'Zuma's judgments reveal how he has attempted to defend the indefensible'

The question of judicial and executive overreach has been at the centre of mounting legal action against the Presidency and Parliament over the past year.

This week, the High Court in Pretoria dismissed President Jacob Zuma’s application to set aside and review the Public Protector’s remedial action given in the State of Capture report.

READ: Zuma must pay costs for bid to halt state capture report

Last week, a High Court also ordered that National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) head Shaun Abrahams leave office and be replaced within 60 days.

ALSO READ: Shaun Abrahams must go (and JZ can’t appoint his replacement) – High Court

There have been other landmark cases in this year alone, including a Constitutional Court ruling over a secret ballot vote and more.

Eusebius Mckaiser spoke to senior journalist Karyn Maughan and Professor James Grant, associate professor of law at Wits University.

Right from the outset, we are a society which has declared itself to be a political enterprise, which is ultimately controlled by law, so there is nothing surprising about that.

Prof James Grant, associate professor of law at Wits University

In an ideal society, we would not be getting involved, but we are constitutionally obligated to intervene when state institutions are making irrational decisions that have impact.

Karyn Maughan, journalist

Speaking on the so-called 'legal fall' of Zuma, Grant and Maughan agree that the judgment on cases involving the President often revealed how he has attempted to defend the indefensible.

Remember in the Nxasana matter, the court went into great detail about the President's legal pathology...that ruling was built on all these legal corpses that have defined all the bodies left behind by all the President's previous cases where there was this culture of fight, fight, fight. Defend what you ultimately concede is the indefensible, and at the last minute say, sorry guys ,got it wrong.

Karyn Maughan, journalist

The words that Karyn has used again, the court literally used those words, that the President is now known for defending the indefensible.

Prof James Grant, associate professor of law at Wits University

Click on the link below here the full conversation....


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI

702 welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the 702 community a safe and welcoming space for all.

702 reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

702 is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
'ANC response to state capture judgment is a subtext that Zuma shouldn't appeal'

'ANC response to state capture judgment is a subtext that Zuma shouldn't appeal'

Karima Brown gives her take on a ruling that President Jacob Zuma must establish a judicial commission of inquiry within 30 days.

#StateCaptureJudgment could cause reputational damage to the ANC

#StateCaptureJudgment could cause reputational damage to the ANC

With only two days left til the ANC Elective Conference, this judgment could cause Zuma further harm, says Natasha Marrian.

Pravin Gordhan calls for corruption to be punished

Pravin Gordhan calls for corruption to be punished

Gordhan says the North Gauteng High Court's state of capture ruling is again an indication that state capture and corruption is a reality in South Africa.

'Judgment pits President Zuma against Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa'

'Judgment pits President Zuma against Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa'

Political analyst Ralph Mathegka weighs in on Friday's Nxasana judgment.

High Court: Zuma abused court process in order to reap benefits for his own good

High Court: Zuma abused court process in order to reap benefits for his own good

EWN reporter Barry Bateman reports that the Presidency is asking for leave to appeal the NPA Nxasana and Abrahams judgment.

[WATCH] What movie title would you give the court's NPA ruling asks Bongani?

[WATCH] What movie title would you give the court's NPA ruling asks Bongani?

Bongani Bingwa asked listeners for their take on the matter.

Shaun Abrahams must go (and JZ can’t appoint his replacement) – High Court

Shaun Abrahams must go (and JZ can’t appoint his replacement) – High Court

Shaun Abrahams must go, and Presidnet Jacob Zuma may not appoint his replacement. So ruled the Pretoria High Court on Friday.

 Mxolisi Nxasana says he was forced from his position at NPA

Mxolisi Nxasana says he was forced from his position at NPA

Nicole Fritz, of Freedom Under Law talks on Nxasana claim that he was outed from National Director of Public Prosecutions position

Popular articles
Each year rich countries waste as much food as sub-Saharan Africa produces

Each year rich countries waste as much food as sub-Saharan Africa produces

We waste a third of all food produced. If we avoid 25% of that wastage, it could feed 870 million hungry mouths.

Land expropriation can succeed if no productive land is taken – Land Bank

Land expropriation can succeed if no productive land is taken – Land Bank

The process must also be corruption free, the bank said. Bruce Whitfield interviews Land Bank CEO TP Nchocho.

ConCourt to rule on law that governs the right to protest

ConCourt to rule on law that governs the right to protest

Civil rights groups claim that the Regulation of Gatherings Act limits and criminalises peaceful protest through intimidation.

[LISTEN] 'Its high time churches moved forward on same-sex couples'

[LISTEN] 'Its high time churches moved forward on same-sex couples'

Reverend Laurie Gaum Dominee at the Dutch Reformed Church says churches should embrace the diversity of people's sexuality.

[LISTEN] Fears that new deal with Cape Town brewery may monopolise SA craft beer

[LISTEN] Fears that new deal with Cape Town brewery may monopolise SA craft beer

A Cape Town-based brewing company and The Tap Room have signed a deal to buy around 700 installed draught taps around SA.

Questions raised over qualifications of Tshwane EMS Head

Questions raised over qualifications of Tshwane EMS Head

SAMWU members allege that EMS head Previn Govender misrepresented his credentials.

As a matter of fact: Has the murder rate for women in SA spiked by 117%?

As a matter of fact: Has the murder rate for women in SA spiked by 117%?

The claim of a 117% rise in the killing of women in South Africa since 2015 was revealed during an Al Jazeera news programme.

Man who admitted to killing 13-year-old CPT schoolgirl handed life sentence

Man who admitted to killing 13-year-old CPT schoolgirl handed life sentence

Andrew Plaatjies was handed two concurrent life sentences after admitting to the murder and attempted rape of the teenage girl.

[LISTEN] 'State institutions were sacrificed to protect individuals within ANC'

[LISTEN] 'State institutions were sacrificed to protect individuals within ANC'

The amaBhungane Centre for Investigative Journalism's Sam Sole explains how we got where we are with State Capture.

[LISTEN] Family of four to pay almost R3 000 for food 'staples' in 2019

[LISTEN] Family of four to pay almost R3 000 for food 'staples' in 2019

BFAP food price specialist Marlene Louw explains the 2018-2027 baseline data on food prices.