'All xenophobic attacks of this kind are inherently criminal' says Eusebius

International Relations Minister Lindiwe Sisulu has called the attacks on foreign nationals criminal and not xenophobic.

Sisulu and Police Minister Bheki Cele met with the ambassadors of African countries in Pretoria on Monday to discuss last week's attacks on foreign nationals in KwaZulu-Natal.

Read: Xenophobic attacks 'related to careless remarks by SA political leaders'

Show host Eusebius McKaiser says he disagrees with the minister's stance.

Firstly, how much research has the government done to try and understand what the motivations were behind these most recent attacks to be able to rule out Afrophobic or xenophobic motives behind them.

Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter

Secondly, the two are not mutually exclusive. All xenophobic attacks of this kind are inherently criminal. The question is not whether they are criminal but whether they are also accompanied by and motivated by xenophobic sentiment.

Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter

That is very important so that you can intervene properly, knowing what it is that you are intervening in. If you say it is sheer criminality, then in a sense you are in denial about what some of the underlying drivers are and what the phenomenon is that you need to tackle here politically.

Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter

Calling it criminality is the first step, but you cannot stop there. I mean that is entirely unacceptable.

Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter

He adds that for the minister to acknowledge that these attacks are xenophobic, is to recognise that the fundamental political and international legal obligations that South Africa has towards citizens from other countries are not being taken seriously by the current government.

There is an international law interest and there is also a geopolitical interest in the minister reducing the description of what is going on here, which is why she is restricting herself to a description of criminality.

Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter

Quite frankly minister, that is utterly irresponsible. It is insensitive and we have to be clear about the reality of what you are dealing with.

Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter

Callers also weighed in on the minister's stance, and Keneilwe says she does not believe that South Africans are xenophobic.

Whether it is the minority or the marginalised women and children, I would rather have a focus on policy that strengthens the law, strengthens the capacity of the police - because I would question the agenda of painting South Africans as xenophobic.

Keneilwe, Caller

Diamond also called in and says the attacks on foreign nationals in Durban are xenophobic.

The issue is that politicians come in and say reckless comments which instil violence in the communities.

Diamond, Caller

Zaine says these attacks are more Afrophobia than they are xenophobic and people need to look at what the drivers of these attacks are.

Part of the problem is that we have public representatives and politicians that say things in public spaces that add fuel to the fire instead of actually trying to deal with the problem.

Zaine, Caller

Watch below as Eusebius shares his views:

Listen below to the full #702openline:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Xenophobic attacks 'related to careless remarks by SA political leaders'

Xenophobic attacks 'related to careless remarks by SA political leaders'

Zambian High Commissioner to South Africa Emmanuel Mwamba will meet with Sisulu and Cele after recent xenophobic attacks.

No confirmation of any South Africans killed in Christchurch mosque shooting

No confirmation of any South Africans killed in Christchurch mosque shooting

SA High Commissioner in NZ Vuyiswa Tulelo says the foreign ministry in NZ is still in the process of identifying people.

Hawks bust Cape Town immigration lawyer on charges of fraud and forgery

Hawks bust Cape Town immigration lawyer on charges of fraud and forgery

Craig Smith, his wife, and their employee were arrested on Monday for allegedly aiding clients to obtain fraudulent documentation.

Makhura's remarks on foreign nationals is abhorrent and shocking says Eusebius

Makhura's remarks on foreign nationals is abhorrent and shocking says Eusebius

Eusebius McKaiser facilitates a debate between callers on xenophobia and what David Makhura had to say about foreign nationals.

Dirco: SA accepts corruption issues raised but foreign countries broke protocol

Dirco: SA accepts corruption issues raised but foreign countries broke protocol

Department of International Relations and Cooperation's Ndivhuwo Mabaya says the message was not sent in the correct manner.

It has been easier this year! - Lesetja Kganyago on Team SA at the WEF in Davos

It has been easier this year! - Lesetja Kganyago on Team SA at the WEF in Davos

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Lesetja Kganyago, Governor of the South African Reserve Bank.

The public can have a say on how foreign nationals' employment should work

The public can have a say on how foreign nationals' employment should work

The regulations will include proposals affecting the applications of all work visas and the submissions of skills transfer plans.

Foreign nationals forcibly removed from RDP houses by locals in Alex

Foreign nationals forcibly removed from RDP houses by locals in Alex

Gauteng MEC of Community Safety Sizakele Nkosi-Malobane says they are looking into the matter.

