Caster ruling: 'They recognised the discrimination, but felt it necessary'

South African athlete Caster Semenya's challenge against the International Association of Athletics Federations rules forcing her to lower her testosterone levels to compete with women has been rejected.

Read: Caster Semenya on CAS ruling: 'I will once again rise above'

The Court of Arbitration for Sport issued its ruling on Wednesday.

Also read: 'There are no two ways about it, we will appeal this Caster judgment'

It means Semenya will have to take medication to suppress her testosterone if she wants to keep running in certain events on the international stage.

To weigh in on the judgment, Sports medicine scientist Dr Shuaib Manjra speaks to 702's Bongani Bingwa.

The Court of Arbitration for Sport released its findings yesterday, and it was a two-page finding, but there is a 138-page judgment, so we have to read the reasonings and the signs that they have used to conclude the way that they have and then we will get a better understanding.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

They are saying if she wants to compete, then she must fight on an equal footing, and for her to compete on a similar level, she must reduce her testosterone level, so it doesn't give her an unfair advantage. That is the reasoning why they want her to lower her testosterone.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

He says the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) relied on two scientific papers which other scientists around the world argue are deeply flawed.

And that was the evidence that was presented to the Court of Arbitration for Sport, we don't know how the court rates both sets of evidence, but clearly, those two-page findings demonstrated a significant advantage.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

I think the vote was split, it was a two to one vote, it wasn't a unanimous vote, they recognised that there is discrimination, but they felt that the perception was necessary, rational and proportionate to uphold the differences in sports.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

He adds that Semenya has a number of options available.

The one option is to quit running altogether, the second option is to appeal the findings, the third is to use hormonal therapy to reduce her testosterone level, and the fourth one is for her to compete in the 1500m and above.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

Listen below to the full interview:

Head of Human Biology at UCT, Professor Malcolm Collins speaks to CapeTalk's Kieno Kammies about the ruling and the biology behind it.

I am very disappointed with the ruling.

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

Semenya has stated that she has a genetic advantage which is part of elite sport.

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

He says her particular advantage is being discriminated against.

One of the big questions the sports world is trying to unpack is, what determines an elite sports person? And the big debate over the years is, is it nurture or is it nature?

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

He says it has now been established that athletic ability is determined by very complex and poorly understood interaction between the two.

So our genetic makeup does play a very important role in determining whether we will be top contenders in any discipline.

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

Semenya's genetic advantage is undisputed, he says.

She is born with differences in sex development which means she will produce higher levels of testosterone, but high jumpers are born with height...so does this mean every sport will have to be capped with something?

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

He does not believe she has an unfair advantage.

Because that is the nature of sport.

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

Listen to Professor Collins below:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Caster Semenya on CAS ruling: 'I will once again rise above'

Caster Semenya on CAS ruling: 'I will once again rise above'

The South Africa Olympian has lost her landmark legal case against the IAAF after the Court of Arbitration for Sport ruled 2-1 in the IAAF’s favour.

'There are no two ways about it, we will appeal this Caster judgment'

'There are no two ways about it, we will appeal this Caster judgment'

Spokesperson Vuyo Mhaga says the sports and recreation ministry is studying Semanya's ruling by the Court of Arbitration.

Caster Semenya loses court challenge against IAAF testosterone rules

Caster Semenya loses court challenge against IAAF testosterone rules

Caster Semenya has been fighting regulations imposed by the International Association of Athletics Federations that compel "hyperandrogenic" athletes - or those with "differences of sexual development" (DSD) - to lower their testosterone levels if they wish to compete as women.

Sports rules are man-made. It's about time we change them, says opinionista

Sports rules are man-made. It's about time we change them, says opinionista

Opinionista Lea Clerets says it's time to rethink the rules of sport and offers some examples of what inclusive competing can be.

UN support for Semenya strengthens human rights argument - legal expert

UN support for Semenya strengthens human rights argument - legal expert

On Thursday the UN's Human Rights Council adopted a South African resolution defending Caster Semenya in IAAF case.

