FUL: If Nxasana's settlement is unlawful, Abrahams appointment is invalid

The Constitutional Court on Wednesday is hearing argument on whether or not the appointment of National Prosecuting Authority boss Shaun Abrahams was unconstitutional.

Abrahams is challenging the judgment relating to the golden handshake that was awarded to former NPA head Mxolisi Nxasana. A full bench set aside Nxasana's settlement and ordered him to pay back the over R10 million he received as part of his exit package. t the same time, it found Abrahams' appointment was invalid.

EWN reporter Barry Bateman explains that the Nxasana and Abraham's case are closely intertwined.

He says the argument presented in court is that if the settlement awarded to Nxasana was unlawful and set aside by the courts, it subsequently created a situation where there was no vacancy to fill, which means Abrahams appointment had also been unlawful.

The big part of the argument has come from Freedom Under Law which relates to the question of the settlement of Nxasana and the impact this had on the appointment of Shaun Abrahams.

Barry Bateman, EWN reporter

Bateman says that there was no evidence of Nxasana submitting a request to the President to resign, which the president should in turn accept.

Instead, correspondence revealed that it was President Zuma who used tactics to try to get Nxasana to leave office.

There was a commission of inquiry into Nxasana's fitness to hold office, when that failed he came up with negotiations around settlement amounts that he is going to leave.

Barry Bateman, EWN reporter

In summing up the argument... Zuma abused his power to get rid of one NDPP and replace him with another. They say by so doing he violated the constitutional requirement of prosecutorial independence enshrined in the Constitution and the National Prosecuting Act.

Barry Bateman, EWN reporter

He unlawfully used public money to have his way and he did this all for his personal benefit and in order to minimise his risk of prosecution.

Barry Bateman, EWN reporter

To hear the rest of the report by Barry Bateman, listen below:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : FUL: If Nxasana's settlement is unlawful, Abrahams appointment is invalid


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI

702 welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the 702 community a safe and welcoming space for all.

702 reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

702 is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
South Africa is the 71st (out of 180) most corrupt country in the world

South Africa is the 71st (out of 180) most corrupt country in the world

Botswana (34th) and Namibia (53rd) are squeaky clean in comparison. Bruce Whitfield interviews ENS Africa's Steven Powell.

[LISTEN] Abrahams remains NDPP despite withdrawal of appeal - expert

[LISTEN] Abrahams remains NDPP despite withdrawal of appeal - expert

On Friday, the president withdrew an appeal against a High Court judgment that NPA boss Shaun Abrahams should vacate his position.

Abrahams to announce decision on Zuma charges soon

Abrahams to announce decision on Zuma charges soon

The State attorney has sent a letter to lobby group Casac.

Former KZN Hawks boss opens criminal case against Shaun Abrahams and his No.2

Former KZN Hawks boss opens criminal case against Shaun Abrahams and his No.2

The matter relates to the decision to withdraw fraud and perjury charges against NPA boss Abrahams’ deputy Nomgcobo Jiba in 2015.

Judge Kriegler: It's not about Nxasana, but the legalities of Zuma's conduct

Judge Kriegler: It's not about Nxasana, but the legalities of Zuma's conduct

Three prominent civil societies head to the court to seek Nxasana's reinstatement as the NDPP.

[LISTEN] NPA sets record straight on Prasa, but Zackie Achmat remains firm

[LISTEN] NPA sets record straight on Prasa, but Zackie Achmat remains firm

The NPA responds to statements made by activist and leader of #UniteBehind Zackie Achmat made in an interview on Wednesday.

[LISTEN] We can't rely on Shaun Abrahams

[LISTEN] We can't rely on Shaun Abrahams

Civil society groups want Mxolisi Nxasana re-instated as head of the National Prosecuting Authority.

Why Ramaphosa's hands are tied over replacing Shaun Abrahams (until next week)

Why Ramaphosa's hands are tied over replacing Shaun Abrahams (until next week)

Casac has asked the national prosecutions boss to wait until after next week's ConCourt ruling before deciding on Zuma's fate.

Why it won't be easy for Ramaphosa to get rid of embattled Sars and NPA bosses

Why it won't be easy for Ramaphosa to get rid of embattled Sars and NPA bosses

A labour lawyer says senior officials can only be removed through disciplinary processes or by striking an early termination deal.

All eyes on Shaun Abrahams as SCA hands down judgment in Zuma's bid to appeal

All eyes on Shaun Abrahams as SCA hands down judgment in Zuma's bid to appeal

Political analyst Karima Brown says the NPA has the final say on whether Zuma can challenge the decision to reinstate charges.

Tom Monyane denies opening criminal case against Pravin Gordhan

Tom Monyane denies opening criminal case against Pravin Gordhan

EWN Senior reporter Barry Bateman says the allegations were made in an affidavit by Sars official, Vlok Symington.

Is Gordhan's firm stance forcing NPA's Shaun Abrahams to back down?

Is Gordhan's firm stance forcing NPA's Shaun Abrahams to back down?

Gordhan has remained resolute and refused to make submissions to NPA on the on fraud charges by yesterday's 5pm deadline.

Popular articles
 The law must change to enable the donation of tons of food going to waste

The law must change to enable the donation of tons of food going to waste

Tatjana von Bormann says the sell-by date and the use by dates are indeed one of the causes unnecessary food waste.

[LISTEN] Black Sash in court to fight against grant deductions

[LISTEN] Black Sash in court to fight against grant deductions

The Black Sash's Lynette Maart says there is an urgent need to protect grant beneficiaries from exploitation.

'Citizens have a right to ask for identification from police during a roadblock'

'Citizens have a right to ask for identification from police during a roadblock'

Major General Michael Mohlala explains the procedure of conducting a roadblock and what to do when you are stopped.

Calls for government to prioritise finding missing fisherman

Calls for government to prioritise finding missing fisherman

Community representative says the allocation of fishing rights is secondary and all they want is to find the missing fisherman.

Gold Fields release financials after job cut announcement

Gold Fields release financials after job cut announcement

Gold Fields spokesperson Sven Lunsche says the company's financial results show that their other mines are doing well.

Marikana widow: 'Priority given to 34 victims but 10 families being ignored'

Marikana widow: 'Priority given to 34 victims but 10 families being ignored'

Widow Of Lonmin security guard at Marikana says life is hard now that she has to live off one salary.

Trollip's job safe for now as no-confidence motion postponed

Trollip's job safe for now as no-confidence motion postponed

The ANC, EFF and other parties were not able to bring their fourth motion of no confidence against NMB Mayor Athol Trollip.

'We are almost done with the Farlam Commission recommendation on Marikana'

'We are almost done with the Farlam Commission recommendation on Marikana'

Police Minister Bheke Cele says all recommendations by the Farlam Commission of Inquiry will be honoured and implemented.

[LISTEN] Is it important to ask: how are you?

[LISTEN] Is it important to ask: how are you?

Callers on the open line debate whether it's inappropriate to greet or not.

'We need history that is able to integrate black and white cricket'

'We need history that is able to integrate black and white cricket'

Eusebius McKaiser hosts a discussion about cricket and society with pundits Lewis Manthata and Ashwin Desai.