[LISTEN] In-depth look at the significance of the Xolobeni mining judgment

The Xolobeni mining saga has finally had some resolution.

The court ruled that the Department of Mineral Resources must obtain full and formal consent from the Xolobeni community before granting any mining rights.

The debate for that land has been raging for the past 15 years after an Australian mining company started mining titanium in the area.

Residents in the area raised concerns about losing their homes and grazing lands, and feared the environment would be damaged.

Eusebius McKasier spoke to lead researcher from the Bench Marks Foundation, David van Wyk and Johan Lorenzen an Associate at Richard Spoor Attorneys about this judgment.

It is an indictment that 25 years into democracy we are having this debate now which is something we should have dealt with in 1994.

David van Wyk, Lead Researcher from the Bench Marks Foundation

We should be looking for a clean break post-1994 to value these communities and their own cultural values and to allow them to make their own decisions.

Johan Lorenzen, Associate at Richard Spoor Attorneys

READ: Victorious mining rights court ruling for Xolobeni community

It is necessary to understand that this community makes its decision by consensus not by voting.

David van Wyk, Lead Researcher from the Bench Marks Foundation

Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Who is the rightful owner of a piece of land in the Cradle of Humankind?

Who is the rightful owner of a piece of land in the Cradle of Humankind?

A small community in the Cradle of Humankind are at war over a piece of land

Victorious mining rights court ruling for Xolobeni community

Victorious mining rights court ruling for Xolobeni community

Lawyer says 'there needs to be full disclosure on what the impact is going to be on the directly affected people'.

ConCourt ruling on mining in Lesetlheng is important for Xolobeni -Richard Spoor

ConCourt ruling on mining in Lesetlheng is important for Xolobeni -Richard Spoor

Attorney, Richard Spoor has been at the forefront of efforts to protect Xolobeni from the harmful effects of mining.

Attorney who marched on Mantashe's mining meeting charged

Attorney who marched on Mantashe's mining meeting charged

John Clark says Xolobeni is a community-based eco-tourism initiative that is being sabotaged because of mining.

Bongani Bingwa: 'Have a little think about what we mean when we talk about land'

Bongani Bingwa: 'Have a little think about what we mean when we talk about land'

Bongani Bingwa focuses on the land issue of Xolobeni in Eastern Cape.

Community objects to mining in ancestral land

Community objects to mining in ancestral land

Founder of the Amadiba Crisis Committee, Nonhle Mbuthuma, explains whey they are objecting to mining in Xolobeni.

Popular articles
No traffic and everyone’s at home… Some short-term insurers offer lower premiums

No traffic and everyone’s at home… Some short-term insurers offer lower premiums

Short-term insurers suddenly carry a massively reduced risk burden, says consumer journalist Wendy Knowler. Getting some back?

A tipping point for video conferencing

A tipping point for video conferencing

A business tool for older generations, a staple for younger ones

Total number of positive coronavirus cases rises to 1,380

Total number of positive coronavirus cases rises to 1,380

This is an increase of 27 cases from Tuesday's announcement. Health Minister Zweli Mkhize has tested negative for the virus.

What is an 'economic depression'? Are we heading for one? Lessons from history…

What is an 'economic depression'? Are we heading for one? Lessons from history…

The Great Depression started 91 years ago and changed everything. Bruce Whitfield speaks to economic historian Keith Breckenridge.

Sars collects R1.4tr in taxes – up 5.3% on a year before, despite the recession

Sars collects R1.4tr in taxes – up 5.3% on a year before, despite the recession

Despite the achievement, the country still lost R100 billion in uncollected taxes, says Commissioner Edward Kieswetter.

Struggling to pay a debt? Your options: credit insurance vs debt relief holiday

Struggling to pay a debt? Your options: credit insurance vs debt relief holiday

Personal Finance expert Maya Fischer-French on the pros/cons of dipping into credit insurance vs opting for a debt relief holiday.

Absa launches extensive Covid-19 payment relief programme

Absa launches extensive Covid-19 payment relief programme

Absa is providing payment relief to its retail clients as well as its business banking and wealth customers.

'Gita Ramjee was probably one of the most remarkable women you would have met'

'Gita Ramjee was probably one of the most remarkable women you would have met'

The revered South African HIV scientist passed away at a Durban hospital on Tuesday after COVID-19-related complications.

[LOCKDOWN] Sars outlines measures to cushion the COVID-19 blow

[LOCKDOWN] Sars outlines measures to cushion the COVID-19 blow

Commissioner Edward Kieswetter says they have diverted customers to their online channels and contact centres.

How to communicate with frustrated children during lockdown

How to communicate with frustrated children during lockdown

Fair Practice Mediation Services director advocate Veerash Srikison says communication can breakdown in families during this time.