Scientific paper may work in Caster Semenya's favour

Scientific paper may work in Caster Semenya's favour

The paper demonstrates that female middle distance athletes don't have an advantage with increased testosterone.

Trouble in the bedroom? Dr Shingai answers men's sex and baby-making questions

Trouble in the bedroom? Dr Shingai answers men's sex and baby-making questions

Urologist and sexual health guru Dr Shingai Mutambirwa fielded several questions from listeners on sexual and reproductive health.

Caster Semenya calls out IAAF for publicising expert witness list

Caster Semenya calls out IAAF for publicising expert witness list

Olympic champ Caster Semenya is challenging proposed IAAF rules that may force her to lower her testosterone levels.

 Semenya's battle against IAAF puts spotlight on sports categories, says expert

Semenya's battle against IAAF puts spotlight on sports categories, says expert

The Olympic 800 metres champion is challenging proposed IAAF rules that could force her to lower her testosterone levels.

'No one asked Phelps to cut down his flipper feet'- Caller #HandsOffCaster

'No one asked Phelps to cut down his flipper feet'- Caller #HandsOffCaster

702/CapeTalk's listeners weigh in on the proposed regulations by the IAAF in support of Caster Semenya.

Messages of support pour in for Caster Semenya in her battle against the IAAF

Messages of support pour in for Caster Semenya in her battle against the IAAF

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

'Semenya is not alone in the battle against IAAF proposed regulations'

'Semenya is not alone in the battle against IAAF proposed regulations'

Dr Phathokuhle Zondi says there are other athletes who are affected by the IAAF proposed regulation to lower testosterone levels.

Motorists and pedestrians urged to steer clear of JHB govt building after fire

Motorists and pedestrians urged to steer clear of JHB govt building after fire

MMC of Public Safety Micheal Sun says while most of the fire has been contained, firefighters are still on scene.

[MUST READ] President Ramaphosa's State of the Nation Address

[MUST READ] President Ramaphosa's State of the Nation Address

President Cyril Ramaphosa is delivering his first State of the Nation Address in the National Assembly.

Bongani Ngqulunga's book reveals untold history of the man who founded the ANC

Bongani Ngqulunga's book reveals untold history of the man who founded the ANC

Pixley Ka Isaka Seme founded the ANC in 1912 when he was 30 years old, but many believe that his story isn't celebrated enough.

Here's what's contributing to the decline in sperm count of men around the world

Here's what's contributing to the decline in sperm count of men around the world

Urologist Dr Shingai Mutambirwa explains that the both sperm count and quality of sperm are important in fertility.

Popular articles
Want to start a small business? Lessons from a successful serial entrepreneur...

Want to start a small business? Lessons from a successful serial entrepreneur...

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Nic Haralambous, founder (at the cost of R5000!) of funky sock company Nic Harry.

Considering emigration? Financial planner discusses the affordability of leaving

Considering emigration? Financial planner discusses the affordability of leaving

Can you afford to leave South Africa? Certified Financial Planner (CFP) Barry O'Mahony on what to consider before deciding.

'SAA’s collapse plays nicely into hands of a politically constrained Ramaphosa'

'SAA’s collapse plays nicely into hands of a politically constrained Ramaphosa'

After dithering for fear of spending political capital, SAA is now out of the President’s hands, says Pieter du Toit (News24).

There is no Ubuntu in how Khanya Cekeshe has been treated - Thuli Madonsela

There is no Ubuntu in how Khanya Cekeshe has been treated - Thuli Madonsela

Former public protector says the eight-year sentence was too harsh and it shouldn't matter that he was not a Wits student.

‘South Africans are getting poorer and poorer because of politics’

‘South Africans are getting poorer and poorer because of politics’

SAA is a classic example, says Isaah Mhlanga, Chief Economist at Alexander Forbes Investments.

[VIDEO] People in amusement park thrown off ride in Thailand goes viral

[VIDEO] People in amusement park thrown off ride in Thailand goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

How to make your first R1 million (after that it just becomes so much easier)

How to make your first R1 million (after that it just becomes so much easier)

Rich. Wealthy. Financially free... Call it what you will; the first million is how you get there. Warren Ingram on his book...