2019 South African general election: Analysis and News

[LISTEN] As a Matter of Fact: Fact checking the EFF's 2019 elections manifesto

The Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) launched its 2019 elections manifesto last month with three claims about school dropout rates, unemployment and land redistribution.

But it seems two of the claims are incorrect.

Researcher at Africa Check Cayley Clifford joined Azania Mosaka to unpack the claims.

READ: An in-depth look at the EFF manifesto and whether its feasible or not

ALSO READ: EFF election manifesto - callers share their views on what it means to them

Clifford explains that the party's claim that SA's school dropout rates are among the worst in the world is inaccurate.

She says the Unesco data from 2014 to 2018 shows that South Africa was in the top 50% of 68 countries based on secondary school completion.

In support of their global comparison, the EFF also referred us to a 2011 working paper which Professor Martin Gustafsson was part of and the issue we found is that it is not a global comparison, it looks at 14 countries. The other issue is that it is not the most recent data, it uses data from 2003 to 2009.

Cayley Clifford, Africa Check - Researcher

There are different ways to measure school dropout rates. Education panelists generally use and accept Unesco's definition which looks at the proportion of students who are enrolled in a school in a given year, who are then not enrolled in the next year. Alternatively you can look at general household surveys.

Cayley Clifford, Africa Check - Researcher

Clifford also says that the claim that the government has bought less than 7% of the land initially meant for redistribution since 1994 is incorrect.

She says data shows that it has bought a third – or 8.2 million hectares – of the land.

They referred us to a 2016 report on land reform and this was commissioned by a high level panel assessing different pieces of legislation that have come into effect since 1994, one of them being land reform.

Cayley Clifford, Africa Check - Researcher

We have a total estimation of a 122 million hectares of land in South Africa, and 6.7% of this is what the government has bought so while it is correct to say government has bought less than 7% of South Africa's total land it is incorrect to say they have bought less than 7% of the original targeted land because we see that figure - 8.2 million hectares is actually 33% of what was originally targeted.

Cayley Clifford, Africa Check - Researcher

Click on the link below to hear more from Clifford...


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
It is crucial that Cyril Ramaphosa prioritises implementation - economist

It is crucial that Cyril Ramaphosa prioritises implementation - economist

Intellidex's Peter Attard Montalto says the president needs to follow through with all his promises.

'It is clear that electorate is giving us serious consideration' - EFF

'It is clear that electorate is giving us serious consideration' - EFF

Post-election, national chairperson advocate Dali Mpofu evaluates the party's gains.

Gigaba, Dlamini and Mokonyane heading to Parliament despite outcry

Gigaba, Dlamini and Mokonyane heading to Parliament despite outcry

Political analyst Nompumelelo Runji says these people have support from their constituencies.

MPs to be sworn in next week as chief justice receives candidate lists

MPs to be sworn in next week as chief justice receives candidate lists

Eyewitness News reporter Ayanda Nyathi shares details on the process leading up to the first sitting of the National Assembly.

[LISTEN] An in-depth look at the EFF manifesto and whether its feasible or not

[LISTEN] An in-depth look at the EFF manifesto and whether its feasible or not

Eusebius McKaiser facilitated a discussion with political analysts Sithembile Mbete and Sizwe Mpofu-Walsh about the EFF manifesto.

EFF supporters 'ate out of Malema's palm' during manifesto launch  - analyst

EFF supporters 'ate out of Malema's palm' during manifesto launch - analyst

Political analyst Professor Lesiba Tefo analyses the EFF manifesto launch.

Popular articles
Game of Thrones fans demand a remake of Season 8

Game of Thrones fans demand a remake of Season 8

The petition describes Benioff and Weiss as woefully incompetent writers and calls for a better ending for the show.

Gigaba, Dlamini and Mokonyane heading to Parliament despite outcry

Gigaba, Dlamini and Mokonyane heading to Parliament despite outcry

Political analyst Nompumelelo Runji says these people have support from their constituencies.

Absa is the most complained about bank in South Africa

Absa is the most complained about bank in South Africa

Capitec Bank, however, is keeping its customers decidedly happy. Bruce Whitfield interviews consumer journalist Wendy Knowler.

8 tips and tricks to cut your cost of living

8 tips and tricks to cut your cost of living

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Warren Ingram, a personal financial advisor at Galileo Capital.