[LISTEN] 'Governing Gauteng is not like governing any other province' - Makhura

[LISTEN] 'Governing Gauteng is not like governing any other province' - Makhura

Gauteng Premier David Makhura discusses his political report in more detail, as well as the pressures of governing the province.

[OPINION] The ethical vulgarity of the insurance industry

[OPINION] The ethical vulgarity of the insurance industry

Andiswa Makanda says the recent refusal by Momentum to pay a claim brings to the fore normative business issues of the insurance industry and the polarisation of what constitutes right and wrong.

'Erdogan is leaving the door open for the Saudi's to come clean'

'Erdogan is leaving the door open for the Saudi's to come clean'

Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan says the murder of Saudi Arabian journalist, Jamal Khashoggi was planned.

'No country in the world can allow its borders to be a free for all'

'No country in the world can allow its borders to be a free for all'

DA spokesperson on immigration for the elections Jacques Julius says the party plans to tackle undocumented immigrants.

Cope's Lekota calls for refugee camps in SA, says they're NOT xenophobic

Cope's Lekota calls for refugee camps in SA, says they're NOT xenophobic

Congress of the People (Cope) president Mosiuoa Lekota says the ANC government is allowing foreigners to flood SA.

Jacqueline Tizora questions SA's silence on Zimbabwe's shutdown

Jacqueline Tizora questions SA's silence on Zimbabwe's shutdown

Tizora has raised concern about the lack of support from some South Africans, citing the long standing problem of afrophobia.

Xeno violence 132 convicts, Angola big African spender, dumping bylaws looked at

Xeno violence 132 convicts, Angola big African spender, dumping bylaws looked at

Round up of the day's talkers

Meet Johann Redelinghuys, a man hell-bent on ending retirement (as we know it)

Meet Johann Redelinghuys, a man hell-bent on ending retirement (as we know it)

“Why try and make retirement more palatable? Why not just abolish it completely?” says headhunter Johann Redelinghuys.

Xenophobia: How South Africa got here

Xenophobia: How South Africa got here

A brief history and context of xenophobia in South Africa, from 2008 to the most recent incidents.

Xenophobic-Afrophobic showdown between Durban and the Joburg CBD

Xenophobic-Afrophobic showdown between Durban and the Joburg CBD

The Midday Report - where you won't miss a thing

Popular articles
[BREAKING NEWS] Johnny Clegg (66) has passed away

[BREAKING NEWS] Johnny Clegg (66) has passed away

Specialists diagnosed the singer with pancreatic cancer in 2015.

Investigators find serious corruption at EOH

Investigators find serious corruption at EOH

A probe found "suspicious transactions" worth R1.2bn, bribery and theft. Bruce Whitfield interviews EOH CEO Stephen Van Coller.

'Thomas Stringfellow lost the money I got when my wife and baby died'

'Thomas Stringfellow lost the money I got when my wife and baby died'

"There’s a 91-year-old. There are people in the hospital who rely on this money to survive," says scam victim Laurence Upton.

'Batchelor was once close to Mikey Schultz and self-confessed Kebble killers'

'Batchelor was once close to Mikey Schultz and self-confessed Kebble killers'

Journalist and author Mandy Wiener describes former footballer Marc Batchelor's links to alleged underworld figures.

Capitec Bank has the strongest brand of any company in South Africa

Capitec Bank has the strongest brand of any company in South Africa

Castle Lager came in second, followed by FNB, Black Label, Discovery and Vodacom, according to the 2019 Brand Finance report.

3 best JSE and offshore shares to buy, right now (by Anchor Capital)

3 best JSE and offshore shares to buy, right now (by Anchor Capital)

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield asks Henry Biddlecombe (an analyst at Anchor Capital) for his stock picks of the week.

Advisor scams pensioners out of R100 million with promises of 14% returns

Advisor scams pensioners out of R100 million with promises of 14% returns

Bruce Whitfield interviews Phillip de Wet (Business Insider), Robert Walton (Boutique Collective Investments) and Brandon Topham.

'I should have told the Sunday Times the pot smoking was irrelevant'

'I should have told the Sunday Times the pot smoking was irrelevant'

Investigative journalist Jacques Pauw says he's sorry for any harm caused in his article on Mkhwebane and her principal witness.

[WATCH] Over 50 artists record special version of Johnny Clegg’s  “The Crossing”

[WATCH] Over 50 artists record special version of Johnny Clegg’s “The Crossing”

For this week's #GoodNewsThursdays, we find out the inspiration behind the production.