Streaming issues? Report here
money-show-thumbnailjpg money-show-thumbnailjpg
The Money Show with Bruce Whitfield
18:00 - 20:00
volume_up
volume_mute

Up Next: The Aubrey Masango Show
See full line-up
The Money Show with Bruce Whitfield
18:00 - 20:00
Home
arrow_forward
Sport
fiber_manual_record
Politics

Caster ruling: 'They recognised the discrimination, but felt it necessary'

2 May 2019 8:38 AM
Tags:
Caster Semenya
IAAF
Court of Arbitration for Sport
CAS

Sports medicine scientist Dr Shuaib Manjra and UCT Head of Human Biology Professor Malcolm Collins unpacks the judgment.

South African athlete Caster Semenya's challenge against the International Association of Athletics Federations rules forcing her to lower her testosterone levels to compete with women has been rejected.

Read: Caster Semenya on CAS ruling: 'I will once again rise above'

The Court of Arbitration for Sport issued its ruling on Wednesday.

Also read: 'There are no two ways about it, we will appeal this Caster judgment'

It means Semenya will have to take medication to suppress her testosterone if she wants to keep running in certain events on the international stage.

To weigh in on the judgment, Sports medicine scientist Dr Shuaib Manjra speaks to 702's Bongani Bingwa.

The Court of Arbitration for Sport released its findings yesterday, and it was a two-page finding, but there is a 138-page judgment, so we have to read the reasonings and the signs that they have used to conclude the way that they have and then we will get a better understanding.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

They are saying if she wants to compete, then she must fight on an equal footing, and for her to compete on a similar level, she must reduce her testosterone level, so it doesn't give her an unfair advantage. That is the reasoning why they want her to lower her testosterone.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

He says the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) relied on two scientific papers which other scientists around the world argue are deeply flawed.

And that was the evidence that was presented to the Court of Arbitration for Sport, we don't know how the court rates both sets of evidence, but clearly, those two-page findings demonstrated a significant advantage.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

I think the vote was split, it was a two to one vote, it wasn't a unanimous vote, they recognised that there is discrimination, but they felt that the perception was necessary, rational and proportionate to uphold the differences in sports.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

He adds that Semenya has a number of options available.

The one option is to quit running altogether, the second option is to appeal the findings, the third is to use hormonal therapy to reduce her testosterone level, and the fourth one is for her to compete in the 1500m and above.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

Listen below to the full interview:

Head of Human Biology at UCT, Professor Malcolm Collins speaks to CapeTalk's Kieno Kammies about the ruling and the biology behind it.

I am very disappointed with the ruling.

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

Semenya has stated that she has a genetic advantage which is part of elite sport.

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

He says her particular advantage is being discriminated against.

One of the big questions the sports world is trying to unpack is, what determines an elite sports person? And the big debate over the years is, is it nurture or is it nature?

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

He says it has now been established that athletic ability is determined by very complex and poorly understood interaction between the two.

So our genetic makeup does play a very important role in determining whether we will be top contenders in any discipline.

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

Semenya's genetic advantage is undisputed, he says.

She is born with differences in sex development which means she will produce higher levels of testosterone, but high jumpers are born with height...so does this mean every sport will have to be capped with something?

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

He does not believe she has an unfair advantage.

Because that is the nature of sport.

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

Listen to Professor Collins below:


2 May 2019 8:38 AM
Tags:
Caster Semenya
IAAF
Court of Arbitration for Sport
CAS

More from Sport

Irvin Khoza

PSL boss Irvin Khoza confirms first PSL teams to enter bio-bubble

28 July 2020 1:43 PM

On Monday, the League Board of Governors gave the green light for the season to resume from 8 August.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Cricket-ball-sport-123rfjpg

'We need deeper interrogation into corporate governance practices at Cricket SA'

27 July 2020 4:09 PM

Casac's Lawson Naidoo shares why he believes an inquiry is needed into racism and governance problems in cricket.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

sam-mohau-hlonyanajpg

How to stay motivated and exercising during COVID-19 with Sam The Challenger

25 July 2020 11:23 AM

Samuel Hlonyana says the most important thing about the challenge is that it is is not about the sugar but to develop a habit.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

98328860-f164-474e-9acc-1d00ea29782c.jpg

Ralepelle: 'I refuse to be the fall-guy for a corrupt system'

