Tom Moyane's lawyers want Kate O'Regan to recuse herself from his inquiry

The lawyers of suspended SARS Commissioner Tom Moyane want former Constitutional Court justice Kate O’Regan to recuse herself from deciding whether he should be dismissed saying the retired judge may fail to be impartial because of her links to Corruption Watch.

O'Regan serves as a board member of the organisation which has lambasted Moyane, accusing him of damaging the integrity and credibility of the revenue service.

The suspended revenue service head faces 12 charges of alleged misconduct.

READ: 'The president won't buckle to any demands by Tom Moyane's legal team'

Eric Mabuza, the lawyer representing Moyane, explains why the judge should not be tasked with presiding over the inquiry.

Corruption Watch has issued statements that Mr Moyane must be arrested and in issuing those statements there is no doubt that the judge herself identifies with those statements.

Eric Mabuza, lawyer representing Tom Moyane

You must remember that the test to check whether someone is going to be fair is not whether they are going to be biased, it is whether in the mind of a reasonable person there s a perception of bias.

Eric Mabuza, lawyer representing Tom Moyane

Meanwhile Executive Secretary of the Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution (CASAC), Lawson Naidoo believes O'Regan is capable of approaching the matter with an open mind.

The fact that someone is anti-corruption should not automatically preclude them from presiding over matters such as this because that is something you would expect from most members of society and certainly from judges that have served in the highest courts of our country.

Lawson Naidoo, Executive Director, Council for the advancement of the constitution

Click on the link below to listen to the full conversation....


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Is a third-party insurance in place of the Road Accident Fund a better idea?

Is a third-party insurance in place of the Road Accident Fund a better idea?

The transport department has announced that it intends to scrap the embattled Road Accident Fund for a new scheme.

[LISTEN] Who has been funding SA's political parties?

[LISTEN] Who has been funding SA's political parties?

Gushwell Brooks, standing in for Karima Brown, spoke to to My Vote Counts (MVC) Political systems researcher Zahira Grimwood.

'The president won't buckle to any demands by Tom Moyane's legal team'

'The president won't buckle to any demands by Tom Moyane's legal team'

EWN's Qaanitah Hunter reports on President Cyril Ramaphosa's refusal to submit Tom Moyane's legal demands.

Moyane lawyer doesn't rule out action against Ramaphosa

Moyane lawyer doesn't rule out action against Ramaphosa

Lawyer Eric Mabuza says the process used to investigate the former Sars commissioner is 'unfair' and needs to be fixed.

Political Desk: Summons of former Sars officials 'coincidental'

Political Desk: Summons of former Sars officials 'coincidental'

Political Editor at Business Day, Natasha Marrian looks at the top political stories of the day.

Has Tom Moyane surrendered over suspension row?

Has Tom Moyane surrendered over suspension row?

It seems Tom Moyane has changed his mind about challenging his suspension, says the Financial Mail's Sikonathi Mantshantsha.

Popular articles
'We wanted Patricia de Lille to go, Patricia de Lille went'

'We wanted Patricia de Lille to go, Patricia de Lille went'

DA's Mike Moriarty says this matter is about whether the IEC has powers to make judgements about the former mayor.

Giant ANC billboard with spelling error has social media in stitches

Giant ANC billboard with spelling error has social media in stitches

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

Caller gives Ramaphosa a new name: Dimakatso

Caller gives Ramaphosa a new name: Dimakatso

Listeners weigh in on the president's forever 'shocked' response to situations.

'I just messed up one line, why is it news?' Darren responds to anthem backlash

'I just messed up one line, why is it news?' Darren responds to anthem backlash

Eusebius McKaiser speaks to Kurt Darren about forgetting the South African anthem's lyrics.

Gift of the Givers' Dr Imtiaz Sooliman – angel amongst men – talks about money

Gift of the Givers' Dr Imtiaz Sooliman – angel amongst men – talks about money

"I have no desire for clothes. I have no desire for holidays. I have no desire for outings. All I see is the suffering of people…"

New Ipsos poll shows ANC winning 2019 election, rates Ramaphosa a vote puller

New Ipsos poll shows ANC winning 2019 election, rates Ramaphosa a vote puller

Senior client officer at Ipsos, Mari Harris says President Cyril Ramaphosa's trust index is higher than other leaders.