Is everything you say prefaced with your social labels? Listeners talk identity

Do all your personal opinions need to be underwritten by your social identity?

Can you express a viewpoint without announcing yourself as a member of a certain social group first?

Presenter Eusebius McKaiser opened a discussion on the language of identity by citing the work of philosopher Kwame Anthony Appiah.

Appiah is s a British-born Ghanaian-American author and philosophy professor who questions to what extent social identities constrain our freedom.

McKaiser suggests that prefacing an opinion by your social identity can make it difficult for others from outside that social group to enter your discussion .

He asked other callers to share their thoughts and experiences.

Why do we use that kind of preface before we give an opinion? What is the aim? One bad potential effect is that it stops conversation.

Eusebius McKaiser, presenter

When we use that kind of language it does something to discourse... There is a danger there, even if it is unintended.

Eusebius McKaiser, presenter

As a first-generation, urban, English-speaking descendant of Khoi-San I will give you all my categories. We talk about an intersectional approach.

Gertrude, caller

I sometimes preface a comment with the fact that I'm a white male in order to highlight my acknowledgement of my limitations and experiences in contributing to a larger discourse, rather than to undermine other people's opinion because their not white males.

Simon, caller

As a human being, I think that prefacing is used to shut down debates a lot of the time. We do it all the time. It's a horrible debate tactic.

Mandla, caller

Take a listen to the discussion:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
[LISTEN] Looking back at 2019 and mapping out 2020 in the world of work

[LISTEN] Looking back at 2019 and mapping out 2020 in the world of work

Human capital development executive Edith Leeuta shares some advice.

Minister Mchunu explains reasons for massive cuts to minister's perks

Minister Mchunu explains reasons for massive cuts to minister's perks

Public Service and Administration Minister Senzo Mchunu has announced the proposed changes to the Ministerial Handbook.

[LISTEN] Tech gifts to consider this Christmas

[LISTEN] Tech gifts to consider this Christmas

Tech guru Aki Anastasiou shares some gift ideas for children and adults which range from R700 to R9,000.

Why  media houses want access to Zuma's tax returns

Why media houses want access to Zuma's tax returns

Financial Mail journalist Warren Thomson and Newzroom Africa specialist reporetr Karyn Maughan discuss the merits of the case.

'As a man I have no right to tell women what they should do with their hair'

'As a man I have no right to tell women what they should do with their hair'

Africa Melane and callers weigh in on the win by Zozibini Tunzi in the world stage.

The milk powder I buy now is not the same as that of my childhood, says caller

The milk powder I buy now is not the same as that of my childhood, says caller

Africa Melane on the Eusebius McKaiser Show and listeners reflect on famous brands that bring back childhood memories.

Popular articles
[UPDATE] No fatalities in N1 north bus fire

[UPDATE] No fatalities in N1 north bus fire

Passengers and JMPD give details of what led to the fire on the bus.

[VIDEO] Real estate company surprises employees with R740,000 bonus each

[VIDEO] Real estate company surprises employees with R740,000 bonus each

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

[VIDEO] Dad accidentally dunking baby in 20-inch snow goes viral

[VIDEO] Dad accidentally dunking baby in 20-inch snow goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook videos that have gone viral.

[WATCH] Baby saved from falling off counter while mom shops for a gun goes viral

[WATCH] Baby saved from falling off counter while mom shops for a gun goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

'Centurion was built in a floodplain, that's the problem,' says environmentalist

'Centurion was built in a floodplain, that's the problem,' says environmentalist

Water and Environment specialist Professor Anthony Turton says Centurion Lake has always been a controversial development.

'Glug Glug' still our most beloved commercial of the last 35 years

'Glug Glug' still our most beloved commercial of the last 35 years

Even people born after 1990 will probably know this ad.

[WATCH] Woman sharing her most embarrassing moment at parking lot goes viral

[WATCH] Woman sharing her most embarrassing moment at parking lot goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

Did you know? SA exports electricity to seven countries in Southern Africa

Did you know? SA exports electricity to seven countries in Southern Africa

Senior Researcher at Africa Check Kate Wilkinson shares their latest from their fact-finding missions.