Malema's comments do not constitute hate speech - SAHRC

The South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) has found that comments made by EFF leader Julius Malema about race do not legally qualify as hate speech.

Senior Legal Officer at SAHRC, Osmond Mngomezulu says there were four complaints against Malema and one against an EFF party member since 2016.

Each complaint was considered separately on its owns merit, he says.

The tricky part is that we are dealing with constitutional rights. We have a right to dignity, the right to equality as well as the right to freedom of expression.

Osmond Mngomezulu, Senior Legal Officer - SAHRC

Where one's expression may have effects on someone's dignity and equality, those are the kinds of balances that courts, including the commission, constantly have to strike a balance on based on the facts available.

Osmond Mngomezulu, Senior Legal Officer - SAHRC

In this context, we could not find whether there was hate speech so we are releasing the findings based on the complaints lodged as well what the law says.

Osmond Mngomezulu, Senior Legal Officer - SAHRC

Mngomezulu says if the complainants are not happy with the findings, the decisions of the commission are reviewable in the court of law.

To hear the rest of the conversation, listen below:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Chinese community take 11 accused of anti-Chinese hate speech to Equality Court

Chinese community take 11 accused of anti-Chinese hate speech to Equality Court

Gauteng Chinese Association demands an unconditional apology from 11 individuals who posted anti-Chinese slurs on Facebook.

'I left Australia for SA so that my sons can practice their religion in freedom'

'I left Australia for SA so that my sons can practice their religion in freedom'

A Muslim mom and former community spokesperson - now living in SA - recounts the deep-rooted history of Islamophobia in Australia.

To ban the old SA flag or not - a debate

To ban the old SA flag or not - a debate

AfriForum's Ernst Roets and the Nelson Mandela Foundation's Sello Hatang debate this contentious issue.

Why did Jussie Smollet fake his own attack? Eusebius and listeners weigh in

Why did Jussie Smollet fake his own attack? Eusebius and listeners weigh in

Eusebius McKaiser facilitates a debate on whether or not American actor Jussie Smollet faked his own attack.

Social media hate slowly encroaching on radio, says journalism prof

Social media hate slowly encroaching on radio, says journalism prof

To mark World Radio Day, Professor George Claassen reflects on the power of radio programming and its role in promoting dialogue.

[LISTEN] Journalist Karima Brown lays charge of intimidation against EFF member

[LISTEN] Journalist Karima Brown lays charge of intimidation against EFF member

Brown says an EFF member sent a text stating that she is on a list of journalists who've been labelled an enemy of the party.

Eusebius asks, 'What is the best way to deal with a character like Mngxitama?'

Eusebius asks, 'What is the best way to deal with a character like Mngxitama?'

Andile Mngxitama and BLF came under fire for hate speech at a rally over the weekend, threatening to kill whites.

Popular articles
 Jacob Zuma back in court today, lawyer plans isiZulu opening statement

Jacob Zuma back in court today, lawyer plans isiZulu opening statement

Tiso Black Star specialist reporter Karyn Maughan discusses the former president's permanent stay of prosecution application.

'Driving licence backlog whittled down to about 30 000 nationally'

'Driving licence backlog whittled down to about 30 000 nationally'

Western Cape Transport MEC, Donald Grant, says there is progress in renewals which stood at about 200 000 two months ago.

Egypt Blast: This was an isolated incident and has been contained - Dirco

Egypt Blast: This was an isolated incident and has been contained - Dirco

The spokesperson Ndivhuwo Mabaya says three injured South Africans are stable in hospital and the 25 others are back home.

'History of contempt and pity runs through 100 years of research at SU'

'History of contempt and pity runs through 100 years of research at SU'

Stellenbosch University's Professor Jonathan Jansen describes universities' research history of racial tropes over past 100 years.

'It is very clear that Ramaphosa is under attack from Magashule and others'

'It is very clear that Ramaphosa is under attack from Magashule and others'

News24 editor-in-chief Adriaan Basson says there is a definite fight back from the ANC secretary-general against the president.

[UPDATE] Kind-hearted listeners ensure murdered security guard receives burial

[UPDATE] Kind-hearted listeners ensure murdered security guard receives burial

Ernest Kanzi's family will take his body back to the Eastern Cape on Thursday thanks to the generosity of Clint Beech and others.

Schwarzenegger urges public not to give Sandton 'fan' the attention he craves

Schwarzenegger urges public not to give Sandton 'fan' the attention he craves

A video of a young man kicking actor and former US governor Arnold Schwarzenegger in the back on Saturday in Joburg went viral.