Should we publish the identity of an accused on social media? An expert debates

The name and photographs of a man accused of raping a seven-year-old child at a restaurant in Pretoria were widely circulated on social media before he appeared in court.

A number of news publications ran the story and published his name too which is against the Criminal Procedure Act.

The country’s Criminal Procedure Act of 1977 prohibits the publication of the identity of the accused before they appear in court to prevent undue prejudice to a person before the prosecuting authority decides to prosecute.

Lecturer in Criminal Justice at UCT Jameelah Omar says the Criminal Procedure Law is old and was drafted before the existence of social media, therefore, should be relooked at.

Read: Sharing Dros rape video and naming suspect is unlawful, warns legal expert

The Criminal Procedure Act is quite old now, it was first enacted in 1977. This is a precision that is quite old as well and probably in need of reform because social media wasn't conceived of at the time.

Jameelah Omar, Lecturer in Criminal Justice at UCT

Omar says although she doesn't think the NPA will prosecute those who published the identity of the accused, people should be careful of what they post on social media.

I think it is important for people to realise that they should be cautious about what they post on social media.

Jameelah Omar, Lecturer in Criminal Justice at UCT

To hear the rest of the conversation, listen below:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Should we publish the identity of an accused on social media? An expert debates


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Eusebius: Chemical castration of rapists will not stop their violence

Eusebius: Chemical castration of rapists will not stop their violence

Eusebius McKaiser and a caller share their views on chemical castration of rapists.

[LISTEN] 'We regard children as being morally innocent' #DrosRape

[LISTEN] 'We regard children as being morally innocent' #DrosRape

Researcher at UNISA Institute for Social & Health Sciences Rebecca Helman talks about her article Dros Rape shouldn't shock us.

A call for Dros rapist to be charged with attempted murder

A call for Dros rapist to be charged with attempted murder

The court ruled that media is not allowed to broadcast or video the proceedings in order to protect the identity of the child.

Do we want to know anything about the accused Dros rapist's life asks Eusebius?

Do we want to know anything about the accused Dros rapist's life asks Eusebius?

Callers on the Eusebius McKaiser Show debate the Dros rape case as bail is denied and the case remanded till 1 November.

Sharing Dros rape video and naming suspect is unlawful, warns legal expert

Sharing Dros rape video and naming suspect is unlawful, warns legal expert

A criminal lawyer says naming the man and sharing the video is an obstruction of justice in terms of the Criminal Procedure Act.

[LISTEN] Dros rape: Reflecting on media law and ethics

[LISTEN] Dros rape: Reflecting on media law and ethics

Sections of the public have accused the media of protecting the 20-year-old suspect because of his race.

'Dros in Silverton  is opened but there are no customers'

'Dros in Silverton is opened but there are no customers'

Eyewitness News reporter Bonga Dlulane gives an update from the Pretoria restaurant where a 6-year-old girl was raped.

Popular articles
I come from having very little, to having a lot - Craig Gradidge

I come from having very little, to having a lot - Craig Gradidge

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Gradidge about his attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.).

'The next Steinhoff is around the corner!'

'The next Steinhoff is around the corner!'

The Steinhoff-debacle happened while the world praised SA for its auditing standards. Bruce Whitfield interviews Dr Steven Firer.

'I left Australia for SA so that my sons can practice their religion in freedom'

'I left Australia for SA so that my sons can practice their religion in freedom'

A Muslim mom and former community spokesperson - now living in SA - recounts the deep-rooted history of Islamophobia in Australia.

Load shedding will be resolved permanently in a few weeks - Fikile Mbalula

Load shedding will be resolved permanently in a few weeks - Fikile Mbalula

ANC head of elections, Fikile Mbalula says the president is hard at work to resolve Eskom's problems.

Genesis of the Eskom problem is ANC looting says Eusebius

Genesis of the Eskom problem is ANC looting says Eusebius

Eusebius McKaiser facillitates a debate between callers about their frustrations due to load shedding.