Ramaphosa story raises ethical alarm bells, says media analyst

Motive and media ethics matter when publishing stories that involve leaked information, explains media analyst William Bird.

This comes after the Sunday Independent's reports that Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa had a number of affairs.

Ramaphosa failed in his attempt to stop the story from being published and the media house says its has copies of his emails to back the claims up.

Bird says the Sunday Independent's story did not outline how the emails were verified before taking it to print.

These things were not present in the story on Sunday. The Sunday Independent may well have checked the veracity of the emails, but there's certainly no indication of that in the story.

William Bird, Executive Director of Media Monitoring Africa

He says the story raises suspicions and has the potential to undermine the credibility of media.

It immediately should put up anyone's red lights...warning readers of those kinds of stories.

William Bird, Executive Director of Media Monitoring Africa

Whistleblowers and people who leak stories always have some kind of agenda.

William Bird, Executive Director of Media Monitoring Africa

Bird explains that the manner in which the story was published was not an ethical decision, but was still within the law.

He says the publication did not make an argument for public interest or show transparency about the agenda of the people who leaked the information.

Read: I have never met Cyril Ramaphosa in my entire life - Nonhlanhla Radebe

You should have the obligation to make those reasons and rational very clear to your readers.

William Bird, Executive Director of Media Monitoring Africa

Whether or not a senior public official is having an affair - unless it impacts directly on their work or if there's evidence of wrongdoing or force, then you have to say what's the public interets in exposing this information

William Bird, Executive Director of Media Monitoring Africa

According to Bird, the publication of the story may only serve a particular interest.

Also read: Ramaphosa allegations a political smear campaign, says Deputy Health Minister

Whoever leaked the Gupta emails, has an agenda as well.

William Bird, Executive Director of Media Monitoring Africa

He advises that readers test the story on its merits and question what agenda it serves.

Take a listen to the insightful discussion:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Ramaphosa story raises ethical alarm bells, says media analyst


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
I have never met Cyril Ramaphosa in my entire life - Nonhlanhla Radebe

I have never met Cyril Ramaphosa in my entire life - Nonhlanhla Radebe

ANC Chief Whip, Jackson Mthembu says the scandal against Cyril Ramaphosa clearly has some kind of political agenda.

Debate: As a public figure Cyril Ramaphosa is held to a higher standard...or not

Debate: As a public figure Cyril Ramaphosa is held to a higher standard...or not

Political analysts Karima Brown and Prince Mashele explain why Ramaphosa's personal affairs impact his presidential campaign.

Infidelity claims won't impede Ramaphosa's presidential bid - Brown

Infidelity claims won't impede Ramaphosa's presidential bid - Brown

Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa made a dramatic confession about an extramarital affair in attempts to clear his name.

Ramaphosa allegations a political smear campaign, says Deputy Health Minister

Ramaphosa allegations a political smear campaign, says Deputy Health Minister

The Sunday Independent reports that Ramaphosa has had a number of affairs and has copies of Ramaphosa’s emails to back this up.

Cosatu looks for candidate to unite alliance

Cosatu looks for candidate to unite alliance

Cosatu's Central Executive Committee is set to discuss how to bolster support for ANC presidential hopeful Cyril Ramaphosa.

Popular articles
Zondo commission's secretary implicated in Bosasa scandal - report

Zondo commission's secretary implicated in Bosasa scandal - report

Eusebius McKaiser spoke to investigative journalist at News24 Kyle Cowan on the latest developments in the inquiry.

Eusebius: 'We are living in a worse nightmare than we thought'

Eusebius: 'We are living in a worse nightmare than we thought'

Eusebius McKaiser shares his views on the former COO at Bosasa, Angelo Agrizz's testimony at the Zondo Commission.

Transnet receives R6.18 billion back from Chinese rail firm

Transnet receives R6.18 billion back from Chinese rail firm

Investigative Journalist at Amabhungane Susan Comrie says the advance payment was from a totally different contract.

Should Zimbabwe officially join South Africa in a monetary union?

Should Zimbabwe officially join South Africa in a monetary union?

What will happen to the rand if it does? Bruce Whitfield interviews Tim Nhamo, a currency specialist at Ironhead Trading.

South Africans are getting poorer and poorer

South Africans are getting poorer and poorer

It's not your imagination; we’ve lost a decade. Bruce Whitfield interviews Johann van Tonder, a researcher at Momentum.

ANC will lose some power in 2019, but Cyril will still be president - astrologer

ANC will lose some power in 2019, but Cyril will still be president - astrologer

Astrologer from Soul Direction Dawn Carter gives us a horoscope forecast for South Africa in 2019.

[WATCH] Baby hilariously tries to eat mom's burritos

[WATCH] Baby hilariously tries to eat mom's burritos

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

Bryan Habana opens up about money, and now having to buy his own clothes

Bryan Habana opens up about money, and now having to buy his own clothes

Bruce Whitfield interviews the legendary Springbok about his attitude toward money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.)