'We've seen profit margins of 30% in South Africa'

The Competition Commission of South Africa has slammed the country's most successful cellphone companies for being 'anti-poor'.

Its provisional report on the cost of mobile data found that local prices compare poorly with other Brics and SADC countries, with MTN and Vodacom charging higher prices at home than they do in markets outside South Africa.

Read: Vodacom, MTN charge more for data at home in South Africa than anywhere else

On the Breakfast Show with Kieno Kammies, Commissioner Thembinkosi Bonakele explains how the research was conducted.

We started by asking for information from stakeholders, lots of civil society groups, we asked for information from operators themselves, we used some of the data from Icasa and then we collated some of the data ourselves from other global sources. public hearings on question

Thembinkosi Bonakele, Commissioner - Competition Commission

Bonakele says this was followed by public hearings focused on the question of whether the price of data in South Africa is high.

The answer was a resounding yes, prices are high in South Africa.

Thembinkosi Bonakele, Commissioner - Competition Commission

Bonakele says the Commission was particularly shocked by the fact that these high prices hit the poor the hardest, as they buy smaller bundles of data.

He outlined the dominance of Vodacom and MTN and their high profit margins in the local market.

The likes of Telkom and Cell C have to scramble for customers. partly because their network tends to be poor... This is the outcome of a market that has failed.

Thembinkosi Bonakele, Commissioner - Competition Commission

It's very clear that there are exorbitant prices here and it's leading to very good profits for the incumbents.

Thembinkosi Bonakele, Commissioner - Competition Commission

We've seen profit margins in the order of 30% in South Africa. When you look at comparable countries you see profitability margins of about 12%.

Thembinkosi Bonakele, Commissioner - Competition Commission

Bonakele goes on to evaluate the arguments the big cellphone companies put forward for their high prices in South Africa, like better quality infrastructure and service.

Take a listen:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : 'We've seen profit margins of 30% in South Africa'


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
'Council for Medical Schemes allowing bully-boy tactics'

'Council for Medical Schemes allowing bully-boy tactics'

Dr Fundile Nyathi unpacks the inquiry into allegations of racial profiling of doctors by medical aid schemes.

Is it time for a shake-up in South African politics?

Is it time for a shake-up in South African politics?

Melanie Verwoerd says the country needs inspirational leaders after voters sent a message to the ANC not to take them for granted.

Peppermint Crisp is here to stay

Peppermint Crisp is here to stay

Nestlé's Ayanda Mackay reassures consumers that a twitter rumour about the choc's discontinuation was just a misunderstanding.

Popular articles
Student climate activist challenges Dept of Environmental Affairs

Student climate activist challenges Dept of Environmental Affairs

Raeesah Noor-Mahomed has joined schoolkids around the world by embarking on a Friday school boycott over climate inaction.

Dead wrong! US cops bust driver using carpool lane with fake skeleton passenger

Dead wrong! US cops bust driver using carpool lane with fake skeleton passenger

An Arizona man dressed up a fake skeleton in the back seat to fool the traffic cops, but didn't do a very convincing job.

Meet the inspirational creative duo behind 'Tonic Design'

Meet the inspirational creative duo behind 'Tonic Design'

Greg Gamble and Philippe van der Merwe join Refiloe Mpakanyane in studio.

Fitness was a career that chose me - 'Queen Fitnass'

Fitness was a career that chose me - 'Queen Fitnass'

Mapule Ndhlovu opens up about her life journey and how exercise changed not only her body, but her mindset for the better.

EFF issues one-line apology to journos after court order

EFF issues one-line apology to journos after court order

Anton Harber and Thandeka Gqubule won their defamation case over Mbuyiseni Ndlozi's party statement implying links to Stratcom.

Ugandan climate activist accuses media of racism after Davos photo crop

Ugandan climate activist accuses media of racism after Davos photo crop

WEF youth climate delegate Vanessa Nakate was cropped out of a group pic with her white peers, also featuring Greta Thunberg.

Letting go of your child who's headed for university and independence

Letting go of your child who's headed for university and independence

Nikki Bush has valuable tips on preparing not only your school-leaver but yourself for the journey into adulthood ahead.

Right to Sight pleads for more donations to conduct cataract surgeries

Right to Sight pleads for more donations to conduct cataract surgeries

Right to Sight trustee Dr Matt Young says they get donations at the most time but now need big sponsors.

Remains of Cato Manor 9 returned on anniversary of their hanging

Remains of Cato Manor 9 returned on anniversary of their hanging

The Cato Manor 9 were hanged in 1961 by the apartheid after taking part in an uprising on 24 January 1960.

Zakes Bantwini opens up about his latest single 'Amanga'

Zakes Bantwini opens up about his latest single 'Amanga'

The musician says he never writes songs about his personal life but this latest single is too personal for him.