DA fights Ramaphosa in ConCourt to have him explain Cabinet moves

President Cyril Ramaphosa and the DA are in the Constitutional Court battling over a court ruling that could be used to force Ramaphosa to disclose his reasons for a Cabinet reshuffle.

The ConCourt will hear arguments about whether the president should give reasons to the public for his executive decisions.

Ramaphosa is challenging a High Court judgment in 2017 ordering that records of top decisions of the Executive should be made available if they are taken on review.

The case stems from the ruling which found former President Jacob Zuma should have provided reasons for sacking Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan.

Constitutional law expert Phephelaphi Dube says the ConCourt is going to be forced to make a fine balancing act.

Dube says the court will have to respect the demands of the rule of law while also acknowledging the separation of powers.

She says that the courts will have to use a rationality test to establish whether the reasons given by a sitting president are rational.

These kinds of questions have never been faced by the ConCourt before.

Phephelaphi Dube, Constitutional law expert

The rule of law demands that there shouldn't be any unaccountable exercise of public power.

Phephelaphi Dube, Constitutional law expert

Listen to the analysis on The Xolani Gwala Show:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : DA fights Ramaphosa in ConCourt to have him explain Cabinet moves


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Patricia de Lille hauls DA to court over an apology

Patricia de Lille hauls DA to court over an apology

Veteran politician says she is fighting for her rights.

Ramaphosa in Cairo to discuss Sudan and Libya

Ramaphosa in Cairo to discuss Sudan and Libya

Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi has called on the AU to address the crisis in two North African countries.

ATM party faction wants it deregistered with IEC

ATM party faction wants it deregistered with IEC

ATM secretary-general Thandisizwe Khukula says these claims by party candidate Bonisile Ngqulwana are 'baseless lies.'

 Amcu workers return to work, some share  challenges brought on by strike

Amcu workers return to work, some share challenges brought on by strike

EWN reporter Kgomotso Modise unpacks the conditions that Sibanye employees went through during a five-month-long stayaway.

[UPDATE] KZN floods death toll rises to 32, more rains expected

[UPDATE] KZN floods death toll rises to 32, more rains expected

MEC pleads with employers to be considerate as weather expected to worsen.

Mathunjwa says Amcu will not apologise for five months no-pay strike

Mathunjwa says Amcu will not apologise for five months no-pay strike

Mining journalist Ed Stoddard says union overplayed its hand on the Sibanye strike.

Popular articles
'Reasons Thabo Mbeki couldn't back ANC haven't left yet' suggests Refilwe

'Reasons Thabo Mbeki couldn't back ANC haven't left yet' suggests Refilwe

Former president Thabo Mbeki has come out now and called on citizens to vote for the ANC, after years of silence.

[WATCH] Is it fake or real? A trauma surgeon explains farfetched movie scenes

[WATCH] Is it fake or real? A trauma surgeon explains farfetched movie scenes

Khabazela shares what has kept social media abuzz on What's Gone Viral.

Discovery, OUTsurance, Clientèle Life… Stop! Some brands advertise way too much

Discovery, OUTsurance, Clientèle Life… Stop! Some brands advertise way too much

Do you resent seeing the same TV ads over and over? Bruce Whitfield interviews branding and advertising expert Andy Rice.

Should we care that Malema has joined the Inanda Country Club? analysts discuss

Should we care that Malema has joined the Inanda Country Club? analysts discuss

Eusebius McKaiser facilitates debate on the symbolism of a pro-poor politician joining an elite club that caters for the rich.

[UPDATE] KZN floods death toll rises to 32, more rains expected

[UPDATE] KZN floods death toll rises to 32, more rains expected

MEC pleads with employers to be considerate as weather expected to worsen.

Orphaned gorillas' selfie goes viral

Orphaned gorillas' selfie goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

Transnet staffers involved in alleged corruption worth billions

Transnet staffers involved in alleged corruption worth billions

AmaBhungane senior investigative journalist Susan Comrie provides insights into a City Press exposé over the weekend.