‘NHI is like building a house with no land on which to put it’

Picture: Pexels

We want a healthcare system able to cover all of us… The process to get there still has to be debated at length…

Damian McHugh, Momentum Health

We have sufficient money as a country… we have a private sector that is spending a huge amount of money on a small number of people…

Dr Guni Goolab, Government Employees Medical Scheme

Don’t worry about standards… the emphases is on getting the requisite healthcare to the requisite patients.

Neil Kirby, Werkmans Attorneys

The land issue of healthcare

That’s how Minister of Health Aaron Motsoaledi described the advent of National Health Insurance (NHI) for South Africa earlier this week.

On Thursday, the minister published for public comment two bills that herald the NHI’s introduction.

One of the bills addresses changes to the Medical Schemes Act of 1998, while the other sets out the structure of NHI.

The NHI Bill’s impacts?

It proposes the introduction of NHI, and the compulsory membership thereof for all South Africans.

It proposes the creation of a basket of “health goods” available to all South Africans regardless whether they have medical aid or not.

The items included in such a basket remain unclear for now.

The Medical Schemes Amendment Bill proposes the abolition of co-payments.

The possible range and cost of services available for purchase may be reduced.

Medical schemes may in future exist only as a top-up to what public healthcare services provide.

Consolidation of medical aids is likely.

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviewed Werkmans Attorneys Director (and head of healthcare and life sciences) Neil Kirby, who penned most of what's written above.

Kirby says the bills are unrealistic, considering massive capacity and infrastructural deficiencies in the public health sector.

It's a bit like building a house with no land on which to put it, he says.

Whitfield also spoke to Dr Guni Goolab (Government Employees Medical Scheme) and Damian McHugh (Momentum Health).

Listen to the interviews in the audio below (and/or scroll down for more quotes from it).

We started talking about this [NHI] in 1960!

Damian McHugh, Momentum Health

It is possible that we do have some unintended consequences…

Damian McHugh, Momentum Health

We can have a system where public and private [sectors] work together…

Damian McHugh, Momentum Health

There is a role for medical schemes going forward… NHI requires substantial changes to the public and private sector…

Dr Guni Goolab, Government Employees Medical Scheme

The issue of co-payments, prescribed minimum benefits… and too many options that are too difficult for members to understand…

Dr Guni Goolab, Government Employees Medical Scheme

The minister was careful to describe how we will address deficiencies [in public healthcare].

Neil Kirby, Werkmans Attorneys

The potential for a fight is there… you’re attacking an existing system, maybe ‘attacking’ is the wrong word… If I’m paying for NHI and a medical scheme, I might not be inclined to keep the medical scheme…

Neil Kirby, Werkmans Attorneys

This shines a light on what is happening in the public sector…

Neil Kirby, Werkmans Attorneys

We’re at the outset of this process. There is still much to happen…

Neil Kirby, Werkmans Attorneys

Enjoy The Money Show, but miss it sometimes?

Get the best bits emailed to you daily, right after it ends:

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required

Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Zimbabwe running out of bread as inflation tops 175%

Zimbabwe running out of bread as inflation tops 175%

Hyperinflation – and the destruction it reaps – is returning to Zimbabwe. Bruce Whitfield interviews CNBC Africa’s Chris Bishop.

'Thomas Stringfellow lost the money I got when my wife and baby died'

'Thomas Stringfellow lost the money I got when my wife and baby died'

"There’s a 91-year-old. There are people in the hospital who rely on this money to survive," says scam victim Laurence Upton.

What is a 'Modern African Gentlemen'? Mini SA asks a 'pretentious' question

What is a 'Modern African Gentlemen'? Mini SA asks a 'pretentious' question

Branding and advertising expert Andy Rice hates Mini South Africa’s new "Clubman Modern African Gentlemen Edition".

Investigators find serious corruption at EOH

Investigators find serious corruption at EOH

A probe found "suspicious transactions" worth R1.2bn, bribery and theft. Bruce Whitfield interviews EOH CEO Stephen Van Coller.

Still young(ish)? Entry-level jobs available on Lulaway’s employment platform

Still young(ish)? Entry-level jobs available on Lulaway’s employment platform

Lulaway has placed 30 000 young South Africans in jobs since 2011. Bruce Whitfield interviews its CEO, Jake Willis.

'Motsoaledi won’t collapse private coverage, but he will harm its quality'

'Motsoaledi won’t collapse private coverage, but he will harm its quality'

The country is poised to make history. Bruce Whitfield interviews Prof Alex van den Heever of the Wits School of Governance.

Popular articles
'Calculated move by media to undermine Public Protector, I don't accept apology'

'Calculated move by media to undermine Public Protector, I don't accept apology'

Former Sars employee Bizoski Manyike responds to the Sunday Times article that called him a 'dope-smoking Rastafarian'.

Capitec Bank has the strongest brand of any company in South Africa

Capitec Bank has the strongest brand of any company in South Africa

Castle Lager came in second, followed by FNB, Black Label, Discovery and Vodacom, according to the 2019 Brand Finance report.

I haven’t saved. I intend to work well into my 100s - Leon Louw (FMF)

I haven’t saved. I intend to work well into my 100s - Leon Louw (FMF)

Bruce Whitfield talks to Leon Louw (Free Market Foundation) about his attitude toward money (hopes, fears, successes, failures...)

3 best JSE and offshore shares to buy, right now (by Anchor Capital)

3 best JSE and offshore shares to buy, right now (by Anchor Capital)

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield asks Henry Biddlecombe (an analyst at Anchor Capital) for his stock picks of the week.

Advisor scams pensioners out of R100 million with promises of 14% returns

Advisor scams pensioners out of R100 million with promises of 14% returns

Bruce Whitfield interviews Phillip de Wet (Business Insider), Robert Walton (Boutique Collective Investments) and Brandon Topham.

'I should have told the Sunday Times the pot smoking was irrelevant'

'I should have told the Sunday Times the pot smoking was irrelevant'

Investigative journalist Jacques Pauw says he's sorry for any harm caused in his article on Mkhwebane and her principal witness.

I decided to make this Rihanna song with my maskandi vision - Mbuzeni Mkhize

I decided to make this Rihanna song with my maskandi vision - Mbuzeni Mkhize

After South African star Mbuzeni Mkhize performed a remix of Rihanna's track 'Diamonds' she contacted him to collaborate with her.

What are the best investment options if you decide to go it alone?

What are the best investment options if you decide to go it alone?

Certified financial planner Paul Roelofse gives the lowdown on the money market, retail bonds and exchange-traded funds.