It's not possible for media to report neutrally, says political analyst

Should journalists, broadcasters, commentators and analysts disclose their political allegiances or should they strive for neutrality?

Presenter Eusebius McKaiser hosted a discussion with commentator JJ Tabane and political analyst Vukani Mde in light of the upcoming general elections.

Read: It's time media treat EFF with more sceptical distance, says journalism prof

Tabane says media practitioners are undeniably imbued with politics but some media jobs (such as reporting) require individual's to separate their political preferences from their work.

In the media space, there are people who are there to report news and people who are there to generate opinion or provoke debate.

JJ Tabane, broadcaster, columnist and commentator

Also read: Sanef: We can't live in a country where journalists are threatened into silence

Mde dismisses the idea of neutrality in journalism and believes that news coverage/selection and reporting is in itself a political exercise.

People who pretend like they don't have political convictions or a politicised identity do so for dishonest reasons.

Vukani Mde, political analyst

Even when we report, and report the facts, that in itself is a political act and an ideologically driven job.

Vukani Mde, political analyst

It's not possible to report neutrally or in a way that is ideologically or politically clean.

Vukani Mde, political analyst

Both guests revealed that they would vote for the ANC in this year's elections and explored the role of the media fraternity in navigating political discourse.

Listen to the engaging debate on The Eusebius McKaiser Show:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : It's not possible for media to report neutrally, says political analyst


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
How to get rid of stigma and thrive while living with HIV

How to get rid of stigma and thrive while living with HIV

Eusebius McKaiser chats to brothers Thula and Ntokozo Mkhize on how people can accept and cope with the virus.

10 anger types that escalate to gender-based violence in relationships

10 anger types that escalate to gender-based violence in relationships

Clinical sexologist Dr Eve says words stick and do not heal as fast as wounds.

'Since Ramaphosa became president Motsepe has become bizarre,' says caller

'Since Ramaphosa became president Motsepe has become bizarre,' says caller

Callers react to businessman Patrice Motsepe telling Donald Trump that Africa loves the US president.

Looking at art as one of the languages in which to talk about mental illness

Looking at art as one of the languages in which to talk about mental illness

Eusebius McKaiser and pundits reflect on how people can manage their mental health challenges by creating artworks.

Caller shares horrific story of how his twin babies died at Mamelodi Hospital

Caller shares horrific story of how his twin babies died at Mamelodi Hospital

Mike says immediately after the first baby died, a private undertaker called him offering his services to bury the child.

Parktown Boys' High pupil: The headmaster emphasised we must not speak to anyone

Parktown Boys' High pupil: The headmaster emphasised we must not speak to anyone

A grade 8 learner recalls in graphic detail how he and other boys watched Enoch Mpianzi being swept away by water.

Popular articles
Woolworths loses R1.1 billion as its Australian business continues to tank

Woolworths loses R1.1 billion as its Australian business continues to tank

The company is compelling CEO Ian Moir to move to Australia to fix things. Bruce Whitfield interviews him.