'Investigating officers have the prerogative to have suspects shackled in court'

The court appearance of Nicholas Ninow who has been accused a raping a 6-year-old girl at Dros restaurant in Pretoria sparked a debate on social media on why he was not shackled.

Pictures making comparisons between Ninow; fees must fall, activist, Mcebo Dlamini and Duduzane Zuma when they appeared in court trended on social media with people asking why Dlamini and Zuma were shackled while Ninow was not.

Some people came to the conclusion that is was racially motivated.

Azania Mosaka engaged Saps spokesperson Vish Naidoo to understand what led to others being shackled and others not.

Regarding shackling of awaiting trails detainees that are going to court, there is no specific policy on that. There is a policy that speaks to the restraining of suspects when arrested and being transported from point A to point B.

Vish Naidoo, National Spokesperson at SA Police Service

When it comes to an accused that is appearing in court, the prerogative is on the investigating officer first and foremost to make a determination as to whether that suspect or awaiting trial detainee may be in restraints when being brought before the court. And that would be informed by the level of threat that suspect poses in terms of causing danger to himself or herself or danger to anybody else in their vicinity.

Vish Naidoo, National Spokesperson at SA Police Service

A second scenario is when a court would place such a rule like the one of Duduzane Zuma. That court had experienced challenges in the past where suspects escaped. So the court made a ruling that every suspect that will appear there will be in restraints.

Vish Naidoo, National Spokesperson at SA Police Service

READ: Why are people upset that Duduzane Zuma was shackled? Is it because he's hot?

Every case has to be treated with its own merits in any other court and that determination will be made by the investigating officer base on whether the suspect may be a flight risk or pose danger.

Vish Naidoo, National Spokesperson at SA Police Service

Attorney and former prosecutor Marius Du Toit says the courts have dealt with the issue of shackles on several occasions.

They have come clear to say that it is extremely undesirable practice to bring the person in shackles because this person has a right to be treated with dignity, has a right to be receiving a fair trial.

Marius Du Toit, Attorney and Former Prosecutor

Our courts have said it is something that should be stopped and it should not be allowed. The High Court in Pretoria has gone on to say if you continue doing it, it will start of contempt of court proceedings against you for bringing people in shackles.

Marius Du Toit, Attorney and Former Prosecutor

Listen to what callers had to say...


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Tips on what to disclose when taking out life insurance

Tips on what to disclose when taking out life insurance

Consumer journalist Wendy Knowler says many consumers have had problems when it comes to disclosing doctor visits and scans.

Why mental health is key to your success as an entrepreneur

Why mental health is key to your success as an entrepreneur

Experts share advice on how to cope with the stress of owning a business.

[LISTEN] The difference between polishing and waxing your car

[LISTEN] The difference between polishing and waxing your car

Exklusiv Autohaus owner Jignesh (Jiggy) Thakor shares his insights.

Why physical education in schools is as important as a child's academic work

Why physical education in schools is as important as a child's academic work

Azania spoke to Embury Institute for Higher Education physical education specialist lecturer Michael Mthethwa to discuss this.

[LISTEN] Fake news doing the rounds on social media

[LISTEN] Fake news doing the rounds on social media

Africa Check senior researcher Kate Wilkinson takes a look at three stories including a claim made about Thuli Madonsela.

Why are people upset that Duduzane Zuma was shackled? Is it because he's hot?

Why are people upset that Duduzane Zuma was shackled? Is it because he's hot?

Eusebius and callers discuss 'pretty boy' privileges and if they thought Duduzane looked hot in chains.

Popular articles
Enjoy life and save for the future by splitting income using the '50/15/5 rule'

Enjoy life and save for the future by splitting income using the '50/15/5 rule'

You only live once — personal finance guru Warren Ingram on divvying up your income if you're not the budgeting type.

South Africa is flirting with recession. Again. How to 'create your own economy'

South Africa is flirting with recession. Again. How to 'create your own economy'

The timing could not be better to create your own economy, says small business guru Pavlo Phitidis.

You can now apply to generate electricity and feed it into the grid

You can now apply to generate electricity and feed it into the grid

The change comes after Energy Minister Jeff Radebe told the National Energy Regulator of SA to license applications to do so.

[WATCH] Twin toddlers climbing a fridge has Twitter in stitches!

[WATCH] Twin toddlers climbing a fridge has Twitter in stitches!

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

'If you want to clear your name, why would you postpone your swearing-in?'

'If you want to clear your name, why would you postpone your swearing-in?'

Former ANC MP Melanie Verwoerd says she is not convinced by David Mabuza's reason to temporarily step aside as an MP.

'Thuli Madonsela’s name has been mentioned for Deputy President'

'Thuli Madonsela’s name has been mentioned for Deputy President'

Lumkile Mondi (Wits), Ferial Haffajee and Busisiwe Mavuso (Business Leadership SA) on the President's upcoming "slim" Cabinet.

[Exposed] Car dealerships, banks in cahoots; you’re not always getting best deal

[Exposed] Car dealerships, banks in cahoots; you’re not always getting best deal

Consumer journalist Wendy Knowler uncovered evidence of banks sending dealer principles on holidays abroad for hitting targets.

Running Bidvest doesn’t scare me! - Mpumi Madisa (39)

Running Bidvest doesn’t scare me! - Mpumi Madisa (39)

Madisa will soon become Bidvest’s CEO and the only black woman CEO of a JSE Top-40 company. At 39, she’ll also be the youngest.