It's not possible for media to report neutrally, says political analyst

Should journalists, broadcasters, commentators and analysts disclose their political allegiances or should they strive for neutrality?

Presenter Eusebius McKaiser hosted a discussion with commentator JJ Tabane and political analyst Vukani Mde in light of the upcoming general elections.

Read: It's time media treat EFF with more sceptical distance, says journalism prof

Tabane says media practitioners are undeniably imbued with politics but some media jobs (such as reporting) require individual's to separate their political preferences from their work.

In the media space, there are people who are there to report news and people who are there to generate opinion or provoke debate.

JJ Tabane, broadcaster, columnist and commentator

Also read: Sanef: We can't live in a country where journalists are threatened into silence

Mde dismisses the idea of neutrality in journalism and believes that news coverage/selection and reporting is in itself a political exercise.

People who pretend like they don't have political convictions or a politicised identity do so for dishonest reasons.

Vukani Mde, political analyst

Even when we report, and report the facts, that in itself is a political act and an ideologically driven job.

Vukani Mde, political analyst

It's not possible to report neutrally or in a way that is ideologically or politically clean.

Vukani Mde, political analyst

Both guests revealed that they would vote for the ANC in this year's elections and explored the role of the media fraternity in navigating political discourse.

Listen to the engaging debate on The Eusebius McKaiser Show:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : It's not possible for media to report neutrally, says political analyst


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
'The criminals in the ANC will gang up on Cyril Ramaphosa'

'The criminals in the ANC will gang up on Cyril Ramaphosa'

Political analyst Prince Mashele and Richard Calland dissect the political landscape as 6th democratic Parliament in SA begins.

'Reason for Mabuza's swearing-in postponement is BS' says Eusebius

'Reason for Mabuza's swearing-in postponement is BS' says Eusebius

He believes these things are about power, horsetrading, and skeletons that these people know they have.

'Even Jacob Zuma has said he can't remember the events for which he is charged'

'Even Jacob Zuma has said he can't remember the events for which he is charged'

Karyn Maughan unpacks the proceedings in the former president's court appearance in Pietermaritzburg.

Zuma's legal strategy is poor, says Eusebius

Zuma's legal strategy is poor, says Eusebius

Eusebius McKaiser and callers discuss the former president's stay of prosecution application.

Game of Thrones cast remember their days on set and what stood out for them

Game of Thrones cast remember their days on set and what stood out for them

Khabazela shares tweets, YouTube videos and Facebook posts that are going viral on social media.

Borderline personality disorder painted badly on the internet, says expert

Borderline personality disorder painted badly on the internet, says expert

Clinical psychologist Jeanie Cavé says according to research the condition is as a result of trauma and is hard to treat.

Popular articles
David Makhura re-elected as Gauteng premier

David Makhura re-elected as Gauteng premier

Eyewitness News reporter Nthakoana Ngatane says it is clear that the Economic Freedom Fighters voted for DA's Solly Msimanga.

'President's constitutional duty is to appoint a deputy president without delay'

'President's constitutional duty is to appoint a deputy president without delay'

Analysts Pierre de Vos and Mcebisi Ndletyana weigh in on DD Mabuza's decision to delay being sworn in as a Member of Parliament.

'The criminals in the ANC will gang up on Cyril Ramaphosa'

'The criminals in the ANC will gang up on Cyril Ramaphosa'

Political analyst Prince Mashele and Richard Calland dissect the political landscape as 6th democratic Parliament in SA begins.

'Reason for Mabuza's swearing-in postponement is BS' says Eusebius

'Reason for Mabuza's swearing-in postponement is BS' says Eusebius

He believes these things are about power, horsetrading, and skeletons that these people know they have.

Deputy president David Mabuza postpones swearing-in as MP

Deputy president David Mabuza postpones swearing-in as MP

Mabuza has made the request to wait for the outcome of an integrity commission report before becoming an ANC MP.

Dis-Chem drives ad expert to 'Steve Hofmeyr-like assaults' on his decoder

Dis-Chem drives ad expert to 'Steve Hofmeyr-like assaults' on his decoder

"It’s been said you can’t bore people into buying your brand. Someone should’ve pointed this out to Dis-Chem," says Andy Rice.

Bone-dry Makhanda (Grahamstown) is falling apart

Bone-dry Makhanda (Grahamstown) is falling apart

What is going on in bone-dry Makhanda (Grahamstown)? Bruce Whitfield interviews Jacko Maree (St Andrew's College).