[LISTEN] Is an inquisitorial system more effective when handling rape cases?

Thursday marked day one of the presidential summit on gender-based violence and femicide.

Government convened the the two-day seminar following a call by the total shutdown movement in August.

A number of activists have long been calling for an inquisitorial system, rather than the adversarial system which often causes rape survivors secondary trauma on the stand.

Activists have made the argument that an inquisitorial system would allow the court to investigate the case by building up a picture of the facts to determine a finding.

Joanne Joseph spoke to Justice Minister Michael Masutha to get his insights on the matter.

I would imagine that an inquisitorial system would give a presiding officer - would free his or her hands to intervene in a manner that strikes some kind of a balance - but remember that it is internationally accepted that the standard of proof in a criminal matter, unlike in a civil matter, is for the state to prove beyond a reasonable doubt and the onus is entirely on the state to meet that threshold.

Michael Masutha, Justice Minister

One of the possibilities is to enable witnesses who are not confident to face the accused for example, to testify on camera in a separate room where they are not face to face with the accused.

Michael Masutha, Justice Minister

In addition, when it comes to children as well as people with mental disabilities, intermediaries are available who act as facilitators.

Michael Masutha, Justice Minister

Indeed it is something we should be resuscitating, certainly something we can look at.

Michael Masutha, Justice Minister

Click on the link below to hear more from Masutha....


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
 Magistrate Desmond Nair provisionally suspended over Bosasa allegations

Magistrate Desmond Nair provisionally suspended over Bosasa allegations

Nair was charged with two counts of misconduct in November last year following a preliminary investigation by the ministry.

Literacy Project to empower caregivers of pre-school children

Literacy Project to empower caregivers of pre-school children

CEO Steven Roux says they identified that there is a significant number of children who are not getting access to good creches.

Frustrated judge tells Dudu Myeni to answer questions directly - report

Frustrated judge tells Dudu Myeni to answer questions directly - report

The former SA chairperson was giving evidence in the delinquency case brought by Outa and the SA Pilots Association

Mboweni allocates R60-billion for SAA and Eskom

Mboweni allocates R60-billion for SAA and Eskom

Economist Dr Sean Miller says Eskom is a national problem and it is going to need to be bailed out.

'Journalists, lawyers under surveillance should get enhanced protection'

'Journalists, lawyers under surveillance should get enhanced protection'

Attorney Dario Milo, for AmaBhungane, bids to confirm high court judgment which found that parts of the Rica are unconstitutional

Yunus Carrim relates how MultiChoice used its power to influence policy - report

Yunus Carrim relates how MultiChoice used its power to influence policy - report

Eyewitness News reporter Bonga Dlulane shares details on some of Carrim's testimony concerning the SABC/MultiChoice deal.

Popular articles
[WATCH] London underground train singer performing Shallow on Ellen goes viral

[WATCH] London underground train singer performing Shallow on Ellen goes viral

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.

Unions not happy with Mboweni's announcement to cut public wage bill by 1%

Unions not happy with Mboweni's announcement to cut public wage bill by 1%

Public Servants Association's Reuben Maleka says the government is trying to pit unions against the public.

Wait - why did that debit order go off so early?

Wait - why did that debit order go off so early?

Wendy Knowler, consumer journalist, on Nedbank's early debit orders.

Budget 2020: The big surprise was two billion rand in tax relief

Budget 2020: The big surprise was two billion rand in tax relief

Individual tax payers are actually better off as a result of Budget 2020.

$7 trillion could save the world but not in the way you might think

$7 trillion could save the world but not in the way you might think

A billionaire asset fund manager has told global CEO’s to focus on climate change.

Budget 2020: The good, the bad, and the ugly

Budget 2020: The good, the bad, and the ugly

The Money Show asked three economists for their views on the pros and cons of Budget 2020.

 Magistrate Desmond Nair provisionally suspended over Bosasa allegations

Magistrate Desmond Nair provisionally suspended over Bosasa allegations

Nair was charged with two counts of misconduct in November last year following a preliminary investigation by the ministry.

Literacy Project to empower caregivers of pre-school children

Literacy Project to empower caregivers of pre-school children

CEO Steven Roux says they identified that there is a significant number of children who are not getting access to good creches.

Frustrated judge tells Dudu Myeni to answer questions directly - report

Frustrated judge tells Dudu Myeni to answer questions directly - report

The former SA chairperson was giving evidence in the delinquency case brought by Outa and the SA Pilots Association

Mboweni allocates R60-billion for SAA and Eskom

Mboweni allocates R60-billion for SAA and Eskom

Economist Dr Sean Miller says Eskom is a national problem and it is going to need to be bailed out.