Muting R.Kelly, Michael Jackson and co makes no ethical impact, pundit argues

Cancelling your support for an artist implicated in sexual abuse allegations makes zero ethical difference to the world and does nothing for victims.

So says commentator, critical thinking and ethics lecturer Jacques Rousseau‏.

Rousseau‏ says that muting artists such as R. Kelly and Michael Jackson, who have been accused of being sexual predators, cannot eliminate their influence on history and music.

He maintains that there is no ethical or moral argument for social media's so-called "cancel culture", where artists are written off for shady behaviour.

The danger of "cancel culture" is that it can tread on the side of performance, Rousseau‏ explains.

He says expressing disapproval for an artist can be achieved while still consuming their work.

Rousseau‏ adds that those who mute or "cancel" artist should not be selective in their outrage and disgust towards certain creative icons.

The artistic genius and the work can be assessed as stand-alone.

Jacques Rousseau‏, critical thinking and ethics lecturer - UCT

Michael Jackson's traces and impact are immeasurable. You can't eliminate that from history but there is great discomfort in listening to that music today.

Jacques Rousseau‏, critical thinking and ethics lecturer - UCT

I don't think I can do anything for the victims of Michael Jackson or any future victims by not listening to his music. It makes zero ethical difference to the world.

Jacques Rousseau‏, critical thinking and ethics lecturer - UCT

I don't see the ethical argument for not listening, I see the emotional argument for not listening.

Jacques Rousseau‏, critical thinking and ethics lecturer - UCT

Listen to the discussion on The Eusebius McKaiser Show:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
[LISTEN] Polyamory 101: 'It's more about emotional intimacy'

[LISTEN] Polyamory 101: 'It's more about emotional intimacy'

In the next few weeks, Dr Eve will be discussing the concept of polyamory and sharing ideas.

'Despite her battles, Nina Simone had a likeness of touch in her musicality'

'Despite her battles, Nina Simone had a likeness of touch in her musicality'

Eusebius McKaiser and Percy Mabandu discuss the life and times of the legendary musician.

 How easy would it be for Mampintsha to succeed with a counter charge?

How easy would it be for Mampintsha to succeed with a counter charge?

The musican is said to be pursuing a counter assault charge against gqom artist Bongekile 'Babes Wodumo' Semilane.

Mampintsha granted bail of R 2 000, no record of counter charge

Mampintsha granted bail of R 2 000, no record of counter charge

The musician was arrested on suspicion of assaulting his girlfriend and gqom artist Bongekile 'Babes Wodumo' Simelane on Sunday.

[SA EXCLUSIVE] Singer Sparkle opens up about R Kelly sex abuse claims

[SA EXCLUSIVE] Singer Sparkle opens up about R Kelly sex abuse claims

CapeTalk presenter Sara-Jayne King talks to Sparkle about the R Kelly documentary and her relationship with the R&B star.

"If you are a black girl, nobody's going to listen to you." #SurvivingRKelly

"If you are a black girl, nobody's going to listen to you." #SurvivingRKelly

Abuse survivor Rosie Motene shares her thoughts on the docuseries Surviving R Kelly which explores sex claims against the singer.

Popular articles
Earn R4500+ per month by renting out your car to Uber drivers

Earn R4500+ per month by renting out your car to Uber drivers

Flexclub pays you to rent out a car you don’t use to Uber drivers struggling to obtain finance, says cofounder Tinashe Ruzane.

[WATCH] 'Come to my house, I want you to make me pregnant quickly', goes viral

[WATCH] 'Come to my house, I want you to make me pregnant quickly', goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

'Appointing Bathabile Dlamini is Sisulu's act of defiance against the president'

'Appointing Bathabile Dlamini is Sisulu's act of defiance against the president'

Mail & Guardian investigative journalist Sabelo Skiti reflects on the infighting between factions in the ruling party.

RMB Holdings ends SA’s 'most successful entrepreneurial venture in 40 years'

RMB Holdings ends SA’s 'most successful entrepreneurial venture in 40 years'

RMB Holdings will dole out its shares in FirstRand, South Africa’s largest financial institution, says Chris Logan.

We paid before the family arrived with the body – Old Mutual

We paid before the family arrived with the body – Old Mutual

Consumer journalist Wendy Knowler investigates after a poor family’s desperation to get a claim paid made headlines.

[WATCH] Group of people protect heavily pregnant woman after she was assaulted

[WATCH] Group of people protect heavily pregnant woman after she was assaulted

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

[WATCH] SABC reporter heading for danger during looting goes viral

[WATCH] SABC reporter heading for danger during looting goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

4 things you should never say if you want to get rich

4 things you should never say if you want to get rich

Don’t ever say or, worse, believe any of these wealth-destroying platitudes, implores personal finance expert Warren Ingram.