Words have the power to harm - but does the punishment fit the crime?

Eusebius McKaiser posed a question to listeners on whether a person should be jailed for their what they say.

This comes after convicted racist Vicki Momberg was sentenced to three years imprisonment with one year suspended by the Randburg Magistrates Court last week.

She was videoed shouting racial slurs at a black police officer who was trying to assist her after she was involved in an alleged smash and grab incident.

Momberg was found guilty of four counts of crimen injuria in November 2017.

Callers also shared their thoughts on the matter. Thembi said she thought Momberg was going to get a short sentence and was shocked at first.

But now I am happy she got two years because this will actually teach people what they teach their children (is important). Teaching your child how to say the K-word could actually land them in jail one day and get them a criminal record.

Thembi, caller

She said her sister in law witnessed two young children swearing at a mother and child at the traffic lights but says hopefully now after the Momberg sentencing people will think twice.

Kefilwe, another caller said she is prepared to put her neck on the line to say that you should go to jail.

The reason I say that is that to be gay in South Africa is life-threatening and that is because of the gravitas of the word itself and the amount of hate that people have to people that are not like them and especially amongst Africans. So for me personally, I would like to see somebody going to jail for calling somebody a 'stabani'.

Kefilwe, caller

She said we need to define what the issue is behind the word.

The word in itself might be innocuous just a six letter word, but when you have institutionalised racism and you have people like Mark Lembertiy calling a fully qualified woman, a BEE candidate, someone who didn't deserve the position that she is in and 30 people don't stand up and say no Mark you are wrong, then you basically are going to keep producing more Vicki Mombergs.

Kefilwe, caller

A caller Albert talked about the importance of 'tone'. He said it goes beyond the impact of a word like the K-word. He described how he has experienced negative body language from white people that has felt as abusive. It goes beyond words and also lies in attitude.

They need to change their attitude. They will use the word 'black' and the tone will not be OK.

Albert, caller

Words can scar us emotionally, and can even make us suicidal. But what is the appropriate societal punishment for that?

Eusebius McKaiser, 702/CapeTalk anchor

Listen further below to this insightful debate:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Letter to my 'big sister': From Graça Machel to Winnie Madikizela-Mandela

Letter to my 'big sister': From Graça Machel to Winnie Madikizela-Mandela

Nelson Mandela's widow Graça Machel has written an open letter paying tribute to struggle icon Winnie Madikizela-Mandela.

Black Coffee receives backlash for performing in Israel

Black Coffee receives backlash for performing in Israel

Callers to the Eusebius McKaiser Show on Wednesday responded to the backlash over the DJ's recent gig in Israel.

She was human, she made mistakes and she was the epitome of imbokodo

She was human, she made mistakes and she was the epitome of imbokodo

Emotional callers pay tribute to the life of Winnie Madikizela Mandela on The Eusebius McKaiser Show.

8 interesting facts about the Two Oceans Marathon and how it's evolved

8 interesting facts about the Two Oceans Marathon and how it's evolved

General Manager at Old Mutual Two Oceans Marathon, Carol Vosloo, shares facts, figures and trivia about the iconic race event.

Catch The Naked Scientist live in 702 Joburg studio on Thursday

Catch The Naked Scientist live in 702 Joburg studio on Thursday

Chris Smith, better known as The Naked Scientist, will be live in the Joburg studio with Eusebius from 10am.

Caller: White people are afraid of transformation

Caller: White people are afraid of transformation

A caller shares her frustration at the response by white people of the news that Stephen Grootes is leaving 702.

Cleanliness is key to combating listeriosis

Cleanliness is key to combating listeriosis

Microbiologist explains how to preventing spreading listeriosis.

Eusebius says EFF misread the moment by walking out on President's election

Eusebius says EFF misread the moment by walking out on President's election

Eusebius Mckaiser asked callers what they thought of how opposition parties conducted themselves in yesterday's election.

[WATCH] The country is on tenterhooks over Zuma's exit  says Eusebius

[WATCH] The country is on tenterhooks over Zuma's exit says Eusebius

Eusebius McKaiser sets the tone for the open-line with some of the latest news headlines.

#TheEusebiusMcKaiserShow: 2017's biggest stories and most cringe-worthy moments

#TheEusebiusMcKaiserShow: 2017's biggest stories and most cringe-worthy moments

Eusebius and his callers share what they think were the biggest news stories and memorable on-air moments this year.

[WATCH] Bongani asks what's that one word you struggle to spell?

[WATCH] Bongani asks what's that one word you struggle to spell?

Bongani Bingwa kicked off the open line with conversation on words that we often struggle to spell.

Popular articles
R400m is absolute nonsense, insists CR17 campaign member

R400m is absolute nonsense, insists CR17 campaign member

Ramaphosa's former campaign member Dr James Motlatsi says he is the one who asked Gavin Watson for a donation, not the president.

Cape Town man found alive in eSwatini, believed dead for 6 years

Cape Town man found alive in eSwatini, believed dead for 6 years

His family believed he had died and performed a memorial service for him but now they are struggling to get him back home.

Public Protector has now become a "rogue unit", says Judge Kriegler

Public Protector has now become a "rogue unit", says Judge Kriegler

Busisiwe Mkhwebane is reportedly probing President Cyril Ramaphosa for alleged money laundering to the tune of R400m.

[WATCH] Sho Madjozi first female South African to win BET award

[WATCH] Sho Madjozi first female South African to win BET award

The rapper, singer and songwriting superstar walked away with the best new international act on Sunday evening in Los Angeles.

Rand Water: 'Don't panic, there will be water!'

Rand Water: 'Don't panic, there will be water!'

Spokesperson Justice Mohale explains that only one purification plant will be affected by the company's planned maintenance.

Gauteng waitress gets R18,000 tip for 'amazing service'

Gauteng waitress gets R18,000 tip for 'amazing service'

A waitress at The Beerhouse in Fourways who received the generous donation wants to finish her matric and become a paramedic.

[WATCH] Looks like 'Mabena' found his way to Sona and Mzansi had a good chuckle

[WATCH] Looks like 'Mabena' found his way to Sona and Mzansi had a good chuckle

The name Mabena has become synonymous with out of step and clumsy soldiers, and it seems one made an appearance at Parliament.

How long to keep tax records available for inspection in South Africa

How long to keep tax records available for inspection in South Africa

Should you keep them "forever"? Tax expert Chris Sloane on the requirement to keep tax records available for inspection by Sars.

Your employer can ask your doctor to write an affidavit to support a sick note

Your employer can ask your doctor to write an affidavit to support a sick note

Law says if a traditional healer is part of medical council with a registered number he or she can write a medical certificate.