Opinion: 'If you are going to apply legal principles call a spade a spade'

There has been mixed public reaction to the High Court ruling prohibiting the placement of 55 English-speaking learners in Höerskool Overvaal in Vereeniging, with some accusing Judge Bill Prinsloo of bias.

The judge found that the department did not have the authority to unilaterally override the school’s language policy and that it failed to assess the school’s capacity to accommodate the pupils.

READ: High Court sets aside GP Edu Dept instruction in Afrikaans school case

702's Breakfast Show host Bongani Bingwa had this to say.

At the heart of Prinsloo's decision was procedure not principle. He found that the district director Chriselda Makhubela had tried to intimidate English speaking schools in the area to say they didn't have capacity to take the learners thus forcing Overvaal to be their only option.

Bongani Bingwa, 702 Breakfast host

At the end of the day, though the courts can only make decisions based on due process, they do things by the book, there may well be merit in the MEC's view of the school. But ultimately if there was undue influence and bias found by the judge they lost the case with cost on procedure not principle.

Bongani Bingwa, 702 Breakfast host

You may have your euphemisms and not call things what they really are but if you are going to apply legal principles, you better make sure you call a spade a spade.

Bongani Bingwa, 702 Breakfast host

Click on the link below to listen to Bongani's full comment....


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Dan Plato: It is a case of taking the people of the city, the voters with you

Dan Plato: It is a case of taking the people of the city, the voters with you

Incoming Executive Mayor in the City of Cape Town Dan Plato says he is honoured to become the next mayor for the city.

[WATCH] From Venezuelan president's fine dining, to a hyena and buffalo battle

[WATCH] From Venezuelan president's fine dining, to a hyena and buffalo battle

Khabazela shares some of the most popular tweets, posts, and videos on 'What's gone viral'.

How to win the battle against crime in Gauteng

How to win the battle against crime in Gauteng

Gauteng Community Safety MEC Sizakele Nkosi-Malobane says law enforcement agencies need to double their efforts to curb crime.

High Court sets aside GP Edu Dept instruction in Afrikaans school case

High Court sets aside GP Edu Dept instruction in Afrikaans school case

Judge Bill Prinsloo has found that the department did not have the authority to unilaterally override the school’s language policy and that it failed to assess the school’s capacity to accommodate the pupils.

Gauteng Education says language and capacity no excuse to turn away pupils

Gauteng Education says language and capacity no excuse to turn away pupils

The department has been making arguments in the High Court in Pretoria in a battle against Afrikaans school Hoërskool Overvaal.

Hoërskool Overvaal vs Gauteng Education court battle postponed

Hoërskool Overvaal vs Gauteng Education court battle postponed

The Education Department argues that the school is using its Afrikaans language policy to exclude black English speaking learners.

Popular articles
Hits from the bong (it’s legal!)… then off to work I go?

Hits from the bong (it’s legal!)… then off to work I go?

The consequences of consuming dagga at home and showing up at the office high. Bruce Whitfield interviews a labour lawyer.

Tax ombud to probe Sars – yet again - after taxpayers complain

Tax ombud to probe Sars – yet again - after taxpayers complain

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Adv. Eric Mkhawane, CEO at the Office of the Tax Ombud.

[LISTEN] 'Lesufi has been attacking Afrikaans schools since 2014'

[LISTEN] 'Lesufi has been attacking Afrikaans schools since 2014'

The Freedom Front Plus says the Gauteng Education MEC has flouted school language policies and is destroying Afrikaans.

'We can barely enforce tobacco legislation, how will we to deal with dagga?'

'We can barely enforce tobacco legislation, how will we to deal with dagga?'

International law enforcement expert and former Drug Unit Commander Lobo das Neves says ruling opens a different can of worms.

Comair reports record earnings, 72nd profitable year in a row – a world record!

Comair reports record earnings, 72nd profitable year in a row – a world record!

Recession, soaring fuel costs and surplus capacity - yet profits keep coming! Bruce Whitfield interviews Comair CEO Erik Venter.

Basic Education to introduce Kiswahili and coding to SA's curriculum

Basic Education to introduce Kiswahili and coding to SA's curriculum

Basic Education spokesperson Elijah Mhlanga spoke to Joanne Joseph on the Afternoon Drive to elaborate.