We are far from being alright - economist

During the 2018 Budget Speech, former finance minister Malusi Gigaba quoted rapper Kendrick Lamar that "We gonna be alright".

Twelve months later as the country is looking forward to minister Tito Mboweni's Budget Speech, economist Mike Schussler says 'we are definitely not alright' as South Africans discover how deep the country's problems go.

Read: Top reasons why Tito Mboweni's Budget will be one of SA's toughest to date

We are finding out how deep our problems are and it is quite scary.

Mike Schussler, Chief Economist - Economists.co.za

Schussler says if the minister only had to balance the sheets to deal with a slow economy it might not be so bad, but he still has Eskom to deal with.

Our revenue and taxes are going to increase quicker than inflation where our expenditure (education, grants) will increase slower than inflation and we will feel the pinch.

Mike Schussler, Chief Economist - Economists.co.za

Apart from all those difficulties, he is being given the Eskom problem and we don't know what he is really going to do.

Mike Schussler, Chief Economist - Economists.co.za

Schussler says he is quite sure that SAA and Eskom will receive money from the government but the question is how much.

Lebohang Pheko, senior research fellow and political economist at Trade Collective agrees with the notion that this is going to be the most difficult budget speech since the dawn of democracy in 1994.

She says the fact that it is an election year changes the dynamics because the minister has to bear in mind that he is not just speaking to taxpayers but also a potential electorate.

She argues that the events of the past twelve months make it difficult for Mboweni to balance all of these considerations.

Against this backdrop, the finance minister not only has to play this balancing act trying to make the rating agency happy but also he has to deal with the education system that is at a state of implosion at the moment.

Lebohang Pheko, Political economist - Trade Collective

We do have to find money for fees, solve the NSFAS situation, public sector wage bill. And that's not just about the high end. We still have teachers that need to be paid adequately, nurses, police officers, government doctors and so on.

Lebohang Pheko, Political economist - Trade Collective

They are the backbone, the heart, and soul of the public sector...

Lebohang Pheko, Political economist - Trade Collective

Pheko says it is going to be impossible for the minister to cut spending, and increase revenue without overburdening and upsetting voters.

Mike Shingange, first deputy president of Cosatu says it is expecting a budget speech that will not threaten the well-being of the workers.

He says there was no mention of privatisation of the state-owned entities during the State of the Nation Address and it would be surprising if the finance minister goes that route.

Last year the president convened both the job summit and investor summit and Treasury will have to present a mission and plan to implement those commitments.

Mike Shingange, First deputy president - Cosatu

The Auditor General said that every year we are losing 10% of the national, provincial and local budget through the looting and if you stop that looting of the 10% without raising tax we can save above 100 billion in order to deliver services to our people. These are the things we thought the minister would address.

Mike Shingange, First deputy president - Cosatu

To hear the rest of the conversations on the Budget Speech, listen below:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Find out how the budget is put together...from a former Treasury insider

Find out how the budget is put together...from a former Treasury insider

Former Treasury DDG and current research associate at UCT School of Economics Andrew Donaldson has some useful insights.

Top reasons why Tito Mboweni's Budget will be one of SA's toughest to date

Top reasons why Tito Mboweni's Budget will be one of SA's toughest to date

Finance Minister Tito Mboweni will on Wednesday present what’s being dubbed the most difficult Budget speech in the past decade.

'The budget won't be imbalanced, it will be as predicted last October'

'The budget won't be imbalanced, it will be as predicted last October'

Standard Bank chief economist Goolam Ballim weighs in on what to expect from Tito Mboweni's budget speech on Wednesday.

It's going to be a compromised budget this year, says Bruce Whitfield

It's going to be a compromised budget this year, says Bruce Whitfield

The Money Show host Bruce Whitfield says Tito Mboweni has really tough decisions to make when he delivers his budget speech.

Mboweni will have to make tough political choices in Budget 2019 - economist

Mboweni will have to make tough political choices in Budget 2019 - economist

Minister of Finance Tito Mboweni is due to deliver his annual Budget Speech in Parliament on Wednesday.

South Africa just became the world’s hottest destination for oil exploration

South Africa just became the world’s hottest destination for oil exploration

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Stephen Larkin, CEO at Africa New Energies.

[LISTEN] As a matter of fact: A look at the #2019 SONA

[LISTEN] As a matter of fact: A look at the #2019 SONA

Senior Researcher Kate Wilkinson says the statistics mentioned in President Cyril Ramaphosa's speech were mostly correct.

Sona 2019 needs to present 'more rooted and practical plans', says pundit

Sona 2019 needs to present 'more rooted and practical plans', says pundit

Pundits give examples of what they expect to come out of the State of the Nation Address this evening.

'If anyone has an LV bag, grab it, see if there is cash or pieces of chicken'

'If anyone has an LV bag, grab it, see if there is cash or pieces of chicken'

Eusebius McKaiser and callers share what their expectations for the State of the Nation Address.

Parly says Sona budget cut by almost 74% and its all systems go

Parly says Sona budget cut by almost 74% and its all systems go

Parliament spokesperson Moloto Mothapo says they are ready to host the Sona and this year it will cost less.

Popular articles
Eskom has 30 days to respond to our demands - EFF

Eskom has 30 days to respond to our demands - EFF

EFF leader Julius Malema handed over a memorandum to CEO Andre de Ruyter after a march to the Eskom headquarters in Sunninghill.

BE WARNED: Heavy traffic set to hit Nasrec on Saturday due to derby, festival

BE WARNED: Heavy traffic set to hit Nasrec on Saturday due to derby, festival

Johannesburg Metro Police's Wayne Minnar suggests alternate routes for music festival goers and soccer fans.

'SA is certainly one of best prepared countries in our region for coronavirus'

'SA is certainly one of best prepared countries in our region for coronavirus'

South African Health Products Authority chairperson Helen Rees they have done their best to train healthcare professionals.

EFF reach Megwatt Park despite heavy downpours

EFF reach Megwatt Park despite heavy downpours

Eyewitness News Edwin Ntshidi says members of the Economic Freedom Fighters were to hand over their memorandum.

[VIDEOs] Heavy rains cause havoc on roads

[VIDEOs] Heavy rains cause havoc on roads

Motorists share videos on Twitter about heavy traffic and floods on the roads.

[WATCH] The Soil back in studio and working on new music

[WATCH] The Soil back in studio and working on new music

Two members of the group joined Azania Mosaka for this week's 702 Unplugged ahead of their concert at Silverstar Casino Ballroom.

Pearl Thusi: The fact that we are in charge of the narrative is very important

Pearl Thusi: The fact that we are in charge of the narrative is very important

The actress says what is really powerful for her about the new show 'Queen Sono' is that the entire ark is driven by women.

SA citizens repatriation: 'We have no idea when Wuhan lockdown will be lifted'

SA citizens repatriation: 'We have no idea when Wuhan lockdown will be lifted'

Department of Health acting director-general Dr Anban Pillay explains why it was necessary to have South Africans returned.

Mandisa Mashego cagey on her talks with EFF leadership over 'internal matters'

Mandisa Mashego cagey on her talks with EFF leadership over 'internal matters'

The Economic Freedom Fighters’ (EFF) Gauteng chairperson Mandisa Mashego was reacting reports and speculation that she had recently resigned as the party's Gauteng chairperson over tensions within the party.

 Adam Catzavelos hit with R50k fine for racist remarks

Adam Catzavelos hit with R50k fine for racist remarks

Should he commit another crimen injuria crime, Catzavelos would need to pay the fine or go to jail.