Zondo rejects the Guptas application to cross-examine witnesses

Deputy Chief justice Raymond Zondo has denied the Guptas leave to cross-examine the witnesses at the state capture inquiry.

However, he has granted former president Jacob Zuma and his son Duduzane Zuma leave to cross-examine former deputy finance minister Mcebisi Jonas.

According to EWN reporter Gia Nicolaides, the Guptas said they were not going to come into South Africa to testify for the fear that they will get arrested.

She says Zondo said that they will be given an opportunity when they are ready to come into the country and testify it won't happen on their terms.

Read: Zondo Commission: 'The three testimonies are showing how the Guptas operate'

He says until they are ready to come and testify here, they will not be granted permission to cross-examine these witnesses.

Gia Nicolaides, EWN reporter

If they do decide to come to South Africa and testify he would be happy to reconsider the application and most likely give them the opportunity to cross-examine.

Gia Nicolaides, EWN reporter

Zondo said that he granted Zuma an opportunity to cross-examine after he agreed to testify. He commended him for co-operating with the commission.

He actually wants the former president to submit his version in an affidavit.

Gia Nicolaides, EWN reporter

However, Jacob Zuma came out on Wednesday saying that he doesn't believe that the state is captured.

Associate professor of law at Wits, James Grant says he doesn't understand why Zondo would ask Zuma to submit an affidavit. He says Zondo is entitled to call someone to take the stand as a witness.

Grant says it is concerning that the country won't hear from the Guptas in this inquiry but at the same time it is good that the commission has taken a position that no one gets special treatment.

There are special functions that are achieved by having someone testify in person. It is not by accident that people are required to testify in person in front of the accused so that the judge or the commissioner can observe this person.

James Grant, Associate professor of law at Wits

That is the important part of the testimony that we see the person shifting uncomfortably, sweating or stuttering. All these things matter and they feature very strongly with the judge or adjudicator.

James Grant, Associate professor of law at Wits

To hear the rest of the interviews on the commission of inquiry into state capture, listen below:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Zondo rejects the Guptas application to cross-examine witnesses


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Should the Guptas be given special treatment to testify abroad?

Should the Guptas be given special treatment to testify abroad?

Karyn Maughn says the Zondo Commission is set to decide whether they will grant permission for the Guptas to testify via video.

 Guptas willing to testify at Zondo Commission but on their own terms - report

Guptas willing to testify at Zondo Commission but on their own terms - report

The state capture inquiry has heard applications from those implicated in alleged corruption to cross-examine witnesses.

[LISTEN] 'Muthambi says Williams used the inquiry for personal attacks'

[LISTEN] 'Muthambi says Williams used the inquiry for personal attacks'

EWN's Bonga Dlulane gives a summary of the response by Faith Muthambi to Phumla Williams in the state capture commission.

'Where were you Faith Muthambi, what are your credentials?'

'Where were you Faith Muthambi, what are your credentials?'

Bongani Bngwa questions Faith Mutambi's credentials amid Pumla Williams testimony at the #StateCaptureInquiry.

Hawks suspend anti-corruption task team head

Hawks suspend anti-corruption task team head

Hawks spokesperson Hangwani Mulaudzi says they are cooperating with the #StateCaptureInquiry.

Phumla Williams: I was tortured by Faith Muthambi

Phumla Williams: I was tortured by Faith Muthambi

As the state capture commission of inquiry continues, both Duduzane Zuma and the Guptas have applied to cross-examine witnesses.

[LISTEN] 'It is clear Duduzane Zuma was the middleman between State and Guptas'

[LISTEN] 'It is clear Duduzane Zuma was the middleman between State and Guptas'

Investigative Journalist at the Mail & Guardian Thanduxolo Jika gives an analysis of the State Capture Commission of Inquiry.

Popular articles
Fitness was a career that chose me - meet 'Queen Fitnass'

Fitness was a career that chose me - meet 'Queen Fitnass'

Mapule Ndhlovu opens up about her life journey and how exercise changed not only her body, but her mindset for the better.

EFF issues one-line apology to journos after court order

EFF issues one-line apology to journos after court order

Anton Harber and Thandeka Gqubule won their defamation case over Mbuyiseni Ndlozi's party statement implying links to Stratcom.

Ugandan climate activist accuses media of racism after Davos photo crop

Ugandan climate activist accuses media of racism after Davos photo crop

WEF youth climate delegate Vanessa Nakate was cropped out of a group pic with her white peers, also featuring Greta Thunberg.

Letting go of your child who's headed for university and independence

Letting go of your child who's headed for university and independence

Nikki Bush has valuable tips on preparing not only your school-leaver but yourself for the journey into adulthood ahead.

Right to Sight pleads for more donations to conduct cataract surgeries

Right to Sight pleads for more donations to conduct cataract surgeries

Right to Sight trustee Dr Matt Young says they get donations at the most time but now need big sponsors.

Remains of Cato Manor 9 returned on anniversary of their hanging

Remains of Cato Manor 9 returned on anniversary of their hanging

The Cato Manor 9 were hanged in 1961 by the apartheid after taking part in an uprising on 24 January 1960.

Zakes Bantwini opens up about his latest single 'Amanga'

Zakes Bantwini opens up about his latest single 'Amanga'

The musician says he never writes songs about his personal life but this latest single is too personal for him.

Unisa extends registration deadline in the wake of union protests

Unisa extends registration deadline in the wake of union protests

Unisa acting director of communications Lusani Netshitomboni says they encourage students to register online.

Jacques Nienaber confirmed as new Springboks head coach

Jacques Nienaber confirmed as new Springboks head coach

Mzwandile Stick has been reappointed as an assistant coach while in an innovative inclusion, Felix Jones will continue but in a new role as a European-based coaching consultant.

Statistics show decline in mining fatalities

Statistics show decline in mining fatalities

Department of Minerals and Energy chief inspector of mine David Msiza says more needs to be done.