that from the minutes one can speculate when Mugabe's immunity began.

If the notice backdates to when the first lady arrived in South Africa in mid July, it would mean the immunity covers the incident. If it only covers when SADC Summit immunity period was, it means the immunity was granted just so she could leave the country.

Ottilia Maunganidza, International criminal law expert

Maunganidza says that since the alleged assault occurred before the SADC Summit or it pre-events, granting Mugabe immunity for that time raises issues into the scope of the immunity and whether it leave the door open for future prosecutions.

One of the considerations that were given in Dirco's notice was that of derivative immunity. Maunganidza explains that derivative immunity refers to people like diplomats, or in this case the First Lady of Zimbabwe, getting immunity based on their status and relationship to the primary immunity holder - the president.

Read: Government has failed us - mother of Gabriella Engels

From a criminal prosecution point of view, unless we see that immunity was just for the SADC Summit or whatever the case may be, it means that she is immune from prosecution if it covers the date of the assault.

Ottilia Maunganidza, International criminal law expert

Maunganidza says that there are different types of immunity which have to be clarified. She add that these can be contested.

For the Engels family, Maunganidza advises that further action against Mugabe would be to contest her diplomatic immunity. Maunganidza also says that the nature of Mugabe's citizenship could also play a role.

If Grace Mugabe is a South African citizen, she cannot have immunity.

Ottilia Maunganidza, International criminal law expert

Listen to the full explanation below:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI

702 welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the 702 community a safe and welcoming space for all.

702 reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

702 is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Is everything you say prefaced with your social labels? Listeners talk identity

Is everything you say prefaced with your social labels? Listeners talk identity

Can you express a view without announcing yourself as a member of a certain social group first? Eusebius opened a discussion.

[LISTEN] Sanitary towels added to proposed list of VAT zero-rated products

[LISTEN] Sanitary towels added to proposed list of VAT zero-rated products

An economist at Argon Asset Management Thabi Leoka explains how they came up with the proposed list for zero-rated products.

Ramaphosa has three months to hire new NPA boss, Abrahams' position invalid

Ramaphosa has three months to hire new NPA boss, Abrahams' position invalid

The ConCourt has confirmed that the appointment of Advocate Shaun Abrahams as prosecutions boss is constitutionally invalid.

Happiness and fulfillment aren't the same. A clinical psychologist enlightens

Happiness and fulfillment aren't the same. A clinical psychologist enlightens

Happiness is often linked to hedonism and can be a fleeting emotional state, says clinical psychologist Khosi Jiyane.

Debating Mbeki's economic legacy

Debating Mbeki's economic legacy

Pundits discuss how South Africa’s economic trajectory performed under former president Thabo Mbeki's administration.

 Multi-racial relationships in South Africa still draw attention say couples

Multi-racial relationships in South Africa still draw attention say couples

Couples in interracial relationships sit down to discuss the difficulties of being in such relationships.

Popular articles
'Minnie understood he might become a target'

'Minnie understood he might become a target'

Marianne Thamm wrote the forward to 'The Lost Boys of Bird Island' and worked with Mark Minnie in editing the controversial book.

[WATCH] Dad dresses up as a mom so his sons don't feel left out on Mother's Day

[WATCH] Dad dresses up as a mom so his sons don't feel left out on Mother's Day

Khabazela shares Facebook posts, YouTube videos that have gone viral including one with the smartest dogs.

How long should you wait for a funeral cover payout?

How long should you wait for a funeral cover payout?

Long-Term Insurance Ombudsman Jennifer Preiss explains some queries they receive with regards to funeral covers and payout times.

Nxasana questions why Minister Masutha's involvement is not being challenged

Nxasana questions why Minister Masutha's involvement is not being challenged

Former NDPP Mxolisi Nxasana says he didn't know the payout he received was a golden handshake.

'DA has a tough choice, ditch divisive leaders or face the ire of the voters'

'DA has a tough choice, ditch divisive leaders or face the ire of the voters'

Breakfast show host Bongani Bingwa reacts to the recent tweets by some DA leaders.

[LISTEN] Is your phone listening in on your conversations?

[LISTEN] Is your phone listening in on your conversations?

MD at World Wide Worx Arthur Goldstuck explains how your phone may record your voice conversations.

JHB CBD muggings - Where are the police ?

JHB CBD muggings - Where are the police ?

City of Joburg mayor Herman Mashaba says undocumented people living in the city make it difficult to combat crime.

DJ Zinhle answers deeply personal questions about her money

DJ Zinhle answers deeply personal questions about her money

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews DJ Zinhle about her attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.).

Castro bodyguard shares tales of dictator’s double life and breath-taking wealth

Castro bodyguard shares tales of dictator’s double life and breath-taking wealth

Juan Sanchez shares stories of Fidel Castro that’ll make you re-examine everything you thought you knew about the Cuban dictator.