24 July 2020 4:08 PM

Former Sharks and Springbok hooker Chilliboy Ralepelle has vowed to take on the South African Institute for Drug-Free Sport in his appeal against his 8-year ban.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

200723-liverpooljpg

How the internet reacted to Liverpool finally lifting the Premier League trophy

23 July 2020 12:39 PM

Liverpool had mathematically won the Premier League title on 25 June but had to wait almost a month to see Jordan Henderson lift the trophy on the Kop.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

baboojpg

OBITUARY: 'Baboo' Ebrahim - humble master of the art of spin bowling

21 July 2020 2:45 PM

The KZN Cricket Union pays tribute to Ismail 'Baboo' Ebrahim, an orthodox left-arm spin bowler whose influence on the art of spin bowling in the 1960s and 1970s was considerable and unforgettable.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

200720-kaunda-ntunja-edjpg

Kaunda Ntunja hailed as pioneer who inspired others to be commentators

21 July 2020 1:55 PM

Sports writer Sbu Mjikeliso pays tribute to the beloved SuperSport commentator.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

200720-kaunda-ntunja-edjpg

Energy, spice & a new level: Jonathan Mokuena remembers his friend Kaunda Ntunja

21 July 2020 11:20 AM

Beloved and celebrated rugby commentator and former SA Schools captain, Kaunda Ntunja tragically passed away this weekend after a battle with COVID-19.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

pope2jpg

England strikes back to level the series against West Indies

20 July 2020 8:03 PM

The second Test between England and West Indies will be a talking point for a long time to come. It saw the English secure an emphatic win to level the series despite the Old Trafford weather not playing its part.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

200720-kaunda-ntunja-edjpg

Xhosa rugby commentator Kaunda Ntunja dies at 38

20 July 2020 1:05 PM

The tragic news was confirmed by his sister, Tando, on social media on Monday morning.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

More from Politics

Candle Eskom 123rf 123rfbusiness 123rflifestyle

Eskom want its stolen money back – from Koko, Molefe, Singh (etc) and the Guptas

3 August 2020 6:27 PM

The process to recover the looted billions has begun. Bruce Whitfield talks to Steven Powell, Director in Forensics at ENS Africa.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

20200803normagigabaoutsidecourtjfif

This is intimidation, this is a way to silence Norma Gigaba - Advocacy group

3 August 2020 4:40 PM

EWN reporter Veronica Mokhoali says Wise 4 Africa supports Norma amid malicious damage to property and crimen injuria charges.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

20200803normagigabaoutsidecourtjfif

Norma Gigaba's arrest by Hawks 'was done within confines of law'

3 August 2020 1:02 PM

Spokesperson Brigadier Hangwani Mulaudzi explains why his department apprehended her and says nothing was wrong with the action.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

ramaphosa-imbizojpg

'Stop passing on inside information about tenders to families and friends only'

3 August 2020 12:52 PM

President Cyril Ramaphosa pained by 'a businessperson who can inflate the price of a surgical mask by as much as 900%'.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

200728Andrew

'People hoped cadres can put eating tendencies aside and focus on saving lives'

3 August 2020 11:37 AM

Clement Manyathela facilitates a conversation on the governing party's corruption allegations against its members.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

191017-david-mabuza-edjpg

Be assured that Deputy President David Mabuza is at home and well - Presidency

2 August 2020 8:53 PM

The Office of the Deputy President has received numerous calls from concerned South Africans regarding his health status.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

200109john

DA calls for snap debate over 'ANC's COVID feeding frenzy'

2 August 2020 1:34 PM

The last few weeks have seen numerous allegations of corruption leveled against senior party members.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

cyril.jpeg.jpg

'It's unconscionable that people use COVID-19 crisis to enrich themselves'

2 August 2020 10:07 AM

President Cyril Ramaphosa reiterates that they have empowered law-enforcement agencies to probe reports of alleged corruption.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

200801davidgif

Masondo says he called the Hawks to ‘protect his family’

1 August 2020 12:23 PM

Minister Masondo defended his actions to the ANC’s integrity commission on Friday after it recommended that he step down from both his positions in government and within the party.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

200731 Bheki Cele1

Murder, sexual assault and common assault surge as Cele releases crime stats

31 July 2020 1:16 PM

EWN reporter Theto Mahlakoana and ISS's Johan Burger reflect on the recent crime statistics released by the police ministry.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward