[LISTEN] Herzlia school protest during Israeli national anthem debated

Protests are very much part of the fabric of South Africa. Globally we have seen huge contestation across campuses and some major cities around the world. Protesting and the ethics around protesting raises pertinent political and ethical question.

Last Thursday during a ceremony at the Jewish community school, Herzlia Middle School in Cape Town, two learners knelt and 'took the knee' in protest during the playing of Hatikvah, the Israeli National Anthem. The event was a graduation ceremony for grade nine learners.

Following the ceremony and the learners’ protest, an email was sent by the school’s Director of Education Geoff Cohen, to all parents. The students are now facing a disciplinary hearing.

The problem we felt as students is that, we were being forced to stand and sing for an anthem that went against our principles and our beliefs. We felt standing there would be a sign of support for the Israeli anthem. We couldn't stand because we are not in support of what is currently happening in Israel.

Herzlia Middle School student

The view of schools that students should refrain from political topics is very problematic. We should allow students to be politically engaged and be able to express political views. We can't have students who can't think for themselves and who are not in favour of debate and critical discussions.

Ilan Price – Phd Candidate at Oxford University

We have tried to reach the South African Jewish Board of Deputies for comment, but they declined our invite.

Click below to listen to the full interview:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Breast cancer and its effect on sexuality

Breast cancer and its effect on sexuality

Dr Eve explores the subject with 702 callers and talks frankly about the effects of cancer on patients sexuality.

Whoever takes over from James Selfe is a poor choice, says Eusebius

Whoever takes over from James Selfe is a poor choice, says Eusebius

The Democratic Alliance will be electing its new federal council chairperson over the weekend.

'Had abuser been a male teacher, we would have had a crazy outcry from society'

'Had abuser been a male teacher, we would have had a crazy outcry from society'

Pundits discuss the sexual misconduct allegations at Bishops Diocesan College in Cape Town.

[LISTEN] Black Tax: Burden or Ubuntu?

[LISTEN] Black Tax: Burden or Ubuntu?

Eusebius speaks to writers Niq Mhlongo, Thanduxolo Jika and Lorraine Sithole about black tax in black communities.

Be familiar with the rules before approaching CCMA, says lawyer

Be familiar with the rules before approaching CCMA, says lawyer

LDA Incorporated Attorneys director Larry Dave says the commission is a functional body and it has improved over the years.

Herzlia alumni slam punishment of pupils for 'peaceful' Israeli anthem protest

Herzlia alumni slam punishment of pupils for 'peaceful' Israeli anthem protest

Two pupils are facing disciplinary action for taking the knee during the Israeli national anthem.

Popular articles
'It turns out DA MP Natasha Mazzone was right about load shedding'

'It turns out DA MP Natasha Mazzone was right about load shedding'

Last month, Eskom shut down claims by the Democratic Alliance that load shedding was on the cards.

[WATCH] Commuters on station stop train from hitting passenger

[WATCH] Commuters on station stop train from hitting passenger

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

[WATCH] How many people does it take to park a car?

[WATCH] How many people does it take to park a car?

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

'We discuss stocks and options with our children at the dinner table'

'We discuss stocks and options with our children at the dinner table'

Bruce Whitfield interviews Basetsana Kumalo about her attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.).

'Had abuser been a male teacher, we would have had a crazy outcry from society'

'Had abuser been a male teacher, we would have had a crazy outcry from society'

Pundits discuss the sexual misconduct allegations at Bishops Diocesan College in Cape Town.

[WATCH] Boy explaining what he heard when parents had sex goes viral

[WATCH] Boy explaining what he heard when parents had sex goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

It's VW, but not as you know it - Why did Volkswagen change its logo?

It's VW, but not as you know it - Why did Volkswagen change its logo?

John Maytham asks what's behind Volkswagen's new-look logo...

5 retirement saving tips for those who left it late

5 retirement saving tips for those who left it late

It’s better to start late than never! The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Jeanette Marais.

[WATCH] Woman faints after hairdresser cuts 12-inch hair without telling her

[WATCH] Woman faints after hairdresser cuts 12-inch hair without telling her

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.