'You can punish your children, you just don't need to hit them'

The ConCourt is due to hear an appeal against a judgment by the High Court in Johannesburg effectively declaring all forms of physical correction of children by their parents unlawful.

EWN reporter Thando Kubheka says the ConCourt will not rule on the matter on Thursday.

READ: 'Children in SA experience high levels of violence'

She says on Thursday the ConCourt will be hearing the appeal which has been brought by Freedom of Religion of South Africa, The Department of Justice and Social Development, which are amongst those opposing this appeal.

This will give parents rights to use physical correction to discipline their children.

The court is currently hearing arguments from those for and against the issue.

Carol Bouwer, the director at Peace Centre, who are against spanking, and one of the groups that brought the matter to court, also weighed in on the conversation and says they want a prohibition of corporal punishment.

However, they are at the ConCourt today to argue the matter of whether reasonable chastisement by parents who do hit their children, is constitutional or not.

The High Court is of the view that it is not unconstitutional and that decision was appealed by Freedom of Religion South Africa, which is a fairly rightwing evangelical Christian grouping who claim that God says you must hit your children - but they are not doing that this time.

Carol Bouwer, Director at Peace Centre

What they are saying right now is that the High Court stepped out of its responsibility and its authority by declaring the defence unconstitutional and they are hoping that the ConCourt will agree with them, but we are hoping that they will agree with us.

Carol Bouwer, Director at Peace Centre

She adds that conservative groups generally argue in all kinds ways against the extension of the protection of human rights.

It was a Christian group of schools who, for example, took the Department of Education to the ConCourt in 2000 about the prohibition of corporal punishment in schools.

Carol Bouwer, Director at Peace Centre

She says there is a conservative element in our society and it is often linked to evangelical Christians who cherry pick their way through the Bible on issues related to children, women and homosexuals.

She adds that the Christian group is also arguing that corporal punishment and reasonable chastisement are two different things.

And we are saying they are not, they are the same thing.

Carol Bouwer, Director at Peace Centre

Bouwer says they are not trying to take away the punishment of children from parents.

We are saying you can punish your children, you just don't need to hit them.

Carol Bouwer, Director at Peace Centre

Listen below to the full interview:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Immigrant parents must follow due processes to register children with DHA

Immigrant parents must follow due processes to register children with DHA

Acting Director General at the Department of Home Affairs Thulani Mavuso clarifies how immigrant children are registered.

10 days paternity leave for dads a 'baby step' in right direction - law group

10 days paternity leave for dads a 'baby step' in right direction - law group

The legal organisation Law For All says the government still has a long way to go in creating equitable parental leave.

How to help your kids get up again after failure or disappointment

How to help your kids get up again after failure or disappointment

Clinical psychologist Ruth Ancer says parents need to ensure that their children feel supported unconditionally.

[LISTEN] Herzlia school protest during Israeli national anthem debated

[LISTEN] Herzlia school protest during Israeli national anthem debated

Eusebius McKaiser and guests debate the right to political expression in schools.

In whose favour will the Zim Con Court rule?

In whose favour will the Zim Con Court rule?

Zimbabwe's Constitutional Court is set to rule on the results of the country's July 30 elections.

Labour broker judgment is a defining moment - Vavi

Labour broker judgment is a defining moment - Vavi

The judgment was handed down on Thursday in the matter between trade union Numsa and a temporary employment service.

Gift of the Givers' Dr Imtiaz Sooliman – angel amongst men – talks about money

Gift of the Givers' Dr Imtiaz Sooliman – angel amongst men – talks about money

"I have no desire for clothes. I have no desire for holidays. I have no desire for outings. All I see is the suffering of people…"

Warning issued over new Absa logo scam

Warning issued over new Absa logo scam

Cyber criminals are using Absa's new logo as the basis of a new phising scam, here's what to look out for.

Van Reenen's Pass blocked by trucks on the N3

Van Reenen's Pass blocked by trucks on the N3

N3 toll route management says the blockaded is a result of a truck driver protest against the employment of foreign nationals.

How the violence of corporal punishment can harm your kids

How the violence of corporal punishment can harm your kids

There's nothing innocent about child spanking. Child protection researcher Dr Stefanie Röhrs explores the detrimental effects.

Children's Institute gives ban on corporal punishment the thumbs up

Children's Institute gives ban on corporal punishment the thumbs up

Dr Stefanie Röhrs says the ruling is a victory for children's rights and parents can use other methods to instill discipline.

'Parents need to know the difference between discipline and assault'

'Parents need to know the difference between discipline and assault'

Dr Shaheda Omar from the Teddy Bear Clinic chats with Eusebius McKaiser about drawing distinctions between this fine line.

SA Council of Educators fails to reduce abuse in schools

SA Council of Educators fails to reduce abuse in schools

Tabling a report in Parliament on Wednesday, SACE says nearly 600 complaints have been logged in the past year.

Poor parent involvement linked to ill-discipline in schools, says Education DG

Poor parent involvement linked to ill-discipline in schools, says Education DG

The department's Mathanzima Mweli says not enough parents play an active role is disciplining their children and rely on teachers.

Popular articles
Ramaphosa apologises to Malema family for Sona abuse claims

Ramaphosa apologises to Malema family for Sona abuse claims

The president also apologised to South Africans about the way in which the gender-based violence matter was debated.

[LISTEN] Facebook group provides support for parents raising teens

[LISTEN] Facebook group provides support for parents raising teens

Azania Mosaka spoke to admin and media consultant of the page Vanessa Raphaely.

Time running out for Rampedi to retract 'paedophile' tweets about Jacques Pauw

Time running out for Rampedi to retract 'paedophile' tweets about Jacques Pauw

Journalist Piet Rampedi's lawyer Eric Mabuza says they will respond in due time but if the deadline lapses 'so be it'.

Cosatu members march to demand reliable, affordable rail transport

Cosatu members march to demand reliable, affordable rail transport

Federation's Western Cape leader Motlatsi Tsubane says they handed over a memorandum to Prasa, Metrorail and other stakeholders.

Dudu Myeni testifies in delinquency case, says her appointment was above board

Dudu Myeni testifies in delinquency case, says her appointment was above board

EWN reporter Edwin Ntshidi gives an update on the SAA board chairperson's case at the Pretoria High Court.

Cindy Poluta's emotional first drive to work without Alfred

Cindy Poluta's emotional first drive to work without Alfred

On her first morning drive to work after hearing the news of her friend Alfred's death, Cindy Poluta shared her memories.

Body of missing Tazne van Wyk has been found

Body of missing Tazne van Wyk has been found

Police said that the 8-year-old's body was found in a stormwater pipe outside Worcester on Wednesday night.

[WATCH] Woman stuns prankster by singing Lady Gaga's song perfectly

[WATCH] Woman stuns prankster by singing Lady Gaga's song perfectly

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.

[VIDEO] Why is Jub Jub destroying so much alcohol?

[VIDEO] Why is Jub Jub destroying so much alcohol?

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.

GPAA explains why it awarded fairly new Mpisane Properties a huge tender

GPAA explains why it awarded fairly new Mpisane Properties a huge tender

Acting chief financial officer Phinda Nondabula says the company met all the required specifications to get the project.