Sars Lawyer: Tom Moyane did not break the law

Sars commissioner Tom Moyane has come under fire for authorising a a R70-million VAT refund to a Gupta-linked company through a third party. He has been accused of money laundering.

Erick Smith, Legal Specialist at Sars says that under no circumstances was the law broken when making these payouts. READ: Fresh claims Tom Moyane fast-tracked fake R70m VAT payments to Gutpas

I can assure you that whilst there were different legal interpretations on the manner of which a VAT refund must be paid, I reinterate, the VAT refund was due and payable by law to the tax payer in this matter.

Erick Smith, Sars Legal Specialist

There was absolutely no transgression of the law in the payment to the tax payer in this case.

Erick Smith, Sars Legal Specialist

Smith says that Moyane's involvement in the payout is also within the bounds of the law, as he is the accountable office within Sars.

According to Smith, normally tax payers escalate their frustrations and concerns to the commissioner, but it is normally dealt with by the legal team.

[WATCH] 'Tom Moyane is a liar' - Kieno Kammies

As to the allegations of wrongdoing and evidence showing top officials warning that these payments would be highly irregular, Smith says that boils down to differences in legal interpretation.

And the issue of third party payments?

I can tell you quite openly that I was one of the legal specialists who had a different interpretation as to whether a taxpayer can be refunded to a third party bank account. Because of the Sars Act, in an attempt to prevent fraud and payments going to the wrong bank account - we had a view that we could not pay a refund to a particular account nominated by the taxpayer in this case.

Erick Smith, Sars Legal Specialist

But there has been an earlier interpretation, by a very senior tax specialist within Sars which invoked another provisional act, which provides for anomalous circumstances. And in those circumstances, the commissioner, through his official, can use his discretion to deal with anomalies.

Erick Smith, Sars Legal Specialist

Smith says this case had an usual set of circumstances. He adds that they money was due and they had to pay it. The only difficulties Sars faced was the interpretation regarding which account the money should be paid to, according to Smith.

In this case, the money was due and payable. It had been through a though audit process - so we had to pay the money.

Erick Smith, Sars Legal Specialist

The Guptas were given no favour.

Erick Smith, Sars Legal Specialist

Listen to the full report below:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
[WATCH] 'Tom Moyane is a liar' - Kieno Kammies

[WATCH] 'Tom Moyane is a liar' - Kieno Kammies

CapeTalk's Kieno Kammies expresses outrage at the Sars commissioner allegedly paying millions in VAT refunds to the Guptas.

Fresh claims Tom Moyane fast-tracked fake R70m VAT payments to Gutpas

Fresh claims Tom Moyane fast-tracked fake R70m VAT payments to Gutpas

The Daily Maverick's Scorpio unit says more than R70-million was paid through third party payments for the benefit of Oakbay.

Sars commissioner Moyane wastes no time replacing Makwakwa

Sars commissioner Moyane wastes no time replacing Makwakwa

Robert Kingon has been appointed to the position of acting Chief Officer for Business and Individual Taxes.

Sars has been in the news for all the wrong reasons - Treasury

Sars has been in the news for all the wrong reasons - Treasury

Treasury has welcomed the resignation of Sars senior tax official Jonas Makwakwa.

Allegations against former Sars officials are baseless - Freedom Under Law

Allegations against former Sars officials are baseless - Freedom Under Law

Judge Kriegler says the allegations are the same as when Tom Moyane was appointed commissioner and wanted to get rid of senior staff.

Popular articles
No traffic and everyone’s at home… Some short-term insurers offer lower premiums

No traffic and everyone’s at home… Some short-term insurers offer lower premiums

Short-term insurers suddenly carry a massively reduced risk burden, says consumer journalist Wendy Knowler. Getting some back?

A tipping point for video conferencing

A tipping point for video conferencing

A business tool for older generations, a staple for younger ones

Total number of positive coronavirus cases rises to 1,380

Total number of positive coronavirus cases rises to 1,380

This is an increase of 27 cases from Tuesday's announcement. Health Minister Zweli Mkhize has tested negative for the virus.

What is an 'economic depression'? Are we heading for one? Lessons from history…

What is an 'economic depression'? Are we heading for one? Lessons from history…

The Great Depression started 91 years ago and changed everything. Bruce Whitfield speaks to economic historian Keith Breckenridge.

Sars collects R1.4tr in taxes – up 5.3% on a year before, despite the recession

Sars collects R1.4tr in taxes – up 5.3% on a year before, despite the recession

Despite the achievement, the country still lost R100 billion in uncollected taxes, says Commissioner Edward Kieswetter.

Struggling to pay a debt? Your options: credit insurance vs debt relief holiday

Struggling to pay a debt? Your options: credit insurance vs debt relief holiday

Personal Finance expert Maya Fischer-French on the pros/cons of dipping into credit insurance vs opting for a debt relief holiday.

Absa launches extensive Covid-19 payment relief programme

Absa launches extensive Covid-19 payment relief programme

Absa is providing payment relief to its retail clients as well as its business banking and wealth customers.

'Gita Ramjee was probably one of the most remarkable women you would have met'

'Gita Ramjee was probably one of the most remarkable women you would have met'

The revered South African HIV scientist passed away at a Durban hospital on Tuesday after COVID-19-related complications.

[LOCKDOWN] Sars outlines measures to cushion the COVID-19 blow

[LOCKDOWN] Sars outlines measures to cushion the COVID-19 blow

Commissioner Edward Kieswetter says they have diverted customers to their online channels and contact centres.

How to communicate with frustrated children during lockdown

How to communicate with frustrated children during lockdown

Fair Practice Mediation Services director advocate Veerash Srikison says communication can breakdown in families during this time.