It's not possible for media to report neutrally, says political analyst

Should journalists, broadcasters, commentators and analysts disclose their political allegiances or should they strive for neutrality?

Presenter Eusebius McKaiser hosted a discussion with commentator JJ Tabane and political analyst Vukani Mde in light of the upcoming general elections.

Read: It's time media treat EFF with more sceptical distance, says journalism prof

Tabane says media practitioners are undeniably imbued with politics but some media jobs (such as reporting) require individual's to separate their political preferences from their work.

In the media space, there are people who are there to report news and people who are there to generate opinion or provoke debate.

JJ Tabane, broadcaster, columnist and commentator

Also read: Sanef: We can't live in a country where journalists are threatened into silence

Mde dismisses the idea of neutrality in journalism and believes that news coverage/selection and reporting is in itself a political exercise.

People who pretend like they don't have political convictions or a politicised identity do so for dishonest reasons.

Vukani Mde, political analyst

Even when we report, and report the facts, that in itself is a political act and an ideologically driven job.

Vukani Mde, political analyst

It's not possible to report neutrally or in a way that is ideologically or politically clean.

Vukani Mde, political analyst

Both guests revealed that they would vote for the ANC in this year's elections and explored the role of the media fraternity in navigating political discourse.

Listen to the engaging debate on The Eusebius McKaiser Show:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : It's not possible for media to report neutrally, says political analyst


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Key advice on how to be more productive at work

Key advice on how to be more productive at work

It's not an achievement to exhaust yourself or spend hours of overtime constantly in "crisis mode", says HR guru Lizette Bester.

Top reasons why Tito Mboweni's Budget will be one of SA's toughest to date

Top reasons why Tito Mboweni's Budget will be one of SA's toughest to date

Finance Minister Tito Mboweni will on Wednesday present what’s being dubbed the most difficult Budget speech in the past decade.

'Netflorist ad shouldn't be banned, but it's a piss-poor example of creativity'

'Netflorist ad shouldn't be banned, but it's a piss-poor example of creativity'

Show host Eusebius McKaiser discusses the Netflorist ad which won an advertising standards case about using racial stereotypes.

Watching 'Peppa Pig' improved my son's English, SA dad says

Watching 'Peppa Pig' improved my son's English, SA dad says

The Pan South African Language Board warns parents to take note of their role in defining language and accent in a child's life.

Black gay men can be misogynists, and here's what a few have to say about it

Black gay men can be misogynists, and here's what a few have to say about it

Presenter Eusebius McKaiser hosted a panel discussion with black gay men exploring entrenched patriarchy and the dynamics at play.

 Caller tells Eusebius how he froze seeing a woman being hit outside a club

Caller tells Eusebius how he froze seeing a woman being hit outside a club

Eusebius McKaiser and a caller discuss scourge of domestic violence in SA and what should happen when one witnesses abuse.

Popular articles
Mboweni will have to make tough political choices in Budget 2019 - economist

Mboweni will have to make tough political choices in Budget 2019 - economist

Minister of Finance Tito Mboweni is due to deliver his annual Budget Speech in Parliament on Wednesday.

Caster Semenya calls out IAAF for publicising expert witness list

Caster Semenya calls out IAAF for publicising expert witness list

Olympic champ Caster Semenya is challenging proposed IAAF rules that may force her to lower her testosterone levels.

'Parliament should have proper inquiry into Mkhwebane's fitness to hold office'

'Parliament should have proper inquiry into Mkhwebane's fitness to hold office'

DA's John Steenhuisen says Parliament should investigate the public protector after the findings against her.

I had nothing to do with VBS - Florence Radzilani

I had nothing to do with VBS - Florence Radzilani

Vhembe District former mayor Florence Radzilani says the Provincial Forensic Investigation exonerated her from the VBS scandal.

Pule Mabe was never alone in hotel room with assistant - ANC NEC's Sdumo Dlamini

Pule Mabe was never alone in hotel room with assistant - ANC NEC's Sdumo Dlamini

ANC's Sdumo Dlamini says party spokesperson Pule Mabe free to return to work after he being cleared of sexual harassment charges.

Black gay men can be misogynists, and here's what a few have to say about it

Black gay men can be misogynists, and here's what a few have to say about it

Presenter Eusebius McKaiser hosted a panel discussion with black gay men exploring entrenched patriarchy and the dynamics at play.

[WATCH] Owner catches car thief off guard and thwarts vehicle theft in Springs

[WATCH] Owner catches car thief off guard and thwarts vehicle theft in Springs

The vehicle's owner came out of the store just in time to scare away the man attempting to steal his bakkie.

Johannesburg’s drive to create a smart city is rolling out

Johannesburg’s drive to create a smart city is rolling out

Vumatel is deploying 15 000 CCTV security cameras over the next five years to make Joburg's streets safer.