A Matter of Fact: Debunking AfriForum's farm murder stats

Africa Check's senior researcher, Kate Wilkinson returned to the Azania Mosaka Show on Monday to debunk some popular statements that may have been deemed factual.

Every month, listeners are granted the opportunity to submit claims often used in the public discourse and may want further clarity on.

Here are three reports submitted by listeners that need verification:

1) Can Kate refute or confirm Afriforum's claim that there are four times as many **murders on farmers than any other community, even the most crime-ridden African t**ownships or informal settlements?

AfriForum put out a statistic claiming the murder rate for farmers was four and a half times higher than South Africa citizens at a higher level.

Kate Wilkinson, senior researcher, Africa Check

Wilkinson notes that there is a significant difference between the number of murder and a murder rate which can be derived through a special calculation.

We know that in the last year we had statistics for farm murders in 2016/2017 there were 74 people who killed and recorded as farm murders by the police. Wilkinson adds that there are stations around the country that have recorded far more higher murders than 74 in a year.

If we look at the top station, in Nyanga, Western Cape they recorded 281 murders.

Kate Wilkinson, senior researcher, Africa Check

The number of farm murders may be higher. We'd need to know the size of the potential victim pool. The tricky thing with calculating a farm murder rate is we don't know how many people are living on farms in South Africa nor do we know how many farmer live in the country. We can't say for sure the AfriForum stats are accurate.

Kate Wilkinson, senior researcher, Africa Check

2) Can Africa Check refute or confirm Mayor Mashaba's claim that approx 80% of Johannesburg inner city Residents are foreign migrant Africans?

This a claim made by the mayor a number of times says Wilkinson. She says they got in touch with the mayor's office who said Mashaba's statements need to be based on his experience of hijacked buildings in the city of Johannesburg.

A survey done by the Gauteng City Region Observatory found that for people living in inner city wards, 26.2% had migrated from another country to Gauteng.

Kate Wilkinson, senior researcher, Africa Check

South African's who have moved to Gauteng, was found to be at 25.4%. This doesn't support the mayors statements.

Kate Wilkinson, senior researcher, Africa Check

A report done by the City's Social Development Department based on five raids of buildings in Doornfontein in 2017 found that of the 183 residents profile only 30.6% of them were foreign nationals explains Wilkinson.

3) Is it a fact that South Africans are the 2nd most obese nation in the world after the US? Question from Oscar Olifant

We are not the second most obese country in the world.

Kate Wilkinson, senior researcher, Africa Check

Listen to the clip below for more facts checked:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI

702 welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the 702 community a safe and welcoming space for all.

702 reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

702 is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Top three fake facts for October

Top three fake facts for October

Africa Check's senior researcher, Kate Wilkinson returns to the Azania Mosaka Show fact check some popular statements and stats.

'More black farm workers are killed than white farm workers'  - Johan Burger

'More black farm workers are killed than white farm workers'  - Johan Burger

Following a spate of farm murders in the Cape, the policing expert says there aren't enough stats available on farm killings.

Joburg may be the largest man-made urban forest in the world

Joburg may be the largest man-made urban forest in the world

Johannesburg is the largest landlocked city in the world and has more than 10 million trees.

Africa Check confirms President got most of his facts right

Africa Check confirms President got most of his facts right

Africa Check fact-checked every bit of President Jacob Zuma's State of the Nation Address (Sona).

South Africans among Africa's biggest drinkers

South Africans among Africa's biggest drinkers

Africa Check have confirmed that South Africa is on the top 6 of Africa's biggest drinkers list.

CNN chose facts over ratings - Africa Check

CNN chose facts over ratings - Africa Check

CNN did not air White House Press Secretary's statement live but only reported about it after monitoring facts says researcher.

When you find out this is true, it will make you angry

When you find out this is true, it will make you angry

There is no shortage of news stories, but determining which are true is no simple matter.

Meet Jo Rust, biker chic

Meet Jo Rust, biker chic

Once there was a waitress in an Italian restaurant who decided that she would circumnavigate Africa on a motorbike...

Which political party would you vote for based on facts?

Which political party would you vote for based on facts?

Kate Wilkinson, senior researcher at Africa Check, tackles some of the inaccurate statements that political parties make.

Crime stats: 2014/5 figures paint bleak picture of safety in SA

Crime stats: 2014/5 figures paint bleak picture of safety in SA

There's been an increase in the number of murders in South Africa for a third consecutive year, according to the crime statistics released in Parliament.

Popular articles
 In the market for a 2nd hand car? Here are some tips to buy it on a budget!

In the market for a 2nd hand car? Here are some tips to buy it on a budget!

In the car feature, our very own car guy Tumelo Maketekete shares some tips and tricks to buying a car on a R100 000 budget.

Vigilante mob attacks alleged criminals in Daveyton

Vigilante mob attacks alleged criminals in Daveyton

Tensions are rife in the East Joburg township as the community attacked and killed criminals.

[WATCH] Dad uses a drone to pull out son's tooth

[WATCH] Dad uses a drone to pull out son's tooth

Khabazela shares YouTube videos gone viral including a barmaid hitting a colleague who slapped her rear during a routine.

[Listen] Lottery responds to Tshepo's fraud claims

[Listen] Lottery responds to Tshepo's fraud claims

Philemon Letwaba says Tshepo's case relates to some of the issues that they are dealing with on a daily basis.

[WATCH] Is it a cow's penis or an udder? Well, this kid thinks it's a penis

[WATCH] Is it a cow's penis or an udder? Well, this kid thinks it's a penis

Check out the videos, tweets, Facebook posts that have gone viral and why this kid cheered her dad on in the toilet.